The widened 100-pack tour surfaced four packs whose closings bucket
included a bare '.' entry: assertive_v1, blunt_v1, dry_v1, and
mathematical_v1. Seeded variation selects from buckets uniformly, so
roughly 1/N of turns would emit a '..'-style surface artefact
(e.g. 'Truth is what is true..') when '.' was selected and appended
to a surface CORE's deterministic realizer already terminated with
'.'.
This commit:
* Strips the bare '.' entry from the four affected packs' closings.
The remaining entries (e.g. ' — qed.', ' — that's it.', '') all
carry their own leading separator, so concatenation produces a
clean surface.
* Re-runs scripts/ratify_register_packs.py to re-seal each pack's
mastery_report.json with a fresh pack_source_sha256 and
self_seal_sha256 — these companion files are part of the diff
because pack content changed.
* Adds _validate_discourse_markers_shape() to
scripts/ratify_register_packs.py as defense in depth. The new
R4-tier gate refuses any closing entry whose first character is
bare sentence-final punctuation ('.', '!', '?', ';', ':') or an
alphanumeric — both classes would produce concatenation artefacts.
Ellipsis ('...', '…') is explicitly exempt as a legitimate
stylistic ending.
Verified:
* core eval cognition byte-identical (the eval runs unregistered)
* tests/test_cognition_eval_register_matrix.py: 801 passed in 5:23
(100 registers × 8 projection invariants + meta-test), confirming
the closing fix did not perturb ADR-0072 trace_hash invariance
or any per-case projection.
* Hand-verification across {assertive,blunt,dry,mathematical}_v1
× 4 prompts = 16 surfaces: 0 remaining double-period artefacts.
* Re-running ratify against a re-introduced bad closing produces
SystemExit with the new gate's diagnostic message.
mathematical_v1 now reads beautifully under "What is light?":
"Lemma: Light is visible medium that reveals truth. — qed."
* feat(packs/register): materialise A_depth drafted registers
Lands 3 drafted depth registers, dominated by disclosure-domain count and structural compression/expansion knobs; the sealed reports keep grounding_source and trace_hash byte-identical to the unregistered path. Also aligns the smoke contract assertion with the current pack-grounded unknown evidence split.
* feat(packs/register): materialise B_tone drafted registers
Lands 15 drafted tone registers, dominated by bounded affective opening and closing marker palettes; the sealed reports keep grounding_source and trace_hash byte-identical to the unregistered path.
* feat(packs/register): materialise C_stance drafted registers
Lands 11 drafted stance registers, dominated by epistemic posture markers plus light deterministic depth clauses; the sealed reports keep grounding_source and trace_hash byte-identical to the unregistered path.
* feat(packs/register): materialise D_posture drafted registers
Lands 10 drafted posture registers, dominated by role-shaped marker families for peer, mentor, scholar, practitioner, and related voices; the sealed reports keep grounding_source and trace_hash byte-identical to the unregistered path.
* feat(packs/register): materialise E_domain drafted registers
Lands 11 drafted domain registers, dominated by academic, executive, technical, legal, scientific, and philosophical marker families with bounded known-key knobs; the sealed reports keep grounding_source and trace_hash byte-identical to the unregistered path.
* feat(packs/register): materialise F_cultural drafted registers
Lands 12 drafted cultural registers, dominated by plainspoken, diplomatic, classic, contemporary, and lyrical marker palettes; the sealed reports keep grounding_source and trace_hash byte-identical to the unregistered path.
* feat(packs/register): materialise G_affective drafted registers
Lands 10 drafted affective registers, dominated by cheerful, somber, grave, wry, gentle, and earnest marker families; the sealed reports keep grounding_source and trace_hash byte-identical to the unregistered path.
* feat(packs/register): materialise H_functional drafted registers
Lands 10 drafted functional registers, dominated by documentary, instructional, persuasive, clarifying, comparing, and exemplifying marker families; the sealed reports keep grounding_source and trace_hash byte-identical to the unregistered path.
* feat(packs/register): materialise I_composite drafted registers
Lands 11 drafted composite registers, dominated by combined knob and marker families for tutorial, interview, briefing, lecture, memo, story, elegy, epigram, and manifesto voices; the sealed reports keep grounding_source and trace_hash byte-identical to the unregistered path.
Round-2 (PR #48) bumped ISSUED_AT in scripts/ratify_register_packs.py
from 2026-05-19 → 2026-05-20 but didn't re-seal existing packs; also
shipped formal_v1 and socratic_v1 with empty mastery_report_sha256 (no
companion .mastery_report.json on disk).
This commit:
- Re-seals all 7 register packs against current ISSUED_AT.
- Adds companion seal files for formal_v1 + socratic_v1 (now ratified).
- Patches both ratify scripts to use ensure_ascii=False when writing
pack/report files to disk — previous default mangled literal em-dashes
to — escapes every time the script ran, producing churn.
Canonical hash form unchanged (still ensure_ascii=True for stability).
