5c77c9eece
The falsifiable experiment's measurements #2 (ablation) and #3 (diversity). Builds the competent, code-disjoint SYMBOLIC reader (the control arm AND the C3 capability path) and the ablation instrument that runs both readers through the real verify_tier2_agreement gate. VERDICT: C3 — the field is decoration on this domain (a sanctioned, honest negative): - field_wrong_commits = [] (wrong=0 holds; the per-step drift guard refuses bad ints) - field_caught_symbolic_errors = [] (the field caught ZERO symbolic errors) - per-class diversity = 0 everywhere (both readers agree and are both correct) - the only admitted-set change is the field LOSING coverage at the precision ceiling. Insight: on forward-substitutable relations, geometric translation IS arithmetic addition, so there is no metric over-determination for the field to exploit — field and symbol are common-mode (Knight-Leveson), not a genuine second derivation. This is the deductive finding's twin: logic was combinatorial (field can't earn it), additive is arithmetically trivial (field adds nothing). The field needs metric-nontrivial AND arithmetically-hard structure to earn a reasoning role — dedicated research, not near-term. Field-as-reasoner is NOT earned; no field vote enters any serving path; the field stays a servant. Capability path = symbolic (C3), not shipped here. - generate/relational_symbolic_reader.py: competent independent reader (pure int). - evals/relational_metric/ablation.py: the reusable decoration instrument. - docs/analysis/field-wedge-ablation-result-2026-06-04.md: the recorded verdict. All prior artifacts STAY (field reader = real wrong=0 read demo + 3rd panel domain). Green: full wedge suite 104; 53 architectural invariants. |
||
|---|---|---|
| .. | ||
| adr | ||
| analysis | ||
| architecture | ||
| audit | ||
| brief | ||
| briefs | ||
| curriculum | ||
| decisions | ||
| evals | ||
| handoff | ||
| handoffs | ||
| implementation | ||
| plans | ||
| research | ||
| sessions | ||
| workbench | ||
| zig | ||
| admissibility-exemplars.md | ||
| audio_pipeline_overview.md | ||
| capability_roadmap.md | ||
| claims_ledger.md | ||
| ethics_packs.md | ||
| EVAL_AUDIT_2026-05-20.md | ||
| eval_methodology.md | ||
| formation_pipeline_plan.md | ||
| frontier_baselines.md | ||
| gaps.md | ||
| hitl-backpressure.md | ||
| holdout_recipients.txt | ||
| identity_packs.md | ||
| master-plan-post-substrate-audit.md | ||
| model_dependency_size_tally.md | ||
| pack_inventory_2026-05-21.md | ||
| position_paper.md | ||
| PROGRESS.md | ||
| recognizer-registry.md | ||
| refusal-taxonomy.md | ||
| reviewers.yaml | ||
| runtime_contracts.md | ||
| RUST.md | ||
| safety_packs.md | ||
| teaching_order.md | ||
| test-debt-quarantine.md | ||
| truth_seeking_schema.md | ||
| Whitepaper.md | ||
| Yellowpaper.md | ||