core/docs/safety_packs.md

Safety Packs — Reference

Status: Operational reference. Update when pack format, loader contract, or composition rules change. Last updated: 2026-05-17 Companion docs: decisions/ADR-0029-safety-packs.md, identity_packs.md

What a safety pack is

A safety pack carries the boundaries CORE will never cross, regardless of which identity pack is selected. Where identity packs encode who CORE is, safety packs encode what CORE will not do. The two layers compose at runtime: manifold.boundary_ids = safety.boundary_ids ∪ identity.boundary_ids.

Three properties distinguish safety packs from identity packs:

Property	Identity pack	Safety pack
Swappable at runtime	Yes (--identity X)	No
Multiple packs available	Yes	Exactly one
Failure to load	Falls back to default; warns	Fail-closed; refuses startup
Schema	value_axes, surface_preferences, etc.	boundary_ids, boundary_descriptions
Directory	packs/identity/	packs/safety/

Shipping safety pack (v1)

Pack id	Description	Ratified
core_safety_axes_v1	Always-loaded core boundaries: no fabricated source, no hot-path repair, no identity override, no silent correction, preserve versor closure.	ee1249acdf8c273aeb656d803c37ef915e536d85f177f5cc18c6e2f6c995ce29

Pack format (v1)

{
  "pack_id": "core_safety_axes_v1",
  "version": "1.0.0",
  "description": "Always-loaded, never-replaceable core safety boundaries.",
  "schema_version": "1.0.0",
  "mastery_report_sha256": "...",
  "boundary_ids": [
    "no_fabricated_source",
    "no_hot_path_repair",
    "no_identity_override",
    "no_silent_correction",
    "preserve_versor_closure"
  ],
  "boundary_descriptions": {
    "no_fabricated_source": "Citations must point to a real source span; the system never invents provenance.",
    "no_hot_path_repair": "...",
    "no_identity_override": "...",
    "no_silent_correction": "...",
    "preserve_versor_closure": "..."
  }
}

Field semantics

Field	Required	Meaning
pack_id	yes	Pack identifier. Convention: <slug>_v<major>.
version	yes	Semver.
description	yes	Human-facing one-liner.
schema_version	yes	Currently "1.0.0".
mastery_report_sha256	yes (production)	SHA of the companion <pack_id>.mastery_report.json. Empty only in development; production refuses.
boundary_ids	yes	Non-empty list of unique boundary identifier strings.
boundary_descriptions	yes	Dict mapping each boundary_id to a human-readable rationale.

Loader bounds (enforced)

• boundary_ids must be a non-empty list of unique non-empty strings.
• pack_id must not contain / or ...
• schema_version must equal "1.0.0".
• In production mode (default), mastery_report_sha256 must be non-empty, the companion report must exist, its report_sha256 must match, and its self-seal must verify via formation.hashing.verify_seal.

Loader contract

from packs.safety.loader import load_safety_pack, SafetyPackError, DEFAULT_SAFETY_PACK

pack = load_safety_pack(
    pack_id=DEFAULT_SAFETY_PACK,    # default — callers should rarely pass anything else
    search_paths=None,               # default: ["./packs/safety"]
    require_ratified=True,           # production default
)

Returns a SafetyPack (frozen dataclass) with fields pack_id, version, description, boundary_ids (frozenset), boundary_descriptions (dict), mastery_report_sha256, ratified.

SafetyPackError inherits from RuntimeError, not ValueError. Missing safety pack is a fail-closed runtime condition, not a recoverable input error. Do not catch and continue.

Development override

CORE_ALLOW_UNRATIFIED_SAFETY=1 python -m core.cli chat

Bypasses only the seal-verification check. Missing file / empty boundaries / malformed JSON still fail closed. Use only while authoring or editing the safety pack; never set in production.

Composition rule

At ChatRuntime startup:

identity_manifold = load_identity_manifold(config.identity_pack or DEFAULT_IDENTITY_PACK)
safety_pack       = load_safety_pack()                # fail-closed
final_manifold    = IdentityManifold(
    value_axes        = identity_manifold.value_axes,
    boundary_ids      = identity_manifold.boundary_ids | safety_pack.boundary_ids,
    alignment_threshold = identity_manifold.alignment_threshold,
    surface_preferences = identity_manifold.surface_preferences,
)

Safety contributes boundaries only. Identity contributes axes, threshold, surface preferences, and may add further boundaries. The runtime exposes the loaded safety pack as ChatRuntime.safety_pack for audit.

