Stop-and-document outcome for issue #680's final runtime wiring. The
serving turn has no lawful in-turn ContemplationResult or provider: the
sole QUESTION_NEEDED producer (generate.contemplation.contemplate) is an
off-serving growth organ that runtime is forbidden to call, and no
plumbing carries its artifact into the turn. Wiring is deferred to a
lawful acquisition slice; chat/runtime.py is left untouched.
Rewrites the Q1-D ASK bus delivery scoping document into the durable decision record for decisions implemented in #668. No code or runtime behavior changes.
Accepts the ASK + VERIFIED serving-integration scoping briefs.
No served-surface code is introduced. ASK is identified as the next gated serving slice; VERIFIED remains blocked on a gold-free second reader and explicit eval-gold serving ban.
Resolve the one open S2-1 design decision in the doc before it leaves draft:
VERIFIED must NOT reuse ReachLevel.APPROXIMATE or the [approximate] prefix.
- §0: add the claim-vs-reach caution — VERIFIED is a disclosed-surface
*license / verification claim*, not a point further out on the speculation
scale; it is more LICENSED than strict/gold, not more speculative. Record the
principled three-axis decomposition (Disposition × DisclosureClaim × ReachLevel)
and allow v1 to collapse to a distinct ReachLevel.VERIFIED iff it carries its
own admissible-set, rationale, and [verified] prefix.
- §4: replace the open question with the settled S2-1 decision (Shay's wording):
VERIFIED gets a distinct disclosed-surface mode with its own deterministic
[verified] prefix; APPROXIMATE is for bounded estimates, VERIFIED for
independently-confirmed answers under the canonical-comparison contract.
- §1 SQ-5, §9 S2-1, §11 non-claims: propagate — only the enum shape
(distinct ReachLevel.VERIFIED vs a separate DisclosureClaim axis) is left to S2-A.
Still scoping only — NO CODE. Stays DRAFT pending Shay's design-lock.
Scope the frontier after the frozen R1–R4 comprehension ladder: the
served-surface disclosure machine and its first two tenants. Scoping
only — NO CODE.
- session doc §1.5 — the pre-question limitation pass / intake gate:
classify the limitation KIND before choosing a disposition (asking is
one of several). Key phrase: question-asking is the intake mechanism
for resolvable missing state; limitation assessment is the gate that
decides whether intake is appropriate.
- Doc 1 (primary) — the Epistemic Disclosure Bus:
EpistemicState + LimitationAssessment → ServedDisposition, two axes
(DISPOSITION × the existing ReachLevel). VERIFIED is the ONLY v1
tenant; ASK/PROPOSE/REPORT/SCOPE reserved. Grounded in the built-but-
inert ADR-0206 seam (govern_response/shape_surface; _canonically_verified
returns None at verify.py:188). Honours the 2026-06-06 dead-path
verdict: v1's VERIFIED producer is a comprehension-organ answer (R2
first, R4 second) with independence in the READING not the solving,
validate-first holdout (INV-25) BEFORE any widening, behind a new
verified_serving_enabled=False, GSM8K seal untouched.
- Doc 2 (companion) — Q1 question articulation: maps the four ASK
dispositions onto the shipped failure_family registry; the
missing_total_count / missing_weighted_total reclassification (decide
with tests, never silently re-key); the grounded-rendering wrong=0
invariant; the structured-residue-on-refusal gap; Q2 re-enters the
gate (augment + rerun, never mutate). Second bus tenant.
HOLD for review.
Records the design reached in discussion: the first real skill of contemplation
is typed, deterministic, failure-family-driven question generation. A question is
a typed request for missing state, not a conversational habit. Proposes
core/epistemic_questions/ organ (EpistemicQuestion, MissingSlot, AnswerBinding),
the QUESTION_NEEDED terminal distinct from PROPOSAL_EMITTED, and the Q1/Q2 PR
ladder. Traces the connection to the ServabilityBlade clarify mode and the
minimal-sufficient-question discipline.
Closes the CMB ladder with a docs-only lockfile. No behavior change.
- New docs/analysis/combined-rate-capability-ledger-2026-06-08.md: the frozen
R4 v1 claim, supported solved grid, solver/reader boundaries, the three
proposal-allowed deferrals, router/contemplation integration, the
domain-precedence adjudication (named, with proof cases cmb-11/15/12·13·14),
a prominent non-claims list, and the verification lanes. Every cited number
re-confirmed against the lanes: gold 19/19 (6/5/8), solver 6/0/5, reader
11/0/8 -> answers 6/0/13; the 7 R4 test files 93 passed.
- Updates comprehension-organ-capability-ledger-2026-06-08.md to fold R4 in as a
fourth organ: organ block, 4-organ router + cmb_* namespacing, a named
domain-precedence section, R4 lane rows, and a reframed deferred/next that
points the next frontier at served-surface epistemology (not more comprehension).
Honest accounting: 1 pre-existing red (test_findings_reset_between_turns) is red
on clean origin/main and imports nothing from R4 — unrelated.
Off-serving unchanged (sealed); no generate.derivation / core.reliability_gate.
