core/docs/workbench

CORE Workbench v1

CORE Workbench is the first dedicated operator/auditor UI for CORE.

It is intentionally designed as:

• a cognition observatory,
• replay debugger,
• proposal review workstation,
• deterministic eval console,
• and audit surface.

It is NOT intended to be a generic chatbot shell.

---

Document Index

Doctrine

• ../decisions/ADR-0160-core-workbench-v1.md

Defines:

• product doctrine
• trust boundaries
• architecture direction
• module scope
• acceptance criteria

---

UX Blueprint

• core-workbench-v1-blueprint.md

Defines:

• visual philosophy
• interaction model
• module behavior
• navigation
• replay/proposal/eval UX

---

Implementation Plan

• implementation-plan.md

Defines:

• W-026 through W-031
• phase sequencing
• backend/frontend constraints
• release criteria

---

API Contract

• api-contract-v1.md

Defines:

• read-only endpoint surface
• request/response envelopes
• mutation boundaries
• runtime/trace/proposal/eval/replay routes

---

Data Shapes

• data-shapes-v1.md

Defines:

• typed UI-facing shapes
• proposal structures
• replay structures
• artifact references
• trust badges

---

Proposal Artifact Substrate

• proposal-artifact-substrate-v1.md

Defines:

• the universal proposal artifact envelope
• subject-specific proposal adapters
• proposal-only vs ratification-enabled capability levels
• safety, validation, affected-artifact, and checksum-impact report shapes
• the migration path for math, cognition, CORE-Logos, packs, and future modalities

---

Wave M Consolidation / B3.5

• wave-m-consolidation-b3.5.md

Defines:

• the route-registry unification plan
• calibration as a first-class evidence subject
• the B4 leeway-feasibility gate
• the UI/UX guide requirement
• the Phase A residue ledger before further complexity

Supporting B3.5 deliverables:

• UI-UX-GUIDE.md — operator/evaluator route map, evidence grammar, route proofs, boundaries, and absences.
• b4-leeway-feasibility-gate.md — B4 source-tuple audit and B4a nullable read model (gate CLEARED 2026-06-13; the producer now exists).
• b4-leeway-producer-scope-2026-06-13.md — the engine-side leeway producer scope: the serving-path seam, the LicenseDecision→LeewayEvidence mapping, and the two honest layers (STRICT / earned-APPROXIMATE).
• phase-a-residue-ledger.md — implemented/deferred/blocked residue.

---

Mastery & Worthiness Waves (1 / R / M)

The plans that took the surface from read-only spine to "worthy of the deterministic engine":

• wave-1-evidence-spine.md — the evidence-address model (URL = subject), Evidence Chain Rail, and RightInspector.
• wave-R-mastery-revamp.md — the 11 real routes, the Replay Moment, trace integrity, and the DAG/Demo/wrong=0 surfaces.
• wave-M-worthiness.md — the governing plan for the worthiness arc: Phase B (calibrated-learning / serving discipline), Phase C (cognition legibility), Phase D (guided tour + shareable evidence bundles), Phase E (robustness). Per-deliverable implementation notes live inline.

---

Design System

• design-system.md — semantic token roles, density, primitives, and the motion / calm-honesty discipline.

---

CORE-Logos Studio

• core-logos-studio-plan.md

Defines:

• the /logos Studio route concept
• pack identity, lexicon, glosses, morphology, alignment, holonomy, safety, and patch-forge tabs
• CORE-Logos evidence subjects
• read-only readers and proposal-only draft endpoint direction
• the handler-family admission sequence for future ratification

---

UI Component Map

• ui-component-map.md

Defines:

• page layout
• navigation structure
• shared components
• trace drawer structure
• proposal/eval/replay modules

---

Acceptance Gates

• acceptance-gates.md

Defines:

• implementation gates
• red flags
• release conditions
• mutation restrictions

---

Visual Evidence / Handoff

• ../handoff/workbench-truncated-cell-visual-evidence-2026-06-14.md — captured screenshots confirming the TruncatedCell full-content reveal (popover + copy + modal) across the proposal queue, the trace propagation edges, and the single-column selection rails.

---

Core Principles

Replay before persuasion

The UI should make replay evidence more important than aesthetic persuasion.

Calm by default

The interface should remain quiet and precise.

Progressive disclosure

The system should become more transparent the deeper an operator inspects.