Authoring a new safety pack

A safety pack is unique to a deployment. The shipping default is core_safety_axes_v1; downstream deployments may author their own stricter pack and place it at packs/safety/<deployment_safety_id>.json.

1. Author the pack JSON. List the boundary ids your deployment requires; supply descriptions explaining each.
2. Run python scripts/ratify_safety_pack.py (idempotent). Produces the companion .mastery_report.json and embeds the SHA in the pack.
3. Test it under fail-closed semantics. Run python -m pytest tests/test_safety_pack.py and verify all 15 tests pass.
4. Commit both files (<pack_id>.json and <pack_id>.mastery_report.json) atomically.

Anti-patterns

• Don't catch SafetyPackError. A missing safety pack should crash the runtime, not silently degrade. The exception class deliberately doesn't inherit from ValueError.
• Don't carry value axes in a safety pack. Safety boundaries are not directional preferences. If you find yourself wanting axes, you want an identity pack.
• Don't make boundary text user-facing without curation. boundary_descriptions is for audit and operator visibility, not end-user prose.
• Don't ship multiple safety packs. The design is "exactly one shipping safety pack per CORE installation." Per-tenant safety packs are an architectural change requiring a future ADR.

Versioning policy

Change	Version bump
Description text edits	Patch (v1.0.0 → v1.0.1)
Adding a boundary	Minor (v1.0.0 → v1.1.0)
Removing a boundary	Major + new ADR justifying the removal (core_safety_axes_v2)
Schema format change	Major + new schema_version

A new major version means a new pack_id. The old pack remains in the repo for replay and audit; the runtime loads whichever pack id is shipped (currently hardcoded in packs.safety.loader.DEFAULT_SAFETY_PACK).

SafetyCheck — structural surface (ADR-0032)

A centralized, observational surface for evaluating safety boundaries at runtime, parallel in shape to IdentityCheck. Produces a SafetyVerdict; does not refuse. Wiring violations into refusal paths is a future ADR.

from packs.safety import SafetyCheck, SafetyContext

check = SafetyCheck()  # ships with default predicates for the five v1 boundaries
ctx = SafetyContext(
    field_state=current_field_state,
    cited_source_shas=frozenset({...}),
    allowed_source_shas=frozenset({...}),
    last_refusal_was_typed=True,
    identity_manifold_hash_before=before_hash,
    identity_manifold_hash_after=after_hash,
)
verdict = check.check(ctx, safety_pack)
# verdict.upheld: bool, verdict.violated_boundaries: frozenset[str]
# verdict.results: tuple of per-boundary SafetyCheckResult

Every field on SafetyContext is optional. Predicates over fields the caller didn't populate default to upheld=True, runtime_checkable=False — absence of evidence is not evidence of violation. ChatRuntime exposes a pre-constructed instance as runtime.safety_check; the turn loop does not auto-invoke it at v1.

Default predicates per v1 boundary

Boundary	Runtime-checkable?	What it checks
preserve_versor_closure	Yes	field_state.versor_condition < 1.0e-6
no_fabricated_source	Yes (when allowlist supplied)	cited_source_shas ⊆ allowed_source_shas
no_silent_correction	Yes	last_refusal_was_typed flag
no_identity_override	Yes (when both hashes supplied)	identity-manifold hash before == after
no_hot_path_repair	No	code-path boundary; enforced by static analysis + code review

The no_hot_path_repair predicate reports runtime_checkable=False and upheld=True honestly. A predicate that silently reported upheld=True would be a small lie — the surface acknowledges what it cannot judge.

Custom predicates

check = SafetyCheck()
check.register("my_boundary_id", my_predicate)

Unknown boundaries (declared in the pack but no predicate registered) default to upheld=True, runtime_checkable=False, reason="no predicate registered for boundary". Doesn't crash; surfaces in audit.

Known limits

1. No SafetyCheck parallel to IdentityCheck. Closed by ADR-0032 (2026-05-17). See §SafetyCheck above. v1 is observational; turn-loop auto-invocation and refusal wiring are future ADRs.
2. No per-tenant safety packs. Multi-tenant CORE deployments share one safety pack.
3. No human-in-the-loop ratification step. Operational discipline lives in PR review, not the code.
4. English-only boundary descriptions at v1.

Cross-reference index

• Pack format spec: this doc §"Pack format (v1)".
• Loader contract: this doc §"Loader contract".
• Decision record: ADR-0029.
• Identity pack composition: identity_packs.md.
• Trust-boundary doctrine: runtime_contracts.md, CLAUDE.md "Security and Trust Boundaries".
• The formation template used for ratification: formation/templates/identity_anchor.py.