The mandatory lookback before CMB-d (3+ PRs on one surface; next-phase boundary). A 5-dimension
read-only fan-out audit over the 10-item checklist found the CMB-a/b/c substrate composes cleanly:
25 solid / 4 drift / 8 gap / 1 reader hazard. Doc:
docs/analysis/cmb-lookback-review-2026-06-08.md.
Fixes the one real hazard (H3): a query attributing the answer to a SINGLE agent ('how many words
does Alice type' with a distractor second rate) wrongly claimed the substantive
combine_mode_ambiguous — a hygiene over-claim that would corrupt the shared router in CMB-d. The
combined-query gate now excludes single-agent 'does <Agent>' attribution (_SINGLE_AGENT_QUERY) and
steps aside as not_combined_rate_shaped; the genuinely-combined forms ('do they' / 'are produced' /
'does it') still yield combine_mode_ambiguous. Pinned by gold cmb-16 + a reader test.
The review also resolves the CMB-d failure-family classification (input_shape:
not_combined_rate_shaped; must_remain_refused incl. rate_unit_mismatch — DECISIVELY, the reader has
no dimension representation so it cannot tell convertible from incompatible units; proposal_allowed:
combine_mode_ambiguous, missing_second_rate) and enumerates the live CMB-d registry preconditions
(not_combined_rate_shaped mapping, rate_unit_mismatch/non_integer_solution string collisions,
non_positive_net_rate family, Organ/ALL_REASONS extension). Provenance false-alarm (stale local main
checkout) noted + verified against origin/main.
gold 19/19 (6/5/8); reader 11/0/0 + 8 refused-correct; solver 6/0 + 5/0; 0 hygiene breaches; 123
tests; serving + R1/R2/R3 unchanged.
The 2026-06-08 practice-attempts/servability-blade session note under-referenced the substrate
that already ships the serving half of its design. Doctrine ('wrong=0 = no false presentation of
epistemic status') stands; the build plan must reuse existing organs, not fork parallel ones.
Adds a binding Amendment + reframes sequencing:
- ServabilityDecision/ServabilityBlade => advance ADR-0206 core/response_governance/ (ReachPolicy /
govern_response / shape_surface, ReachLevel STRICT<APPROXIMATE<EXTRAPOLATE<CREATIVE, gated STRICT,
already disclosing [approximate]) — NOT a new object.
- the epistemic_state Literal => reuse core.epistemic_state.EpistemicState (ratified taxonomy), not
a smaller renamed enum.
- ProblemAttemptSession => extend core/comprehension_attempt/, don't fork.
- first activation = produce reserved VERIFIED via canonical comparison (scoping doc already exists),
consume through govern_response/shape_surface, prove on the yardstick, one state at a time.
Preserves the research trail (amendment, not rewrite). Docs only.
Records the wrong=0 refinement reached in discussion: wrong=0 is not a binary
answer/refuse gate but 'no false presentation of epistemic status'. Practice/
contemplation may explore typed, isolated candidate guesses; served output needs
a servability blade with more modes than verified|refuse. Proposes
ProblemAttemptSession (PRA) and ServabilityDecision (SRV), sequenced PRA -> REL ->
SRV, and traces the idea to the R1/R2/R3/CMB reader trajectory. Session doc, not
an ADR yet.
First rung of the combined-rate ladder, off-serving (imports no generate.derivation /
core.reliability_gate). Claims exactly: the combined-rate setup ruler is defined and
gold-valid. No reader/solver/wiring yet — no capability claim.
- generate/combined_rate_comprehension/: local RateUnit (decoupled from R3), CombinedRateProblem
(two-explicit-rates + per-query-slot guard; effective_rate = rate_a +/- rate_b; non-positive net
left to the solver, not the model).
- evals/combined_rate_oracle/: span-free signature (sum commutative / difference ordered) + a
NON-VACUOUS validator. 17 gold fixtures: 6 solved (full combine_mode x query grid), 4
solver_refuses, 7 reader_refuses (the complete refusal taxonomy + the 2x2 domain-entry grid).
Adversarial 5-lens verification returned fix_first; the validator now cross-checks every solved
gold and solver_refuses reason against the canonical arithmetic (_canonical_outcome) so a
mislabelled / arithmetically-impossible fixture is rejected (meaningful-fail per CLAUDE.md), with
dedicated tests. Added eff<0 and eff=0/time coverage fixtures; removed a dead determinism guard.
gold 17/17 valid; 25 oracle tests; R1/R2/R3 + router-hygiene + serving all unchanged.
Doc: docs/analysis/cmb-a-combined-rate-ruler-2026-06-08.md
Consolidation/true-up after #646-#648. Records the off-serving comprehension
system as one ledger: R1 relational arithmetic, R2 finite-integer constraints,
R3 explicit single-rate + exact minute/hour conversion, the router/contemplation/
proposal loop, the proposal-review reporter, idle_tick read-only visibility, and
the standing router-organ-hygiene invariant. Pins the whole-system lane state
(answer_wrong==0 everywhere) and the off-serving import-disjointness guarantee.
Also fixes a documentation-integrity defect the R2 batch introduced: the R2 ADR
took number 0211, which collided with ADR-0211 (Conformal Falsification Bench,
2026-06-06 — earlier, test-pinned, depended on by ADR-0216). The conformal ADR
keeps 0211; the R2 ADR is renumbered to the next free number 0217. Ratified
decision content unchanged; only the identifier and references move.
