core/tests/test_contract_residuals.py
Shay 7b2456d402
feat(kernel): implement diagnostic-only SearchGateDecision
Implements a diagnostic-only SearchGateDecision adapter over ContractResidual records.

Preserves the authority boundary:
ContractAssessment -> ContractResidual -> SearchGateDecision.

SearchGateDecision is not proof, repair, budget, search, serving, candidate generation, or mutation authority.

Validation reported on head 1d68292c7f:
- tests/test_search_gate.py: 23 passed
- tests/test_contract_residuals.py: 75 passed
- adjacent contract/proposal tests: 48 passed
- ruff: passed
- compileall: passed
- smoke: 108 passed
- git diff --check: clean
2026-06-22 11:36:05 -07:00

530 lines
16 KiB
Python

from __future__ import annotations
import ast
import dataclasses
from pathlib import Path
import pytest
from generate.contract_residuals import (
ContractResidual,
ResidualKind,
ResidualSourceAxis,
project_contract_residuals,
)
from generate.kernel_facts import SourceSpan
from generate.problem_frame_contracts import ContractAssessment
def _assessment(
*,
candidate_organ: str = "unary_delta_transition",
missing_bindings: tuple[str, ...] = (),
unresolved_hazards: tuple[str, ...] = (),
runnable: bool = False,
explanation: str = "diagnostic candidate is not runnable",
evidence_spans: tuple[SourceSpan, ...] = (),
) -> ContractAssessment:
return ContractAssessment(
candidate_organ=candidate_organ,
missing_bindings=missing_bindings,
unresolved_hazards=unresolved_hazards,
runnable=runnable,
explanation=explanation,
evidence_spans=evidence_spans,
)
def _entries(
kind: ResidualKind,
axis: ResidualSourceAxis,
*labels: str,
) -> tuple[tuple[str, ResidualKind, ResidualSourceAxis], ...]:
return tuple((label, kind, axis) for label in labels)
EXPECTED_LABEL_MAP: tuple[
tuple[str, ResidualKind, ResidualSourceAxis],
...,
] = (
*_entries(
ResidualKind.MISSING_PROPOSAL,
ResidualSourceAxis.PROPOSAL,
"quantity_entity_proposal_required",
"unary_delta_proposal_required",
),
*_entries(
ResidualKind.MISSING_RELATION,
ResidualSourceAxis.RELATION,
"local_binding_relation_unbound",
),
*_entries(
ResidualKind.MISSING_ROLE,
ResidualSourceAxis.ROLE,
"quantity_unbound",
"entity_unbound",
"quantity_kind_unresolved",
"base_quantity_unbound",
"scale_unbound",
"state_entity_unbound",
"grounded_partition_subgroup",
"grounded_whole_entity",
"original_whole_unbound",
"action_cue_unbound",
"delta_quantity_unbound",
"changed_object_unbound",
"direction_unbound",
),
*_entries(
ResidualKind.AMBIGUOUS_RELATION,
ResidualSourceAxis.RELATION,
"local_binding_relation_ambiguous",
"decrease_relation_ambiguous",
"unary_delta_relation_ambiguous",
),
*_entries(
ResidualKind.AMBIGUOUS_ROLE,
ResidualSourceAxis.ROLE,
"quantity_ambiguous",
"entity_ambiguous",
"multiple_original_whole_candidates",
"delta_quantity_ambiguous",
"changed_object_ambiguous",
),
*_entries(
ResidualKind.INEXACT_PROVENANCE,
ResidualSourceAxis.PROVENANCE,
"provenance_span_inexact",
"base_quantity_provenance_missing",
"scale_provenance_missing",
),
*_entries(
ResidualKind.NONLOCAL_BINDING,
ResidualSourceAxis.LOCALITY,
"quantity_entity_nonlocal",
"pronoun_antecedent_unresolved",
),
*_entries(
ResidualKind.UNSUPPORTED_TOPOLOGY,
ResidualSourceAxis.TOPOLOGY,
"percent_subgroup_links_incomplete",
"inverse_topology_unlicensed",
"event_assertion_unlicensed",
"passive_voice_unsupported",
