44e78aa438
Phase 2 of the generalization arc, implementing the plan's §4 curriculum-entailment gold contract. "Does force cause acceleration?" is answered from the ratified physics chain corpus and nothing else; "Does gravity cause acceleration?" is declined because gravity is in no pack CORE has been taught; "Does force cause motion?" is unsettled even though the curriculum contains both links, because nothing ratified says causation composes. Path (flag-gated, default off): closed question grammar -> subject routing by ratified vocabulary -> family-scoped premise compilation from reviewed, pack-resident chains -> the SAME argument bands (ADR-0260/0261) -> the ROBDD engine. Zero subject-specific decision code: physics differs from philosophy only in which rows load. Epistemology enforced mechanically, not by convention: - gold is a function of (curriculum, question); cases pin chain ids and the runner FAILS a case whose pinned chain is absent or unratified; - untaught => UNKNOWN, never "no" (open-world; silence is not denial); - an independent oracle (own loader, ratification predicate, family table, agreement rules, verdict rule) re-derives every gold — it disagreed once, on "entropy reveals energy" vs "entropy causes energy", and the ORACLE was the side that was wrong; - anti-recall probes are a lane GUARD: a split without >=3 true-but-untaught probes refuses to run. Findings recorded rather than worked around (ADR-0262 §5): - every curriculum band is UNEARNED and every answer is hedged. A band needs n>=657 with a real outcome mix; physics teaches 7 causal + 9 modal relations, so at most 16 questions in the subject can ever be ENTAILED. A balanced band needs ~219 taught relations per subject×family — a ~25x gap that only ratified curriculum content closes. Phase 2's blocker is curriculum volume, not machinery. - REFUTED is unreachable from present corpora (every chain is positive). - there is NO biology domain-chain corpus; the biology OOD lane measures fluency, not truth. The four subjects with ratified chains and mounted packs are physics, mathematics_logic, systems_software, philosophy_theology — the composer serves all four. [Verification]: curriculum lane 32/32 wrong=0 with 5 anti-recall probes and all three contract guards passing; tests/test_curriculum_serve.py 20 passed; core test --suite deductive 252 passed; lane pinned as curriculum_serve_v1.
32 lines
4.6 KiB
JSON
32 lines
4.6 KiB
JSON
{"id": "cs-phy-0001", "text": "Does force cause acceleration?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-causal-001"], "class": "taught_edge_causal"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0002", "text": "Does acceleration cause motion?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-causal-002"], "class": "taught_edge_causal"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0003", "text": "Does work cause energy?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-causal-003"], "class": "taught_edge_causal"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0004", "text": "Does charge cause field?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-causal-004"], "class": "taught_edge_causal"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0005", "text": "Does field cause force?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-causal-005"], "class": "taught_edge_causal"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0006", "text": "Does temperature reveal motion?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-causal-006"], "class": "taught_edge_reveals"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0007", "text": "Does entropy reveal energy?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-causal-007"], "class": "taught_edge_reveals"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0008", "text": "Does conservation require symmetry?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-modal-001"], "class": "taught_edge_modal"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0009", "text": "Does mass require force?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-modal-002"], "class": "taught_edge_modal"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0010", "text": "Does momentum require mass?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-modal-003"], "class": "taught_edge_modal"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0011", "text": "Does energy require conservation?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-modal-004"], "class": "taught_edge_modal"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0012", "text": "Does frequency require wave?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-modal-005"], "class": "taught_edge_modal"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0013", "text": "Does wave require field?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-causal-008"], "class": "taught_edge_family_by_connective"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0014", "text": "Does force cause motion?", "gold": "unknown", "chains": ["physics-causal-001", "physics-causal-002"], "class": "two_hop_not_composed"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0015", "text": "Does charge cause acceleration?", "gold": "unknown", "chains": ["physics-causal-004", "physics-causal-005", "physics-causal-001"], "class": "three_hop_not_composed"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0016", "text": "Does energy require symmetry?", "gold": "unknown", "chains": ["physics-modal-004", "physics-modal-001"], "class": "two_hop_modal_not_composed"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0017", "text": "Does momentum require force?", "gold": "unknown", "chains": ["physics-modal-003", "physics-modal-002"], "class": "two_hop_modal_not_composed"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0018", "text": "Does acceleration cause force?", "gold": "unknown", "chains": ["physics-causal-001"], "class": "reverse_direction"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0019", "text": "Does motion cause acceleration?", "gold": "unknown", "chains": ["physics-causal-002"], "class": "reverse_direction"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0020", "text": "Does entropy cause energy?", "gold": "unknown", "chains": ["physics-causal-007"], "class": "relation_not_interchangeable"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0021", "text": "Does work cause motion?", "gold": "unknown", "chains": [], "class": "unlinked_pair"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0022", "text": "Does temperature require symmetry?", "gold": "unknown", "chains": [], "class": "unlinked_pair"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0023", "text": "Does mass require energy?", "gold": "unknown", "chains": [], "class": "anti_recall_true_but_untaught"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0024", "text": "Does force cause work?", "gold": "unknown", "chains": [], "class": "anti_recall_true_but_untaught"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0025", "text": "Does charge require field?", "gold": "unknown", "chains": ["physics-modal-007"], "class": "reverse_direction_modal"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0026", "text": "Does field require charge?", "gold": "entailed", "chains": ["physics-modal-007"], "class": "taught_edge_modal"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0027", "text": "Does gravity cause acceleration?", "gold": "declined", "chains": [], "class": "anti_recall_untaught_vocabulary"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0028", "text": "Does current cause field?", "gold": "declined", "chains": [], "class": "anti_recall_untaught_vocabulary"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0029", "text": "Does pressure require volume?", "gold": "declined", "chains": [], "class": "anti_recall_untaught_vocabulary"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0030", "text": "Does force explain acceleration?", "gold": "declined", "chains": [], "class": "out_of_curriculum_relation"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0031", "text": "Does force accelerate mass quickly?", "gold": "declined", "chains": [], "class": "question_shape_out_of_band"}
|
|
{"id": "cs-phy-0032", "text": "Does the force cause acceleration?", "gold": "declined", "chains": [], "class": "question_shape_out_of_band"}
|