core chat now decides Aristotelian syllogisms end-to-end -- the marquee
'basic logical work' widening. Closes Phase 0's fork: the ONLY categorical
decider was evals/syllogism/oracle.py (the sealed independence oracle serving
must not import; INV-25). This ships a production decider.
generate/proof_chain/categorical.py lowers a categorical argument to the
propositional regime (one Boolean atom per term-membership profile) and rides
the already-verified ROBDD engine -- no new decision procedure, soundness
inherits from the flagship. Sound AND complete for the modern/Boolean reading
(Darapti + existential-import-only forms correctly INVALID), with no reliance
on a lucky domain size. Independent of the eval oracle by mechanism (ROBDD-
over-profiles vs brute-force finite-model enumeration); proven by case-for-case
agreement with it across the whole syllogism gold lane.
New: generate/proof_chain/categorical.py, render_syllogism (deterministic
valid/invalid/inconsistent templates), CATEGORICAL shape-band, arena
categorical band (4 valid forms + 2 invalid, by-construction gold cross-checked
vs the independent syllogism oracle), tests/test_categorical_decider.py (8
tests incl. the independence-by-agreement proof).
Changed: chat/deduction_surface.py (categorical branch, license-gated via a
shared _license_gate helper; propositional path byte-identical), arena
DeductionSolver dual-path in lock-step with the composer, re-sealed ledger (5
bands, categorical earns SERVE at 0.99087 wrong=0), Phase-2 lane decide()
mirrors the dual path with the 3 categorical cases reclassified to their true
valid/invalid verdicts + 1 invalid case (n 27->28), report+SHA regenerated.
Honest wrinkles: irregular plurals ('fish') decline with unknown_morphology
(a reader limit, correctly not a wrong); surfaces read in singularized terms
('all whale are animal') -- the exact ids the engine reasoned over, no cosmetic
re-pluralization that could drift from the decision.
[Verification]: smoke 180 passed; cognition 122 passed/1 skipped; core test
--suite deductive 45 passed; test_categorical_decider 8 passed; practice
runner 5 bands all SERVE wrong=0; deduction_serve lane SHA regenerates to the
committed pin.
Deduction serving stops being a bare flag and becomes an EARNED capability
governed by the ADR-0175 reliability gate over the ADR-0199 learning arena
-- the arena's second concrete instance (GSM8K math is the first) and the
reliability substrate's first non-estimation serving consumer, a concrete
dent in that zone's standing 'designed, not wired' critique.
Non-circular thesis: the ROBDD engine is sound+complete (never wrong on the
problem it's handed), so the license does NOT certify it. It certifies the
full pipeline (reader -> projector -> engine) per argument shape -- the
FALLIBLE part is the template reader, which can misparse an argument and
hand the engine the wrong problem. The arena catches that as a 'wrong' by
comparing the pipeline's committed outcome to by-construction gold.
New: generate/proof_chain/shape.py (4 exhaustive structural shape-bands, the
capability axis, shared by arena + serving), evals/deduction_serve/practice/
(the deduction arena instance: deterministic synthetic corpus, by-construction
gold independent of the reader per ADR-0199 L-2, cross-checked against the
INDEPENDENT truth-table oracle before sealing), chat/data/deduction_serve_
ledger.json (committed SHA-sealed ledger, 4 bands x 720 correct/0 wrong),
chat/deduction_serve_license.py (tamper-evident serving reader, mirrors
estimation_license.py), tests/test_deduction_serve_license.py (13 tests),
docs/adr/ADR-0256 (+ resolves the ADR-0206 numbering collision in doc form).
Changed: chat/deduction_surface.py (composer consults the license: earned
band -> authoritative Phase-1 surface; unearned/stripped ledger -> same sound
answer served DISCLOSED/hedged -- authority now rests on committed evidence,
not a boolean), core/config.py (flag docstring: enables an EARNED path),
core/cli_test.py (deductive suite runs the license test).
