Composes v2-EN's connective grammar (if/then, or, and, either) with
v3-MEM's singular-membership sentence reading over one shared
per-individual atom space, so "If Socrates is a man then Socrates is
mortal. Socrates is a man. Therefore Socrates is mortal." decides — the
exact gap ADR-0258 §6.1 reserved. Genuinely fuses the two mechanisms: a
bare universal's instantiated atom can unify (via the same closed
morphology relation) with a connective leaf's atom, deciding arguments
neither band alone could.
- generate/proof_chain/cond_member.py: new reader. A sentence is checked
for a connective token BEFORE the universal-lead check (so a stray
connective can never leak into an opaque name/class run); reuses v3-MEM's
own _parse_singular/_parse_universal verbatim (already negation-aware,
so no separate negation layer is needed, unlike v2-EN's opaque minter).
Four new shape-bands (fused/disjunctive/chain/conditional), each earning
its own SERVE license.
- chat/deduction_surface.py: new fallback tier tried strictly after v3-MEM
— pure widening, every previously-served argument stays byte-identical.
- evals/deduction_serve/practice/gold.py: 4 new synthetic template groups
(20 templates), reusing the v3-MEM case generator; intended formulas
cross-checked against the independent oracle (INV-25).
- evals/deduction_serve/v2_condmem/: 26 hand-authored real-English cases,
content-disjoint from the synthetic corpus.
- ds-mem-0024 promoted declined -> unknown (not entailed — the antecedent
is never asserted in that text; this is the first promotion in the
corpus that doesn't land on entailed).
- Ledger re-sealed to 17 bands; deduction_serve_v1 lane SHA re-pinned
(surgical single-line edit, not a blanket --update).
Verification: core test --suite deductive 160 passed (31 new reader
tests); practice arena 17 bands x 720 wrong=0, all SERVE-licensed; lane
splits v1 28/28, v2_en 26/26, v2_member 26/26, v2_condmem 26/26; smoke 180
passed; warmed_session 10 passed. Flag deduction_serving_enabled stays
default-off.
CORE now decides natural-English deductive arguments end-to-end:
'If it rains then the ground is wet. It rains. Therefore the ground
is wet.' -> ENTAILED, rendered over the user's own clauses. Both of
ADR-0256's documented boundary cases (multiword conditional, nested-
negation contraposition) are now decided; their lane gold updated
declined->entailed.
- generate/proof_chain/english.py (new): closed function-word grammar
over OPAQUE clause-atoms (minted ids); if/then, [either] or, and,
three negation forms (leading not / sentential / copular incl.
contractions); typed refusals; honesty caps. Soundness: positive
verdicts are substitution-closed; UNKNOWN is scoped + guarded
(quantifier-led, is-a membership, unnormalizable negation refuse
out of the opaque band).
- render_entailment_english: verdicts quoted back verbatim; UNKNOWN
phrasing explicitly scoped to the opaque reading.
- chat/deduction_surface.py: v2-EN fallback tier AFTER v1/v1b —
monotone widening, byte-identical on previously-served arguments.
- Four en_* shape-bands EARN SERVE via the ADR-0199 arena (720/band,
wrong=0, reliability 0.99087 >= 0.99); 9-band ledger re-sealed.
- evals/deduction_serve/v2_en: 26 hand-authored real-English cases
(content disjoint from the synthetic lexicon), wrong=0; report
re-pinned.
- realizer guard (ADR-0075): deduction surfaces exempt — quoted
templates are not slot-composed articulations (pack 'open'=VERB
was rejecting an honest quoted 'the door is not open'); pinned
cold+warm in e2e.
[Verification]: deductive 84 passed; smoke 180 passed; cognition 122
passed 1 skipped; arena 9x720 wrong=0 all SERVE; lanes v1 28/28,
v2_en 26/26.
core chat now decides Aristotelian syllogisms end-to-end -- the marquee
'basic logical work' widening. Closes Phase 0's fork: the ONLY categorical
decider was evals/syllogism/oracle.py (the sealed independence oracle serving
must not import; INV-25). This ships a production decider.
generate/proof_chain/categorical.py lowers a categorical argument to the
propositional regime (one Boolean atom per term-membership profile) and rides
the already-verified ROBDD engine -- no new decision procedure, soundness
inherits from the flagship. Sound AND complete for the modern/Boolean reading
(Darapti + existential-import-only forms correctly INVALID), with no reliance
on a lucky domain size. Independent of the eval oracle by mechanism (ROBDD-
over-profiles vs brute-force finite-model enumeration); proven by case-for-case
agreement with it across the whole syllogism gold lane.
New: generate/proof_chain/categorical.py, render_syllogism (deterministic
valid/invalid/inconsistent templates), CATEGORICAL shape-band, arena
categorical band (4 valid forms + 2 invalid, by-construction gold cross-checked
vs the independent syllogism oracle), tests/test_categorical_decider.py (8
tests incl. the independence-by-agreement proof).
Changed: chat/deduction_surface.py (categorical branch, license-gated via a
shared _license_gate helper; propositional path byte-identical), arena
DeductionSolver dual-path in lock-step with the composer, re-sealed ledger (5
bands, categorical earns SERVE at 0.99087 wrong=0), Phase-2 lane decide()
mirrors the dual path with the 3 categorical cases reclassified to their true
valid/invalid verdicts + 1 invalid case (n 27->28), report+SHA regenerated.
