Closes the Opus share of the curriculum-license-loop arc. Three deliverables,
all docs -- no production code.
1. E1-R7-ASSERTION-SPEC.md -- the Opus half of Phase E1. The code move was
already specified by runtime_contracts.md ("defer the single sink emission
to the pipeline serve boundary"); what to ASSERT was not, and the default
sink is None, so nothing exercises the path. Eight invariants (I1-I8) plus
three mechanism rulings (M1-M3), each with the silent failure it prevents.
The three mechanism rulings are the value. M1: stage a turn_log INDEX, not
a captured TurnEvent -- a captured copy is the pre-override snapshot, i.e.
the defect with extra steps. M2: attach_telemetry_sink must NOT flush a
staged turn event, which is the OPPOSITE of what it correctly does for
_pending_reboot_payload; the reboot payload is final when buffered, a turn
event is mid-flight, and flushing on attach would silently restore R7. M3:
the runtime cannot detect whether a pipeline will run (the pipeline wraps
the runtime), so deferral must be explicit opt-in and the no-pipeline path
must stay byte-identical.
All ten source citations verified against HEAD.
2. Plan of record AMENDED with four falsified premises from Phases A/B, with
the original text preserved:
- physics·modal was the wrong first target -- its ceiling is 480 against a
657 threshold, and 8 of 11 bands cannot reach 657 at all. Vocabulary is
the constraint, not chain count. Retarget: philosophy_theology·modal.
- MAX_PREMISE_SENTENCES=16 caps a family at 16 chains, so ADR-0262 §5.1's
own remedy (~219 relations) collapses the band at row 17. No curriculum
band can earn SERVE until premise compilation is query-scoped. New
implementation phase precedes ALL content work.
- authoring a negative today serves a confident wrong "Yes", not UNKNOWN.
- 21 of 25 ratified deduction bands are short on distinct evidence.
3. DIVISION-OF-WORK updated for the handoff: §0 status table with branch names
and merge order, the revised order (E2 -> R5-R7 -> C -> D -> E1(code) ->
parity), the new R5-R7 unit specified to gate-level detail, and a standing
"do not fix" on the deduction ledger exposure.
One correction to my own earlier text: §4 told Phase C to mirror the
deduction producer "exactly". That would replicate the padding -- a flat
CASES_PER_BAND=720 cycling a 28-instance space. Phase C now points at the
`estimation` producer instead (660 distinct, zero repeats), and must
register in AUDIT_SOURCES.
[Verification]: uv sync --locked on canonical CPython 3.12.13; in-worktree
smoke 555 passed, deductive 285 passed (this branch is off main and carries
neither ADR-0264 nor the Phase B tests, so 555 is the correct baseline here,
not the 569 that holds on the stacked A+B branches).
e58e377e06