Option A (text-faithful): RateProblem gains time_unit (the duration's ORIGINAL unit; time stays int; defaults to the rate denominator). The SOLVER converts via convert_time -> exact Fraction -> int-or-refuse(non_integer); Fraction never leaves the solver, no floats. The reader accepts a convertible (minute<->hour) duration mismatch (keeps original time_unit); a non-convertible one still refuses rate_unit_mismatch. Signature includes time_unit ('30 minutes' != '30 hours').
Gold: r3-09 flips reader_refuses -> SOLVED (60 mph for 30 min = 30 mile, exact 1/2 hour; distractor 1800 rejected); new r3-13 non-convertible (3 gallons) stays rate_unit_mismatch. R3 gold 13/13; reader 9/0/0 -> answers 7/0/6 (setup_correct 8->9). Failure-family: rate_unit_mismatch now non-convertible-only -> still unsupported_rate_duration proposal surface; router-hygiene invariant stays green; R1 7/0/3, R2 10/0/0 unchanged. 119-test smoke green incl. invariants. Off-serving, no float path.
No organ may claim a substantive boundary on text outside its domain — on every OTHER organ's gold, a refusal must map to the non-substantive input_shape family (not-my-domain), never a substantive boundary/growth surface. This is what lets one organ suppress another's legitimate proposal via boundary-first (caught at N6, R3e, R3.1). MUST-PASS gate before any new organ joins route_setup. Currently green for R1/R2/R3. + standing-rule doc.
classify_r3 normalizes the rate reader into a ComprehensionAttempt; route_setup now tries R1/R2/R3 (same exactly-one-setup_correct rule); the pass manager solves+verifies a routed r3_rate setup (solve_rate + reused answer-choice verifier); unsupported_temporal_state dropped from the unsupported-family set so temporal_state -> REFUSED_KNOWN_BOUNDARY. Organ gains r3_rate.
Terminal matrix (verified): 6 solved->SOLVED_VERIFIED; rate_unit_mismatch+combined_rates->PROPOSAL_EMITTED(unsupported_rate_duration); non_integer/missing_time/temporal->REFUSED_KNOWN_BOUNDARY; exactly 2 proposals (the rate-like gaps only).
REGRESSION CAUGHT+FIXED: R3's reader returned missing_rate (a substantive boundary) on non-rate R2 text, blocking r2-011's legitimate missing_total_count proposal via boundary-first. Fix: missing_rate only when a duration is present; else not_rate_shaped -> input_shape (not-my-domain) — same discipline as the N6 category_pair_not_found fix. r2-011 proposes again; R1/R2 unaffected. R1 7/0/3, 15-case 15/0/0, R2 10/0/0, R3 8/0/0 unchanged; off-serving; 121-test smoke green incl. invariants + idle contract suites.
docs/analysis/r3-rate-inventory-ledger: R3 v1 state (reader 8/0/0 + 4 refused -> answers 6/0/6; gold 12/12), per-fixture table, the compound-unit substrate, covered families + R3.2/R3.3 deferrals.
core/comprehension_attempt/failure_family.py: makes unsupported_rate_duration REACHABLE as a growth surface (proposal_allowed) mapping rate_unit_mismatch + combined_rates — both emitted ONLY after a rate clause is recognized, so always rate-like (anti-over-propose discipline, same as the N6 fix). missing_rate/time/quantity -> rate_underdetermined boundary; temporal_state -> unsupported_temporal_state boundary (clock detector can fire on non-rate text, NOT a safe growth surface); query_target_unrecognized/no_query -> input_shape. Owner gains 'r3'. 107-test smoke green incl. partition + contemplation + invariants; R1 7/0/3 + R2 10/0/3 unchanged; off-serving.
Pins the boundary: existing idle_tick remains the only idle_tick; proposal review is read-only; NOT L10 always-on heartbeat; does not advance learning; only surfaces review obligations. Documents how IT-b works (gate, sub-pass, failure-isolation, no-did_work) and that R3 (rates/time/state) is next.
core/config.py: review_pending_proposals: bool = False (opt-in, mirrors consolidate_determinations). chat/runtime.py: IdleTickResult gains an additive optional proposal_review field; idle_tick runs a READ-ONLY sub-pass (after consolidation, gated) that surfaces core.proposal_review.idle_summary(). It does NOT set did_work / checkpoint / mutate / ratify / mount / modify readers; a reporter exception is CAPTURED (safe=False, errors=('proposal_review_failed:<type>',)), never propagated.
docs/runtime_contracts.md documents the sub-pass + field (required for runtime-surface changes). Contract tests: default-off -> proposal_review None (existing shape preserved); enabled -> summary surfaced; exception captured not propagated; read-only review never checkpoints; other passes unperturbed. 91-test smoke green incl. architectural invariants + both existing idle contract suites. Existing idle_tick remains the only idle_tick; NOT L10 always-on.