Proposal is not ratification

The UI must preserve ADR-0057 review doctrine.

Read-only first

The first workbench phases prioritize visibility and auditability before any mutation capability.

---

Current Status (2026-06-14)

The Workbench is shipped and well past the W-026…W-031 planning era. The read-only local API + React UI are real; W-026 (read-only API) through W-031 (replay theater) all landed, followed by the Wave 1 evidence spine, the Wave R mastery revamp (11 routes + the Replay Moment), and the Wave M worthiness arc.

Wave M is complete — Phase B (calibrated-learning surfaces), Phase C (cognition legibility, incl. the trace Field reader), Phase D (guided tour + evidence bundles), and the B4 leeway producer all merged. Since then the always-on heartbeat has added a continuous Lived Life surface and a read-only CORE-Logos reader (identity / lexicon / glosses / morphology / alignment / safety). Phase E (robustness; continuous) and the parallel tracks (the CORE-Logos Studio mutation/patch-forge path, the universal proposal envelope) remain.

The Vault evidence surface is likewise complete end to end: P0 honest empty/unavailable framing (every state framed as the Vault; absence vs persisted-empty split; #760), P1 entry-inspector depth + status/facet/text filters + an honest evidence-rail progression (#762/#763/#764), and P2 read-only exact-CGA recall evidence (GET /vault/entries/{index}/recall; #766). It stays a read-only evidence surface — no runtime controls, no persistence toggle, no approximate recall.

Doctrine is unchanged: read-only first, allowlisted execution only (/evals/run, ratify, /demos/{id}/run), every surface a real backend reader (no theater), determinism over persuasion.

Shipped surfaces

16 registry-driven routes (src/app/routes.ts), grouped by section:

Section	Routes
Converse	Chat
Cognition	Trace (Pipeline / Field / Bundle / Surfaces / Grounding / Verdicts / Metadata / Raw tabs), Contemplation (staged learning loop)
Determinism	Tour (guided determinism narrative), Replay (hash-to-hash), Demos (Demo Theater)
Evidence	Proposals (+ HITL ratification), Runs (+ identity continuity), Lived Life (always-on heartbeat), Vault (honest empty/unavailable framing · inspector depth + status/facet/text filters · evidence-rail progression · exact-CGA recall), Audit
Discipline	Evals (wrong=0 ledger), Calibration (gold-tether arena, Wilson floor vs θ)
Substrate	Packs, CORE-Logos (read-only pack reader)
Settings	Settings (landing / density / inspector prefs)

Cross-cutting: Evidence Address (URL = subject, ?inspect=), Evidence Chain Rail, command palette + registry-driven keyboard help, per-turn pipeline / field / leeway / bundle evidence, full-content reveal for truncated table cells (TruncatedCell — hover/focus popover + copy + modal), doctrine gates (hexScan, schemaDrift, enumCoverage, route conformance, golden-file DAG layout).

---

W-026 Local Runbook

Start the read-only local API:

core workbench api

Verify liveness:

curl http://127.0.0.1:8765/health

Inspect each W-026 endpoint family:

curl http://127.0.0.1:8765/runtime/status
curl http://127.0.0.1:8765/artifacts
curl http://127.0.0.1:8765/artifacts/evals/contemplation_quality/contract.md
curl http://127.0.0.1:8765/proposals
curl http://127.0.0.1:8765/evals
curl http://127.0.0.1:8765/evals/contemplation_quality
curl -X POST http://127.0.0.1:8765/evals/run \
  -H 'Content-Type: application/json' \
  -d '{"lane":"contemplation_quality","version":"v1","split":"public"}'

Bind to a different local port:

core workbench api --port 9000

Non-local binds require an explicit operator flag:

core workbench api --host 0.0.0.0 --allow-nonlocal-bind

---

Initial Work Queue (delivered)

The original W-026…W-031 queue is complete; it is kept here as provenance. Current work is tracked in the Wave M worthiness plan and the residue ledger.

Work Item	Goal	Status
W-026	Read-only API	done
W-027	Frontend shell	done
W-028	Chat + trace drawer	done
W-029	Proposal queue	done
W-030	Eval center	done
W-031	Replay theater	done

---

Guiding Question

The correct operator reaction to the workbench should be:

“Wait… I can actually inspect and replay the cognition.”

not:

“Cool chatbot.”