All four structural bands earn SERVE at reliability 0.99087 (>= theta_SERVE
0.99) with wrong=0, so Phase-1 behavior is preserved byte-for-byte; the
gate's teeth are proven by injecting an empty ledger (the same sound answer
degrades to a disclosed hedge). Did NOT reuse the ADR-0206 govern_response
bridge (its STRICT/APPROXIMATE 'widen-past-strict' semantics are the opposite
shape from deduction's always-sound answer); did NOT rewrite report.json's
stale adr field (SHA-pinned bytes, documented in ADR-0256 s2a instead).
[Verification]: smoke 180 passed; cognition 122 passed/1 skipped;
core test --suite deductive 38 passed; architectural_invariants 75 passed;
practice runner 4 bands all SERVE wrong=0.
Wires the verified ROBDD entailment engine (generate/proof_chain,
716/716 wrong=0) into core chat serving. A propositional argument
('P1. P2. ... Therefore C.') is now comprehended, projected, and
decided end-to-end -- the first real working basic-logic workflow:
user question -> CORE decides -> articulated deterministic answer.
New: chat/deduction_surface.py (DEDUCTION composer, sibling to the
existing oov/narrative/example composer pattern), generate/proof_chain/
render.py (deterministic EntailmentTrace -> surface templates, no LLM),
tests/test_deduction_surface.py (15 tests incl. full propositional gold
corpus decided end-to-end across a multi-turn session, wrong=0).
Changed: core/config.py (deduction_serving_enabled flag, default off),
generate/intent.py (IntentTag.DEDUCTION, observability-only -- the core
classify_intent rule table is untouched so flag-off stays byte-identical),
chat/runtime.py (one flag-gated block in the existing pack/teaching/
partial/oov dispatcher).
Design notes (full detail in docs/research/deduction-serve-arc-phase1-
turn-spine-2026-07-23.md): the deduction check runs BEFORE generic intent
classification (never touches classify_intent's rule table) and BEFORE
the empty-vault gate (a live multi-turn probe caught turn-12 silently
falling through once the vault warmed -- pack/teaching/oov are cold-start-
only by design, deduction serving isn't). grounding_source='deduction' is
NOT registered in the closed, Workbench-coupled GroundingSource Literal
(cross-stack TS contract, inert for this arc's core-chat-only consumer,
documented as a deferred follow-up). Band v1 stays propositional-only --
categorical/syllogism arguments commit but honestly decline as
out-of-band; evals.syllogism.oracle is never imported (INV-25 intact).
[Verification]: smoke 180 passed; cognition 122 passed/1 skipped;
test_deduction_surface.py 15 passed; test_dispatch_trace.py +
test_oov_surface.py 26 passed; test_intent*.py 145 passed.
The ratified capability, through the existing mutation owner only:
- teaching/proof_promotion.py — pure decider. Fresh-reads every premise AND
the claim from the store (claim_entry_index; forms never proposer-supplied),
strict status compares (no parse-defaulting), reading_certified must be the
boolean True, engine certification via the pinned deductive engine,
proposer_payload accepted and provably never read (del before use; poisoned-
mapping test), certificate digest emitted for D4 trace-hash folding. Zero
mutation; zero vault.store calls; zero status writes (proven with the
INV-21/INV-29 detectors themselves).
- vault/store.py::apply_certified_promotion — the single transition site.
Independently re-verifies: byte-for-byte replay under DEDUCTIVE_ENGINE_PIN,
promotion_positive, live claim form/reading/status cross-checks, live
premise form/reading/status cross-checks (staleness refuses). Fabricated or
tampered certificates flip nothing; authority is live store state plus
recomputation, never the artifact.
- generate/proof_chain/engine_pin.py — DEDUCTIVE_ENGINE_PIN mirrors the
deductive_logic_v1 lane SHA; sync pinned by AST test against
scripts/verify_lane_shas.py.
- Consistency fix found in lookback: both promotion sites now stamp
epistemic_state alongside epistemic_status (the ADR-0148 site left the
stored state tag stale; recall recomputed it, but the stored key lied).