Documents the boundary: observes + reports + verifies; never advances teaching / ratifies / mounts / modifies readers / affects serving. ChatRuntime.idle_tick remains the only idle_tick (different stream, different verb). A future PR may call this reporter from idle_tick as a read-only sub-pass. L10-adjacent, NOT L10; the always-on heartbeat remains separate/unbuilt and is not claimed here.
generate/contemplation/{findings,pass_manager}.py: a single bounded pass — route (N3) -> classify+enrich (N4) -> terminal -> maybe emit proposal-only (N5). No loops/daemon/L10. Seven terminals: SOLVED_VERIFIED / REFUSED_KNOWN_BOUNDARY / REFUSED_UNSUPPORTED_FAMILY / CONTRADICTION_DETECTED / PROPOSAL_EMITTED / AMBIGUOUS_ORGAN / NO_PROGRESS. R2 solved+verified end-to-end; R1 routed setup is SOLVED_VERIFIED (numeric answer stays the eval lane in v0).
Hazard found+fixed: N6 exposed that category_pair_not_found fires on ANY non-R2 text, so mapping it to a growth surface made gibberish falsely PROPOSAL_EMITTED. Reclassified it to input_shape and made missing_category_pair reserved — only the PRECISE missing_total_count/missing_weighted_total remain reachable growth surfaces. Classification is boundary-first (input_shape non-blocking), so a problem one organ recognizes as a substantive boundary never proposes against the other's broad refusal.
Acceptance proven: known correct refusal -> no proposal; unsupported gap -> proposal-only artifact (exactly the 2 missing_* gaps over the gold); answer-key contradiction -> CONTRADICTION_DETECTED; organ conflict -> AMBIGUOUS_ORGAN. 188 tests green incl. architectural invariants; R1 7/0/3 + R2 reader 10/0/0 unchanged; off-serving.
Post-merge baseline for the contemplation batch: R1 7/0/3, R2 reader 10/0/0, gold 13/13, serving unchanged. Enumerates the full typed refusal surface across both organs (R1 reader/admissibility, R2 reader/solver/answer-choice) and a first-pass cross-organ failure-family taxonomy with must_remain_refused / proposal_allowed / owner — the table N4 will make executable. Repeats the load-bearing distinction: correct refusal != missing capability.
Records the final R2 v1 state: reader setup_correct 10 / setup_wrong 0 + 3 correct reader-refusals; 7 solved answers + 3 solver-refused + 3 reader-refused; gold 13/13. Per-fixture table, the four wrong=0 gates, the reader-vs-solver division of labor (equal coefficients are a solver refusal, not a reader one), covered families, and R3 deferrals. R1 7/0/3 and 15-case 15/0/0 unchanged.
evals/constraint_oracle: span-free canonical setup signature (unknowns/facts/constraints/query; terms merged+sorted, lhs constant folded into rhs), a 13-fixture gold (7 solved / 3 solver_refuses / 3 reader_refuses) with a closed expect+refusal taxonomy, and a gold-validation runner. No reader yet — this proves the ruler is coherent (13/13 valid), not capability.
ADR-0211 ratifies the R2 finite-integer two-category constraint compiler: the IR, the canonical signature, the closed taxonomy, the four wrong=0 gates (setup oracle / reader refusal / exact solver / answer-choice contradiction flag), off-serving disjointness, and the C1-C9 ladder. Cross-refs ADR-0207/0175/0083/0055-0057; reuses the R1 setup_oracle pattern. Off-serving (no generate.derivation / reliability_gate). 13 oracle tests incl. per-branch meaningful-fail.
r1-07 now reads setup-correct and answers 6 — 'Nia has 9 more beads than Omar. Nia has 15. -> Omar = 6'. The reader binds the unknown base's unit FROM the relation when its subject is a known fact and its referent is the otherwise-ungrounded query target, so the equation is admissible; the answer oracle reverse-solves it (PR-7a). Bounded: single base == query target (no chains), known subject value, base not otherwise grounded, <=1 inverse (multiple_inverse_bases else), never over times/divide.
R1 setup 6/0/4 -> 7/0/3; R1 answers -> 7 correct / 0 wrong; 15-case 15/0/0; setup_wrong stays 0. Off-serving. Refreshes the R1 ledger to 7/0/3 (R1 closed; the 3 remaining refusals are wrong=0 boundaries).
Baseline decision artifact at main@5ada1392 (post-#616). Records the R1
4/0/6 state per-fixture: the 4 admitted semantic families and the invariant
protecting each, and a classification of the 6 refusals — 2 pure phrasing
gaps (r1-03/r1-04 aggregate-query), 1 real reverse-solve capability (r1-07),
and 3 correct wrong=0 boundaries that must stay refused (r1-08/09/10).
Source-verified against the merged reader (refusal codes + line refs) and
the live lanes (setup 4/0/6, answers 4/0/6 setup_wrong/gold_error 0,
15-case 15/0/0). Docs-only; no code, no serving lane, no SHA-lane content.
PR-6c adds the divisive comparative frame: "half as many" read as EXACT INTEGER
DIVISION. It is the divisor twin of PR-5c's multiplicative frame, and moves the
independent R1 gold's r1-02-half from refused → correct.
No serving path touched. No rational/fractional answer support added. Non-exact
division refuses.
Design (ADR-0134 amended — divide made symmetric with multiply):
- `_check_divide` now admits a SINGLE-DEP divide-by-dimensionless-literal
(item / dimensionless = item), the exact twin of single-dep multiply. The
2-dep rate-divide path is untouched. This keeps the IR's "literal operands
are not deps" invariant (proven in PR-6a) uniform across Mul AND Div, so the
reader builds both without a per-op special case and WITHOUT synthesizing a
divisor symbol that would pollute the setup-oracle's unit signature.