Honest wrinkles: irregular plurals ('fish') decline with unknown_morphology
(a reader limit, correctly not a wrong); surfaces read in singularized terms
('all whale are animal') -- the exact ids the engine reasoned over, no cosmetic
re-pluralization that could drift from the decision.
[Verification]: smoke 180 passed; cognition 122 passed/1 skipped; core test
--suite deductive 45 passed; test_categorical_decider 8 passed; practice
runner 5 bands all SERVE wrong=0; deduction_serve lane SHA regenerates to the
committed pin.
Deduction serving stops being a bare flag and becomes an EARNED capability
governed by the ADR-0175 reliability gate over the ADR-0199 learning arena
-- the arena's second concrete instance (GSM8K math is the first) and the
reliability substrate's first non-estimation serving consumer, a concrete
dent in that zone's standing 'designed, not wired' critique.
Non-circular thesis: the ROBDD engine is sound+complete (never wrong on the
problem it's handed), so the license does NOT certify it. It certifies the
full pipeline (reader -> projector -> engine) per argument shape -- the
FALLIBLE part is the template reader, which can misparse an argument and
hand the engine the wrong problem. The arena catches that as a 'wrong' by
comparing the pipeline's committed outcome to by-construction gold.
New: generate/proof_chain/shape.py (4 exhaustive structural shape-bands, the
capability axis, shared by arena + serving), evals/deduction_serve/practice/
(the deduction arena instance: deterministic synthetic corpus, by-construction
gold independent of the reader per ADR-0199 L-2, cross-checked against the
INDEPENDENT truth-table oracle before sealing), chat/data/deduction_serve_
ledger.json (committed SHA-sealed ledger, 4 bands x 720 correct/0 wrong),
chat/deduction_serve_license.py (tamper-evident serving reader, mirrors
estimation_license.py), tests/test_deduction_serve_license.py (13 tests),
docs/adr/ADR-0256 (+ resolves the ADR-0206 numbering collision in doc form).
Changed: chat/deduction_surface.py (composer consults the license: earned
band -> authoritative Phase-1 surface; unearned/stripped ledger -> same sound
answer served DISCLOSED/hedged -- authority now rests on committed evidence,
not a boolean), core/config.py (flag docstring: enables an EARNED path),
core/cli_test.py (deductive suite runs the license test).
All four structural bands earn SERVE at reliability 0.99087 (>= theta_SERVE
0.99) with wrong=0, so Phase-1 behavior is preserved byte-for-byte; the
gate's teeth are proven by injecting an empty ledger (the same sound answer
degrades to a disclosed hedge). Did NOT reuse the ADR-0206 govern_response
bridge (its STRICT/APPROXIMATE 'widen-past-strict' semantics are the opposite
shape from deduction's always-sound answer); did NOT rewrite report.json's
stale adr field (SHA-pinned bytes, documented in ADR-0256 s2a instead).
[Verification]: smoke 180 passed; cognition 122 passed/1 skipped;
core test --suite deductive 38 passed; architectural_invariants 75 passed;
practice runner 4 bands all SERVE wrong=0.
New evals/deduction_serve/ lane scores the PRODUCTION serving decider
(the exact comprehend -> to_deductive_logic -> evaluate_entailment_with_trace
pipeline chat/deduction_surface.py runs) end-to-end from raw text --
distinct from evals/deductive_logic (bare engine vs formula strings) and
evals/comprehension/propositional_runner.py (reader fidelity vs the
independent oracle, not the production engine). This is the only lane
proving the capability core chat actually serves.
27 hand-authored cases (gold computed by independent logical reasoning,
not copied from a first engine run), 4 classes: entailed/refuted/unknown/
declined. 27/27 correct, wrong=0. Wired into core test --suite deductive
(tests/test_deduction_serve_lane.py) and SHA-pinned in
scripts/verify_lane_shas.py (deduction_serve_v1).
Honesty check during authoring: a case intended as 'entailed'
(contraposition, 'Therefore if not q then not p') actually declined --
tracing why found a genuine reader-grammar boundary (negation cannot
nest inside an if/then clause; generate/meaning_graph/reader.py's _chunk
rejects it). Reclassified to declined/out_of_band_nested_negation
(documented in contract.md) rather than forcing an artificial pass, and
added a replacement entailed case (three-hop chain) to keep coverage.
Out-of-scope finding (documented, not fixed here): running
scripts/verify_lane_shas.py --update to compute this lane's pin also
re-executed every OTHER registered lane and surfaced two pre-existing,
unrelated problems on main -- miner_loop_closure/curriculum_loop_closure/
demo_composition regenerate non-deterministic content IDs (their
committed pins don't reproduce even on a clean checkout), and public_demo
errors outright (matches the known env-timeout flake in project memory).
Reverted all four lanes' results/*.json and PINNED_SHAS entries to their
original committed values -- this PR's only PINNED_SHAS change is the new
deduction_serve_v1 entry.
[Verification]: smoke 180 passed; cognition 122 passed/1 skipped;
core test --suite deductive 25 passed; evals.deduction_serve.runner
27/27 wrong=0; pinned SHA independently re-verified against the
committed report.json bytes.
Shay