Obligations: all six strict-xfail markers retired and live (O1/O2
strengthened to prove the transition through the vault owner); the
module-existence pin deleted per its own docstring; the two remaining
honesty pins kept. INV-21 allowlist unchanged; INV-29 allowlist unchanged
({vault/store.py}); INV-29's 29c visibility floor raised 2 -> 3 to cover the
new site.
No runtime turn path calls promotion; the deterministic demo is PR D.
Validation: new suite 49 passed; obligations 8 passed (0 xfail remaining);
invariants 66 passed; certificate 27 passed; 0148 6 passed; epistemic 20
passed; smoke files green; lane SHAs verified.
Pure evidence substrate for proof-carrying coherence promotion. No
promotion, no vault import, no status transition, no teaching-path
change; ADR-0218 stays Proposed.
- generate/proof_chain/certificate.py: frozen PromotionCertificate
(version/claim_form/premise ids+forms+statuses/entailment_trace/
engine_pin/decision/reason, canonical_json with sort_keys+compact
separators); build_certificate runs evaluate_entailment_with_trace
over entry_id-sorted premises; verify_certificate rebuilds from the
embedded forms and accepts iff byte-identical — tampered forms/claim/
trace/decision/reason/ordering/version all fail replay, structural
breakage fails closed as malformed_certificate.
- promotion_positive is necessary-not-sufficient: entailed over a
non-empty all-coherent recorded premise set; REFUTED/UNKNOWN/REFUSED
verify as themselves but are never positive; zero-premise tautology
certificates fail-closed non-positive in v1.
- engine_pin is recorded provenance; pin tampering is caught only via
caller-supplied expected_engine_pin (P3 must pass the lane SHA) —
limit pinned by dedicated tests.
- entail.py: docstring-only fix removing the incorrect ADR-0206
attribution (numbering collision); now cites ADR-0218. Zero behavior
change. generate_claims.py:74 still carries the label (serving-frozen
surface, flagged for follow-up).
- No xfail markers retire: every PR-A obligation binds to the P3
promoter, which must not exist before ratification. The certificate-
shaped halves of O1/O7 are proven for real in
tests/test_proof_chain_certificate.py (27 tests). ADR phasing bullet
and obligations docstring record the reconciliation.
Validation: certificate 27 passed; obligations 3 passed + 6 xfailed;
architectural invariants 61 passed (INV-21/INV-29 green, allowlists
unchanged); entail/builder/rules 61 passed; smoke files 95 passed.
The first SIZEABLE, honestly-verified reasoning capability — built on CORE's
own terrain (exact, verifiable, deterministic), not GSM8K's stochastic terrain.
THE OPERATOR (generate/proof_chain/entail.py, ADR-0206):
- evaluate_entailment(premises, query) -> entailed | refuted | unknown | refused.
- The multi-hop inference operator evals/symbolic_logic/gaps.md said did not exist
("no operator that takes A->B, B->C and returns A->C") and ADR-0205 deferred.
- Built on the ADR-0201 ROBDD canonicalizer: premises |= Q iff (AND P) -> Q is a
tautology. SOUND AND COMPLETE for propositional logic, not single-step.
- wrong=0 is structural: an exact tautology check refuses (LogicError) on
malformed / out-of-decidable-regime (quantified/predicate) input, never guesses.
THE HONEST METRIC (evals/deductive_logic/):
- holdout v1 (500 cases): 500 correct / 0 WRONG, incl. 227 non-trivial deductions
(117 entailed + 110 refuted). dev (200): 200/0.
- Gold from an INDEPENDENT truth-table oracle (oracle.py) sharing zero code with
the engine. 8,000-case fuzz across two independent decision procedures:
0 disagreements. This is the soundness evidence the GSM8K composer could never
produce (it could not separate its 2 right from its 87 wrong answers).
- contract.md states the load-bearing honesty boundary: PROPOSITIONAL ONLY, and
given-formulas (NL->logic grounding is a separate later layer, kept out of scope
so we do not re-step on the GSM8K natural-language rake).