- `Div(Symbol, Literal)` IR node: "ref / divisor", operation_kind "divide",
projects to `divide_by`. Divisor-only contract mirrors the scalar-only one.
- Reader: `_DIVISOR_WORDS={half:2}` slots into the same 8-token "<WORD> as many"
template as the factor words; graph carries only the two entities.
- Gold reconciliation: r1-02 placeholder `times_as_many factor 0.5` → exact
`divide_by divisor 2` (gold 4). Makes the INDEPENDENT gold integer-faithful.
The wrong=0 boundary — exact divisibility:
the oracle admits `divide_by` only when `base % divisor == 0`. An odd base
halved REFUSES (gold_error), never floors to a wrong integer. Divisor must be
a nonzero int (0, 0.5, 1.5, bool all refuse); divisor=1 is intentionally the
identity (pinned). admissibility proves DIMENSION; the oracle proves EXACT VALUE.
Meaningful-fail (CLAUDE.md Schema-Defined Proof Obligations), both verified red:
- drop the `% divisor` guard → test_oracle_refuses_non_exact_division fails (returns 3).
- disable the single-dep divide branch → the admissibility test AND the reader's
`half` test fail (admissibility refuses → reader refuses → half stays refused).
Gates:
R1 setup: 3 correct / 0 wrong / 7 refused
R1 answers: 3 correct / 0 wrong / 7 refused / setup_wrong 0 / gold_error 0
15-case setup: 15 / 0 / 0
91 PR-6c tests + 60 relational lanes + 56 architectural invariants + 502
binding-graph/proof-chain/adapter tests green. All 8 SHA-content lanes match
(serving unmoved; admissibility has no generate.derivation/reliability_gate consumer).
Scoping + holdout validation of the VERIFIED canonical-comparison producer (the
ADR-0206 §5 math-serving widening's gate). Records the empirical verdict so it is
not re-chased: on holdout_dev the fold-derivation reader is 2 correct / 87 wrong on
candidate-graph-refused cases, and a pure-chain certifier would admit 37 wrong (a
wrong=0 breach) — the train_sample 3/7 was overfit. math_verifier.verify is
solver-replay soundness, not correctness; the R1 graph reader is nested (0 flips).
Math serving is comprehension-bound; the math seam correctly stays inert; the real
lever is the general COMPREHEND organ, not a narrow GSM8K certifier. No code change.
Completes the ADR-0206 §5 math-serving deferral in its own careful PR. The GSM8K
wrong=0 serving gate, select_self_verified, now takes a ReachPolicy. This changes
NO serving behavior today — it is the safe, byte-identical, sanctioned first edit to
the most wrong=0-critical line, with a live-wiring test, so a future VERIFIED
widening has a precise, proven integration point.
Why it can't actually widen yet (the tension scoping surfaced): GSM8K wrong=0 is
ABSOLUTE (zero wrong, ever); a reliability license is STATISTICAL (a 0.99 Wilson
floor); math answers aren't disclosed like the cognition path (E). So widening the
math serve on a statistical license would eventually serve a SILENT wrong. ADR-0206
§4 foresaw this: VERIFIED is "the only state that will license widening past gold,"
and it is reserved pending a canonical-comparison pass (the soundness≠correctness
gap) that is unbuilt.
Design (safe by construction):
- select_self_verified(..., policy=STRICT_POLICY). STRICT (the default every one of
the 5 callers passes) is the prior logic verbatim — unique answer → Resolution;
zero-verify or disagreement → refuse. Byte-identical: the pinned serving-lane SHAs
(demo_composition 3a3d09f3, fabrication 01e1b6b7, math_teaching_corpus eaf160d1)
are unchanged; Resolution is unchanged; no import cycle.
- A wider reach resolves a disagreement ONLY via _canonically_verified — the VERIFIED
gate — whose body returns None (capability unbuilt). So the widening is
STRUCTURALLY inert: a disagreement refuses regardless of policy. wrong=0 holds by
construction, not caller discipline. A statistical reliability license is NOT
consulted by the math path (the cognition/math asymmetry is deliberate: cognition
discloses, math is absolute).
- test_seam_is_live_wiring injects the gate to prove the consumer fires under a wider
reach — and STRICT still refuses even then.
Verified: smoke (90), invariants (56), governance + selfverify + ms2 (354 incl. the
new seam tests), GSM8K serving regression byte-identical (the one red,
test_serving_unchanged_by_search expecting stale 6/44, fails identically on clean
main — a pre-existing stale artifact, not this change). Three-lens adversarial review
(byte-identity/seal, structural wrong=0 inertness, no-overclaim): all held.
The real unlock — a VERIFIED canonical-comparison producer — is scoped in
docs/analysis/VERIFIED-canonical-comparison-scoping-2026-06-06.md (recommended:
back-substitution / constraint-satisfaction on a checkable problem class). Still
deferred: SITUATE (stakes), the live FEED-BACK loop, reach_level JSONL emission.
The final AGI-spine step (A INSTRUMENT → B WIRE → C DEEPEN → D CLOSE → E ESTIMATION).