"multiple_actor_surface",
),
*_entries(
ResidualKind.UNIT_OBJECT_CONFLICT,
ResidualSourceAxis.UNIT_OBJECT,
"unit_kind_conflict",
"unit_continuity_unproven",
"unit_object_conflict",
),
*_entries(
ResidualKind.HAZARD_BLOCKED,
ResidualSourceAxis.HAZARD,
"competing_family_context",
"percent_change_vs_percent_of",
"state_entity_continuity_unproven",
"scale_out_of_range",
"partition_subgroups_not_distinct",
),
*_entries(
ResidualKind.TARGET_UNBOUND,
ResidualSourceAxis.TARGET,
"delta_decrease_target_unbound",
"delta_decrease_target_required",
"grounded_question_target",
"forward_aggregate_target_required",
),
*_entries(
ResidualKind.CONTRACT_GAP_UNCLASSIFIED,
ResidualSourceAxis.UNKNOWN,
"unbound_base_quantity",
"container",
"content",
"count_per",
"worker",
"rate",
"duration",
),
)
@pytest.mark.parametrize(("label", "kind", "axis"), EXPECTED_LABEL_MAP)
def test_contract_residual_exact_label_mapping(
label: str,
kind: ResidualKind,
axis: ResidualSourceAxis,
) -> None:
residuals = project_contract_residuals(
(_assessment(missing_bindings=(label,)),)
)
assert len(residuals) == 1
residual = residuals[0]
assert residual.residual_kind is kind
assert residual.source_axis is axis
assert residual.residual_code == label
def test_all_currently_emitted_labels_are_accounted_for() -> None:
assert len(EXPECTED_LABEL_MAP) == 53
assert len({label for label, _, _ in EXPECTED_LABEL_MAP}) == 53
@pytest.mark.parametrize(
"label",
("Quantity_Unbound", "quantity_unbound ", "unknown_label"),
)
def test_arbitrary_and_case_altered_labels_fall_back_without_fuzzy_match(
label: str,
) -> None:
residuals = project_contract_residuals(
(_assessment(missing_bindings=(label,)),)
)
assert len(residuals) == 1
assert residuals[0].residual_code == label
assert residuals[0].residual_kind is ResidualKind.CONTRACT_GAP_UNCLASSIFIED
assert residuals[0].source_axis is ResidualSourceAxis.UNKNOWN
def test_duplicate_code_across_missing_and_hazard_fields_emits_once() -> None:
residuals = project_contract_residuals(
(
_assessment(
missing_bindings=("quantity_unbound",),
unresolved_hazards=("quantity_unbound",),
),
)
)
assert len(residuals) == 1
assert residuals[0].residual_code == "quantity_unbound"
def test_runnable_assessment_produces_no_residual_even_with_labels() -> None:
residuals = project_contract_residuals(
(
_assessment(
missing_bindings=("changed_object_unbound",),
unresolved_hazards=("unit_object_conflict",),
runnable=True,
),
)
)
assert residuals == ()
def test_refused_assessment_without_labels_produces_no_invented_residual() -> None:
assert project_contract_residuals((_assessment(),)) == ()
def test_residual_preserves_code_spans_and_explanation_verbatim() -> None:
span_a = SourceSpan("gained", 4, 10, 0)
span_b = SourceSpan("3", 11, 12, 0)
explanation = "diagnostic candidate is not runnable: changed_object_unbound"
residuals = project_contract_residuals(
(
_assessment(
missing_bindings=("changed_object_unbound",),
explanation=explanation,
evidence_spans=(span_a, span_b),
),
)
)
assert len(residuals) == 1
residual = residuals[0]
assert residual.residual_code == "changed_object_unbound"
assert residual.evidence_spans == (span_a, span_b)
assert residual.explanation == explanation
def test_family_id_is_resolved_from_candidate_organ() -> None:
residual = project_contract_residuals(
(
_assessment(
candidate_organ="unary_delta_transition",
