Commit graph

1 commit

Author SHA1 Message Date
Shay
eed20749db
docs(handoff): Step-3 relational-reasoning brief pack (OWA → transitive → finite-verb → FrameVerdict) (#777)
* docs(handoff): Step-3 relational-reasoning brief pack

Four parallel-safe briefs continuing the comprehend->determine arc after #775
(one-hop relational inference, breadth 10). Ordered OWA-first per the merge-safety
sequencing — harden unknown!=false before transitive/closed-world stress it:

1. ProofWriter-OWA refusal-floor lane (measure-only; standalone wrong=0 gate, NOT a
   capability-index domain) — dispatch first.
2. Transitive relational chains (strict-order predicates only; reuses the proof_chain
   ROBDD search-then-verify; non-transitive predicates must refuse).
3. overlaps_event finite-verb reader surface (closes #775's known coverage gap).
4. FrameVerdict / two-sided closed-world — DESIGN ONLY, gated behind brief 1 landing
   and design ratification; no answer=False path, INV-30 preserved.

Each brief carries the shared acceptance gates (independent oracle, pos+neg fixtures,
capability-index movement, replay-stable, wrong=0, INV-30 green, no template spam) +
dispatch lines. B1/B2/B3 are file-disjoint and parallel-safe; B4 is gated.

* docs(handoff): tighten Step-3 brief dispatch semantics

* docs(handoff): address gemini-code-assist review on the Step-3 brief pack

- B1 (OWA): gold extended to {True, Unknown, False}; include gold-False items
  (negation entailed). determine() is True-or-refuse, so asserting True on ANY
  non-True gold (Unknown OR False) is the wrong=0 breach — strengthens the floor.
- B2 (transitive): inside_of + during_event are ALSO transitive (containment);
  now explicitly DEFERRED from the first cut (admit only with their own confuser
  fixtures), not silently omitted.
- B3 (finite-verb): added the finite-verb QUERY surface as scope — _read_relational_clause
  requires questions to start with 'is', so an overlaps_event query is unparseable
  today; pin one interrogative form (Does A overlap B?) and fail-closed, else the
  symmetric case refuses and yields no coverage.
2026-06-15 12:08:06 -07:00