The engine may now SERVE a DISCLOSED estimate for a query it would otherwise refuse —
but only for a predicate-class that has measured itself reliable, and never as fact.
This executes the ADR-0206 §5 cognition-path widening: the bridge's LICENSE node
(reliability_gate.license_for), previously "built — not yet called from serving", is now
called. govern_response returns APPROXIMATE iff a genuine licensed Action.SERVE
LicenseDecision is passed (STRICT for every other input — so every existing serving call
site is byte-identical); shape_surface DISCLOSES the estimate as "[approximate] …".
Mechanism:
- generate/determine/estimate.py — a BLIND converse-guesser: told p(a,b), asked p(b,a),
it commits the converse. It never reads the pack's symmetry metadata; whether the guess
is right is MEASURED, not assumed.
- evals/determination_estimation/ — the gold lane: run_practice (sealed, ADR-0199) folds
the converse-guesser over symmetric (sibling_of) vs directed (parent_of) cases, scored
against the pack's graph.edge.symmetric truth (gold independent of the solver). The gate
DISCRIMINATES: sibling_of earns SERVE (660 correct → Wilson floor 0.990046 ≥ θ_SERVE),
parent_of does not (660 wrong → 0.0). The license is earned by VOLUME — 657 perfect
commits is the exact θ_SERVE=0.99 threshold (656 is below).
- generate/determine/data/estimation_ledger.json — the ratified committed ledger,
hash-verified on load (a hand-edited ledger raises RatifiedLedgerError); it IS the
deterministic sealed-practice output (a GSM8K-style --check test pins this).
- chat/runtime.py — when a converse query is refused and the class holds a SERVE license,
the disclosed estimate is surfaced through the bridge (gated by config.estimation_enabled,
default OFF; only meaningful with accrue_realized_knowledge).
Invariants:
- wrong=0 by construction — an estimate is ALWAYS disclosed ([approximate]), never a silent
commit (UNVERIFIED_POSSIBLE is never in APPROXIMATE's admissible set), and only a genuine
ratified license widens (a forged {"licensed":True} dict / a PROPOSE license / an
unlicensed SERVE all stay STRICT). Defense-in-depth: type-gate ∧ admissible-set ∧
hardcoded disclosed state.
- never self-authored — ceilings stay at safe defaults (θ_SERVE=0.99); the engine cannot
raise its own bar. The ledger is sealed practice, hash-verified.
- session/serving only — no corpus/pack/identity/proposal/vault mutation; the HITL teaching
path is untouched. Deterministic; no clock/random.
- byte-identical for every non-E turn (the 2643 govern_response call passes no license).
Out of scope (separate ADR-0206 §5 PRs): the math-serving seam (select_self_verified,
touches the sealed metric), SITUATE (stakes), and the live FEED-BACK loop.
Verified green: smoke (90), architectural invariants (56), response_governance (321,
incl. the new license-gated widening test), the determination-estimation lane (12), and
the B/D/determine regression net. Four-lens adversarial review (disclosure/wrong=0,
calibration integrity, byte-identity, boundary/determinism): all held. Design:
docs/analysis/E-estimation-design-2026-06-06.md.
Review/ratification pass over the 6-phase afferent environment-falsification
roadmap (rebased onto D-inclusive main). The roadmap validated green: smoke (90),
architectural invariants (56), the full sensorium suite, all phase tests, and the
four eval lanes (environment-falsification / event-vision / vision / sensorimotor)
report failed:0. A five-lens adversarial review found the efferent gate
fail-closed (default-deny, conjunctive safety∧ethics∧tool_scope, refuses before
the decoder, hash-only traces, no real decoder, no overclaim), the afferent
Phases 1-5 read-only (runtime import-guards + frozen dataclasses), and the
expected-artifact obligations deterministic + meaningfully-failing. Two
reconciliations from that review:
1. Witness-log importer trust boundary (sensorium/logs/importer.py). The offline
JSONL importer now rejects malformed input with a deterministic ValueError
instead of a raw JSONDecodeError/KeyError, names the 1-based line on a bad
JSON line, rejects non-object records and non-integer ticks, and size-caps the
file (8 MiB) so an oversized log is refused rather than read whole. The trust
boundary is now stated in the module + function docstrings. Behavior for VALID
logs is byte-identical (the environment-falsification lane hashes are
unchanged). New rejection-path tests added.
2. ADR-0198 reconciliation. The §3 verdict-enforcing GATE mechanism
(VerdictEnforcingEfferentGate + MotorActionIntent) has now landed, so the
Implementation Status is amended to say so — while being explicit that the §3
lowering itself (deriving verdicts from the ADR-0029/0033/0036/0037 governance
packs), the motor decoder (every adapter is decoder=None), and ratification by
the dedicated motor governance ADR (now drafted as ADR-0216, Proposed) all
remain deferred. No physical motor decode is authorized.
Disjoint from the GSM8K serving path and from Step D (generate/determine|realize,
chat/runtime, core/config) — clean rebase, no overlap.
CLOSE the autonomous-loop spine: when idle, the engine consolidates each
soundly-derived determination back into the held self, so the next determine()
reaches it directly and can chain one hop further. The directly-answerable set
climbs monotonically across idle ticks to the deductive-closure fixed point.