missing_bindings=("changed_object_unbound",),
),
)
)[0]
assert residual.family_id == "state_change.unary_delta"
def test_unknown_candidate_organ_keeps_none_family_id() -> None:
residual = project_contract_residuals(
(
_assessment(
candidate_organ="future_unknown_organ",
missing_bindings=("unknown_label",),
),
)
)[0]
assert residual.family_id is None
def test_replay_stability_and_sorted_output_are_independent_of_input_order() -> None:
assessment_a = _assessment(missing_bindings=("changed_object_unbound",))
assessment_b = _assessment(
candidate_organ="quantity_entity_binding",
missing_bindings=("unit_kind_conflict",),
)
forward = project_contract_residuals((assessment_a, assessment_b))
reversed_input = project_contract_residuals((assessment_b, assessment_a))
assert forward == reversed_input
assert tuple(residual.residual_id for residual in forward) == tuple(
sorted(residual.residual_id for residual in forward)
)
def test_known_sha256_vector_and_explanation_independence() -> None:
span = SourceSpan("gained", 4, 10, 0)
residual_a = project_contract_residuals(
(
_assessment(
missing_bindings=("changed_object_unbound",),
explanation="first explanation",
evidence_spans=(span,),
),
)
)[0]
residual_b = project_contract_residuals(
(
_assessment(
missing_bindings=("changed_object_unbound",),
explanation="second explanation",
evidence_spans=(span,),
),
)
)[0]
assert residual_a.residual_id == (
"e56fa420ce0acc64071fc5ef819d740d54f1ab17f1a268728a0ef490784ffe32"
)
assert residual_a.residual_id == residual_b.residual_id
def test_evidence_span_order_and_sentence_index_participate_in_identity() -> None:
span_a = SourceSpan("gained", 4, 10, 0)
span_b = SourceSpan("3", 11, 12, 0)
residual_ordered = project_contract_residuals(
(
_assessment(
missing_bindings=("changed_object_unbound",),
evidence_spans=(span_a, span_b),
),
)
)[0]
residual_reversed = project_contract_residuals(
(
_assessment(
missing_bindings=("changed_object_unbound",),
evidence_spans=(span_b, span_a),
),
)
)[0]
residual_no_sentence = project_contract_residuals(
(
_assessment(
missing_bindings=("changed_object_unbound",),
evidence_spans=(SourceSpan("gained", 4, 10), span_b),
),
)
)[0]
assert residual_ordered.residual_id != residual_reversed.residual_id
assert residual_ordered.residual_id != residual_no_sentence.residual_id
def test_empty_evidence_is_lawful_and_does_not_synthesize_span() -> None:
residual = project_contract_residuals(
(
_assessment(
missing_bindings=("changed_object_unbound",),
evidence_spans=(),
),
)
)[0]
assert residual.evidence_spans == ()
def test_projection_leaves_assessment_unchanged() -> None:
span = SourceSpan("lost", 8, 12, 0)
assessment = _assessment(
missing_bindings=("delta_quantity_unbound",),
evidence_spans=(span,),
)
before = assessment
project_contract_residuals((assessment,))
assert assessment == before
def test_contract_residual_has_no_authority_fields() -> None:
disallowed = {
"runnable",
"verdict",
"answer",
"proof",
"search_eligible",
"retryable",
"priority",
"budget",
"action",
"serving_allowed",
"mutation",
"recommended_migration_target",
}
assert disallowed.isdisjoint(
{field.name for field in dataclasses.fields(ContractResidual)}
)
def test_public_api_is_exactly_the_read_model_projection() -> None:
import generate.contract_residuals as contract_residuals
assert tuple(contract_residuals.__all__) == (