TESTS (17, all green): classic inference shapes (MP, multi-hop chain, modus
tollens, disjunctive/hypothetical syllogism, conjunctive rules, genuine unknown),
refusal boundary (inconsistent / quantified / predicate / malformed), and a
deterministic engine-vs-oracle fuzz cross-check.
Pure new module — does NOT touch serving. Smoke 73 passed; invariants 40 passed.
Phase 2.3: the first inference rule + the wrong=0 mechanism for proofs.
- generate/proof_chain/rules.py: evaluate_modus_ponens / evaluate_proof_conclusion.
Proof-layer dispatch (Option B) over proposition FORMULAS via the canonicalizer;
never touches check_admissibility/_resolve_dep_units (proofs have no units).
Disagreement rule = the select_self_verified twin: pool ALL admissible single-step
MP derivations, require a unique canonical key == declared conclusion. Pooling (not
filter-to-declared-first) is the soundness mechanism.
- generate/logic_canonical.py: parse_top_implication (+ _unparse) — recovers an
implication's syntactic antecedent/consequent (the ROBDD form doesn't preserve it).
- Closed typed-reason set; the corpus's finer labels consolidate (6 disagreement
refuse-labels -> conclusion_disagreement; 4 antecedent-flavor labels ->
unestablished_antecedent — same redundancy, same mechanism-makes-one-distinction
principle).
- Honesty boundary (exact scope): guarantees a unique conclusion among SINGLE-STEP MP
over the premises, NOT "uniquely entailed" by all strategies.
Cross-check: all 24 GPT-5.5 adversarial corpus cases agree on OUTCOME against the real
rule (no rule bug / no corpus outcome-misread); reasons consolidate as above.
Mutation: filter-to-declared-first makes DISAGREE-007/010 wrongly admit -> pooling
tests fail (pooling load-bearing).
Drive-by fix (cleanup-as-you-find): merged ADR-0204 ProofNode.__post_init__ was
dedented to module level -> all ProofNode validation was silently DEAD (smoke skips
the dedicated test file; the smoke != full-suite hazard). Re-indented; validation
restored.
Additive (math lane untouched). Full binding-graph surface green; smoke 67.
Phase 2.2, structure only (no inference rule — modus_ponens is 2.3). Translates a
Proof into a SemanticSymbolicBindingGraph; the ADR-0203 acyclicity guard + ADR-0132
referential integrity fire at construction.
- generate/proof_chain/model.py: the one canonical proof input shape (ProofNode/Proof
+ proof_from_premises desugaring of the corpus premises/conclusion shape).
- generate/proof_chain/builder.py: build_proof_graph — node→symbol+equation;
canonical_key→rhs_canonical, depends_on→dependencies, rule→operation_kind;
premises = empty-deps/op="premise"; unit_proof=PROOF_NO_UNIT, admissibility="pending";
conclusion tracked as conclusion_symbol_id.
- tests: 9 — valid DAG (PC-MP-001 desugared) + multistep construct; PC-CYCLE-001
refuses THROUGH the real builder (circular_dependency); canonical_key round-trips
byte-identical + equivalent formulas share rhs_canonical; admissibility-dispatch
confirmation; self/dangling refusals; out-of-regime node refuses. Mutation-verified
(drop dep-wiring -> cycle admitted -> test fails).
Admissibility dispatch confirmed graceful on proof operation_kinds: unknown kinds
-> AdmissibilityError(unknown_operation), unitless deps -> unit_unbound; NEVER
misroutes into _check_additive. Named 2.3 constraint: check_admissibility runs
_resolve_dep_units before dispatch, so modus_ponens must bypass unit-resolution.
Open items named for 2.3 (ADR-0204): conclusion typing (BoundUnknown revisit),
semantic_role="unknown" (closed vocab has no "proposition"), unit_proof sentinel.
Additive (first consumer; math lane untouched). Full binding-graph surface green;
smoke 67. Honesty boundary: through 2.3, sound over declared atoms, not grounded in input.