Mechanism — generate/determine/consolidate.py::consolidate_once runs ONE
semi-naive layer of the member/subset deductive closure (member∘subset → member,
subset∘subset → subset; NEVER member∘member — instance-of is not transitive).
Each one-hop conclusion not yet realized is VERIFIED by the sound+complete
proof_chain ROBDD (reusing C's single verifier _verify_subsumption) and written
back via generate/realize::realize_derived as a SPECULATIVE realized record
carrying derived-provenance (premise structure_keys + rule + the ENTAILED
verdict). idle_tick gains a consolidation pass gated by the new
config.consolidate_determinations (default OFF); IdleTickResult.facts_consolidated
reports the layer.
Invariants held:
- wrong=0 — every consolidated fact is a sound-rule conclusion confirmed by the
sound+complete decider; member∘member is structurally unreachable (a member fact
is only ever extended by a subset edge). _verify_subsumption now refuses a
mislabeled/wrong-arity path (belt-and-suspenders now that consolidation is a
second caller), so the fallacy cannot be laundered through a corrupted chain.
- honesty — a fact derived from SPECULATIVE premises stays SPECULATIVE / as-told;
the soundness of the inference never upgrades the standing of the premises.
COHERENT is never minted.
- teaching-safety — SESSION memory (immediate), an extension of the realize path;
NOT corpus mutation and NOT coupled to proposals. The HITL path is untouched.
- determinism/replay — pure function of the realized set; sorted write order;
derived structure_key identical to a told fact's; provenance round-trips through
the Shape B+ snapshot (consolidated facts resume the SAME life across reboot).
- no new normalization — writes reuse the INV-21-allowed vault writer;
algebra/versor.py keeps closure.
Falsification — evals/determination_closure: a frozen replay seeds a deep is-a
chain and runs idle ticks; asserts the closure climbs monotonically to a complete
fixed point (no-op final tick), wrong=0 (member∘member canary never derived, no
fabricated membership), all derived facts SPECULATIVE, and every derived record
re-verifies ENTAILED from its recorded premises.
Verified green: smoke, runtime, cognition, architectural invariants, plus the new
D unit + lane tests and the determine/realize/persistence regression net. Five-lens
adversarial review: 4 lenses held; the 5th (normalization) was a misattribution
(pre-existing vault reproject, triggered identically by the merged realize path,
on sanctioned null-vector storage). Design + findings: docs/analysis/
D-close-consolidation-design-2026-06-06.md.
When accrue_realized_knowledge is on and a question turn is Determined over realized
knowledge, the user-facing surface IS that answer (generate.determine.render_determination):
'Yes — as I was told, truth is a concept.' The realizer's articulation_surface is
RETAINED as evidence — the determination is a user-facing SELECTION (like the
unknown-domain gate), not a rewrite. An Undetermined turn keeps the default
articulation surface (the honest 'I don't know'); flag-off never takes this path.
Basis is rendered honestly: SPECULATIVE grounds read 'as I was told', never 'verified'
(D0 only asserts answer=True, so the surface is an affirmation — no fabricated or
asserted-False string). Selection only: no field op, no normalization, proposes no
learning (HITL untouched).
Updates docs/runtime_contracts.md selection policy + adds the contract test in the
same PR (per the surface-contract discipline).
From the mandated lookback audit of the composed R0→R1→R1c→OOV surface:
- wrong=0 HAZARD (medium): realize_quantitative trusted equation admissibility it
never checked. `comprehend_quantitative` runs real check_admissibility, but the
type does not enforce it, so a future non-reader constructor could slip a
dimensionally-incoherent 'pending'/'refused' equation into the held self (then
surfaced as-told by DETERMINE). Now RE-ASSERTS admitted-status defensively ->
NotRealized("unadmitted_equation"); docstring corrected to match (no longer claims
the type guarantees it). Bite test via a hand-built pending-equation graph.
- Defensive: wrap binding_graph hashing -> NotRealized("unhashable_structure") so a
future numeric field is a clean refusal, not an uncaught TypeError mid-write.
- Coverage (the obligations now bite, not decoration): unadmitted_equation,
not_a_quant_comprehension, no_bound_fact, grounding_failed (monkeypatched probe),
cross-substrate coexistence (meaning_graph + binding_graph in one vault — recall
isolates, structure_keys differ), and the negated_relation refusal (hand-built,
since the reader encodes declarative negation in the PREDICATE not rel.negated).
- Drift: R0 idempotency test now names the actual dedup key (structure_key, not
content_hash); scope doc notes #591 made OOV placement injective (the §0/§1
non-injectivity finding describes the pre-#591 substrate).
Note: the lookback flagged negated_relation as a high reachable-untested hazard, but
verification showed the reader never sets rel.negated=True for declaratives (it
refuses "X is not a Y" or uses some_not/disjoint predicates) — so it is a defensive
branch, tested via a hand-built graph. Green: 35 realize + ruff clean.
R0 keyed a realized fact by its subject's field versor, which is NOT injective:
two facts about one subject embed to byte-identical versors and collide at inf on
metric recall (proven). R1 adds the missing structural key.
