Two ADRs that unblock the remaining items from the 2026-05-20 audit
that could not ship as direct PRs.
ADR-0088 — Realizer-Grounded Authority (Finding 2 retry)
========================================================
The first-response audit remedy (wire ``ground_graph`` between
``runtime.chat`` and ``realize_semantic``) was empirically attempted
on ``fix/ground-graph-wiring`` and reverted: the grounded realizer's
template output (e.g. ``"Light is a visible medium that reveal
truth"``) is grammatically and stylistically weaker than the runtime
path's ADR-0085-polished pack-grounded surface, so the realizer wins
the surface resolver (PR #76) and the user-visible surface regresses
on 23 byte-identical tests + ``register_invariant_grounding``.
ADR-0088 reframes Finding 2 as a two-phase rollout:
* Phase A (no behavior change) — realizer fluency parity.
Templates consult the same gloss source ADR-0085 wired into the
CAUSE composer, emit 3sg verb agreement, and carry the same
pack-provenance tag the runtime path emits. Byte-identical
today because the realizer is still gated by
``_is_useful_surface``.
* Phase B (substantive) — ground the graph and let the realizer
compete. Surfaces change exactly once, with a per-case
re-baseline justified by a "fluency ≥ pre-fix runtime surface"
invariant.
The audit's final-draft remedy (hot-path short-circuit only) is
explicitly rejected — pure perf cleanup, no metric lift since
``core eval cognition`` is already at 100% groundedness.
ADR-0089 — Compound-Intent Pipeline Dispatch (Finding 4)
========================================================
``classify_compound_intent`` is implemented but never reaches
``CognitiveTurnPipeline.run()``. Compound inputs like *"What is X
and how does it relate to Y?"* silently drop the second clause.
Naive multi-node dispatch breaks every downstream stage:
PropositionGraph (one root), plan_articulation (single-root),
realize_semantic (one target), surface resolver (one surface per
turn), compute_trace_hash (one intent_tag + articulation_surface),
teaching loop (one correction-source proposal), register / anchor-
lens telemetry (one variant per turn).
ADR-0089 proposes a three-phase rollout:
* Phase C1 (no behavior change) — call ``classify_compound_intent``
in step 1b, record dropped clauses on
``CognitiveTurnResult.dropped_compound_clauses`` for
observability while routing the dominant clause through the
existing single-intent path.
* Phase C2 (opt-in substantive) — flag-gated multi-node graph
dispatch with new ``CompoundEdge`` / ``ConjunctionRelation``,
widened ``compute_trace_hash`` carrying a
``compound_clauses_hash``, and a ``multi_clause_surface`` field
on the resolver. Flag-off preserves byte-identity.
* Phase C3 — telemetry alignment + demo + docs.
Each phase is independently shippable and preserves the existing
null-lift / byte-identity invariants register and anchor-lens
established (ADR-0072, ADR-0073d) as the project's pattern for
substantive runtime behavior changes.
Both ADRs are Proposed; ratification follows the existing pack /
ADR review process. No code lands in this commit.
8b51813c73