"ResidualKind",
"ResidualSourceAxis",
"ContractResidual",
"project_contract_residuals",
)
def test_family_examples_project_expected_residuals() -> None:
examples = (
(
_assessment(
candidate_organ="unary_delta_transition",
missing_bindings=(
"action_cue_unbound",
"direction_unbound",
"changed_object_unbound",
),
),
{
"action_cue_unbound": ResidualKind.MISSING_ROLE,
"direction_unbound": ResidualKind.MISSING_ROLE,
"changed_object_unbound": ResidualKind.MISSING_ROLE,
},
),
(
_assessment(
candidate_organ="quantity_entity_binding",
missing_bindings=("quantity_kind_unresolved",),
unresolved_hazards=("unit_kind_conflict",),
),
{
"quantity_kind_unresolved": ResidualKind.MISSING_ROLE,
"unit_kind_conflict": ResidualKind.UNIT_OBJECT_CONFLICT,
},
),
(
_assessment(
candidate_organ="fraction_decrease",
missing_bindings=("delta_decrease_target_unbound",),
),
{"delta_decrease_target_unbound": ResidualKind.TARGET_UNBOUND},
),
(
_assessment(
candidate_organ="percent_partition",
missing_bindings=("percent_subgroup_links_incomplete",),
unresolved_hazards=(
"partition_subgroups_not_distinct",
"percent_change_vs_percent_of",
),
),
{
"partition_subgroups_not_distinct": ResidualKind.HAZARD_BLOCKED,
"percent_subgroup_links_incomplete": (
ResidualKind.UNSUPPORTED_TOPOLOGY
),
"percent_change_vs_percent_of": ResidualKind.HAZARD_BLOCKED,
},
),
)
for assessment, expected in examples:
residuals = project_contract_residuals((assessment,))
assert {residual.residual_code for residual in residuals} == set(expected)
for residual in residuals:
assert residual.residual_kind is expected[residual.residual_code]
def test_positive_family_controls_project_to_empty_tuple() -> None:
runnable_assessments = (
_assessment(candidate_organ="unary_delta_transition", runnable=True),
_assessment(candidate_organ="quantity_entity_binding", runnable=True),
_assessment(candidate_organ="fraction_decrease", runnable=True),
_assessment(candidate_organ="percent_partition", runnable=True),
)
assert project_contract_residuals(runnable_assessments) == ()
def test_module_imports_are_leaf_read_model_allowlist() -> None:
source = Path("generate/contract_residuals.py").read_text()
tree = ast.parse(source)
imports: set[str] = set()
calls: set[str] = set()
for node in ast.walk(tree):
if isinstance(node, ast.Import):
imports.update(alias.name for alias in node.names)
elif isinstance(node, ast.ImportFrom):
imports.add(node.module or "")
elif isinstance(node, ast.Call):
if isinstance(node.func, ast.Name):
calls.add(node.func.id)
elif isinstance(node.func, ast.Attribute):
calls.add(node.func.attr)
assert imports <= {
"__future__",
"hashlib",
"json",
"dataclasses",
"enum",
"generate.kernel_facts",
"generate.problem_frame_contracts",
}
forbidden_calls = {
"build_problem_frame",
"assess_contracts",
"determine",
"store",
"write",
"repair",
"search",
"serve",
"SourceSpan",
}
assert forbidden_calls.isdisjoint(calls)
def test_no_reverse_imports_into_contract_residuals() -> None:
for path in Path("generate").glob("*.py"):
if path.name in ("contract_residuals.py", "search_gate.py"):
continue
assert "contract_residuals" not in path.read_text()
def test_enum_values_are_lower_snake_case() -> None:
for enum_cls in (ResidualKind, ResidualSourceAxis):
for member in enum_cls:
assert member.value == member.value.lower()
assert " " not in member.value
assert "-" not in member.value