- RealizedRecord/metadata carry ordered `relation_arguments` (the relation-space
key R0's sorted `entity_names` discards) and a span-free `structure_key`.
- `recall_realized(ctx, subject=/predicate=/content_hash=/structure_key=/
structure_kind=/entity=)` retrieves realized facts by EXACT structural metadata
(no metric / ANN), via a new read-only `VaultStore.iter_metadata()` accessor.
- Idempotency now dedups on the span-free `structure_key`, so the same proposition
told from a different source/offset collapses (R0's span-inclusive content_hash
could not). Guarded by an ambiguous-entity-name refusal — a wrong=0 defense,
since `Entity.name` is non-unique in the model (only `entity_id` is enforced).
- `content_hash` retained for provenance + replay_hash; `vault_index` pinned to the
live deque position.
Design adversarially verified (docs/analysis/REALIZE-R1-DETERMINE-scope-2026-06-06.md);
the false "established pattern" private-access comment is removed in favor of the
public accessor. wrong=0 + versor_condition<1e-6 + exact CGA recall preserved;
vault/store.py adds only a read-only accessor (no normalization). Green: 23 realize
+ 110 invariant/vault + 90 smoke; ruff check clean.
Scopes REALIZE (comprehended/told structure -> the held self with an
EpistemicStatus, persisted via Shape B+, recalled exactly) — roadmap Step 3, the
boundary that turns comprehension from an eval artifact into accumulating living
knowledge; intake ("being told") lands here.
Produced by a reconnaissance -> design -> adversarial-verification pass over the
real substrate (vault, EpistemicStatus, Shape B+ persistence, teaching/intake,
comprehension output, determinism/replay). Central finding: a realized record is a
structured vault entry (versor, metadata), NOT a new store — so it inherits exact
cga_inner recall, EpistemicStatus stamping (teaching/epistemic.py already exists),
and bit-exact snapshot/restore for free.
Defines the realized-knowledge record, the told->realize->recall->survives-reboot
contract, the composition seams (verified APIs), the obligations (wrong=0,
provenance, EpistemicStatus honesty, no forbidden normalization, no parallel
learning path, determinism), slice R0 + a falsifiable exit gate, and the design
forks/risks/open-questions.
Adversarially corrected: R0 must catch embedding KeyError/empty-decomposition ->
no-op (+ OOV grounding determinism); determinism is state-restore-based not
input-pure (versor/score are session-state-dependent); MeaningSpan (not
SourceSpanLink) is the provenance API; sharpened gate arms (history-dependence +
idempotency/placement re-run).
Execution-ready brief for the next comprehension increment (user-chosen,
doctrine-aligned): read arithmetic word-problem prose into the binding_graph
quantity substrate -> project to the independent relational_metric oracle ->
wrong=0. Reuses the existing 15-case relational_metric gold lane (no gold
authoring).
Captures the full scope from this session: the oracle grammar (fact/more_than/
fewer_than/sum_of), the new number-parsing reader capability, binding_graph
construction (SymbolBinding/BoundFact/BoundEquation with REAL admissibility — a
proof obligation, not a stamp), the direct-construction recommendation (keep the
comprehension organ disjoint from the GSM8K MathProblemGraph / serving path), the
projector, wiring, the generative round-trip anti-overfit test, and the
validation gates.
Briefed rather than rushed: this is binding_graph's first comprehension consumer,
a load-bearing integration whose correctness hinges on real equation
admissibility — it deserves fresh context, per "no shortcuts on architectural
gaps".
Spike falsified §5's assumption: en_core_syntax_v1 is a 24-entry lexicon of
grammatical terminology, not a parser. No general structural parser exists.
The field's Proposition already decodes S-P-O but FrameRegistry.select never
refuses (confabulation hazard). New load-bearing fork: Path alpha (field
standing-hand + refusal floor) vs beta (build a minimal parser). Recommend
alpha. Updated section 5 and section 9.
Scope-before-build for the AGI-roadmap make-or-break phase (COMPREHEND).
Honest substrate map: the reasoners (binding-graph/proof_chain/grammars) and
the articulation path (PropositionGraph) are built, but no organ turns general
NL into reasoning-ready structure. Recommends Option B (a general MeaningGraph
the existing structures project into), syntax-keyed parse-or-refuse reader,
cross-domain proof on the Phase-1 yardstick, and the overfit-trap guardrails.
No code.
Commits the design/analysis artifacts produced while building the lived spine and
planning the next arc (the work itself already merged in #563-#573):
- AGI-candidacy-autonomous-improvement-roadmap-2026-06-05.md — the path from the
lived spine to AGI-candidacy: the comprehend→realize→determine→learn loop, the
cross-domain capability+calibration yardstick, the logical-necessity × technical-
priority execution order, and the corrected epistemic foundation (grounded
honesty designed-in; estimation learned/ratified; confidence always evidence-
grounded; intake first-class — NOT "no ingestion"; calibration+grounding the
measured invariant).
- L10-runtime-scoping + L10-continuity-spike-design — the L10 decision surface and
the falsifiable spike spec (P1-P5) that became evals/l10_continuity/.
- L10-shapeBplus-persistence-scope — the A->E scope that became Shape B+ resume.
.gitignore: ignore the local .system-map/ navigation index (per-developer, never
tracked; regenerated on demand).