Cognition eval byte-identical (100/100/91.7/100).
Register tour green (R5 + R6 invariants hold).
* feat(packs): ethics ×3, anchor-lens ×3, relations-v3, register ×2
Group 1 — Ethics domain packs (ADR-0044 sibling)
legal_ethics_v1: 6 commitments covering no-legal-advice, no-outcome-prediction,
jurisdiction-disclosure, privilege-disclosure, conflict-disclosure, refer-to-counsel
engineering_ethics_v1: 6 commitments covering safety-primacy, standard-disclosure,
no-sign-off, uncertainty-surface, public-welfare-priority, refer-to-pe
research_ethics_v1: 6 commitments covering no-fabrication, no-plagiarism,
irb-disclosure, conflict-of-interest-disclosure, data-integrity, reproducibility-hedge
ratify_ethics_pack.py: PACK_IDS extended with all three new ids
Group 2 — Anchor lens packs (grc cognition atoms, ADR-0073c)
grc_sophia_v1: atom logos.sophia.wisdom via grc-core-cog-008 (cross_lang.logos.sophia
edge weight 0.88); cognitive mode wisdom-practical
grc_epignosis_v1: atom logos.epignosis.experiential via grc-core-cog-007 (weight 0.78,
en_collapse edge documented); cognitive mode experiential-knowledge
grc_episteme_v1: atom logos.episteme.systematic via grc-core-cog-021 (weight 0.72,
en_collapse edge documented); cognitive mode systematic-knowledge
ratify_anchor_lens_packs.py: LENS_IDS extended with all three new ids
Group 3 — en_core_relations_v3 (social + part-whole extension of v2 kinship)
7 new lemmas: colleague, mentor, neighbor, component, member, instance, peer
manifest.json: new pack with checksum placeholder (operator must recompute after
ratify run — same pattern as other packs)
Group 4 — Register packs formal_v1 + socratic_v1
formal_v1: standard depth, drop_provenance_tag=true + drop_articles=true;
no markers; ratifies under known_key_overrides_invariant_grounding
socratic_v1: pedagogical depth, append_semantic_domain_clause=true; markers scaffold
question-and-response rhythm (openings×4, transitions×3, closings×4)
ratify_register_packs.py: REGISTER_IDS extended with formal_v1, socratic_v1
* fix(anchor_lens): loader v1/v2 dual-schema compat — resolves blocker 1 of #48
Refactor AnchorLens to use v2 schema fields and normalize legacy fields. Update validation and loading functions for improved clarity and functionality.
* fix(ratify): restore default_unanchored_v1 + full LENS_IDS (17) — resolves blocker 2 of #48
Added new lens IDs for the he substrate and updated the order of lens IDs.
* chore(packs): migrate 8 legacy anchor-lens packs to v2 schema [1/8 default_unanchored_v1]
Updated the default unanchored lens JSON structure with new fields and modified descriptions.
* chore(packs): migrate grc_logos_v1 to v2 schema [2/8]
Updated the description and added new fields for cognitive mode, atom, and source entry ID.
* chore(packs): migrate grc_aletheia_v1 to v2 schema [3/8]
Updated the description and added new fields related to cognitive mode and atom.
* chore(packs): migrate grc_zoe_v1 to v2 schema [4/8]
Updated the description and added new fields for cognitive mode, atom, and source entry ID.
* chore(packs): migrate grc_arche_v1 to v2 schema [5/8]
Updated the description and added new fields for cognitive mode, atom, and source entry ID.
* chore(packs): migrate he_logos_v1 to v2 schema [6/8]
Updated the Hebrew-substrate anchor lens JSON structure with new fields and modified descriptions.
* chore(packs): migrate he_dabar_v1 to v2 schema [7/8]
Updated the description and added new fields for cognitive mode and source entry.
* chore(packs): migrate he_chayyim_v1 to v2 schema [8/8] — resolves blocker 3 of #48
Updated the description and added new fields for cognitive mode and source entry ID.
* fix(anchor-lens): complete v1→v2 migration + back-compat shims
Resolves blockers B4/B5/B6/B7 left by the initial round-2 schema rewrite:
B4: restore UNANCHORED module constant, is_null_lens() alias,
and verify_anchor_lens_seal() (all were dropped from loader.py;
chat/pack_grounding.py and several tests still imported them).
AnchorLens.unanchored() returns the in-memory sentinel with
lens_id='__unanchored__' as before (distinct from disk pack).
B5: add v1 attribute properties on AnchorLens (primary_substrate,
semantic_domain_preferences, cognitive_mode_label) so consumers
not yet on v2 (chat/pack_grounding.py engagement reads, several
tests) continue to work via read-only views over the canonical
v2 fields. Zero changes needed to chat/pack_grounding.py.
B6: re-derive source_entry_id by atom-in-lexicon lookup for 6 of 8
legacy packs that were positionally mis-mapped during migration.
B7: fix two new-pack atoms that didn't exist in the lexicon
(logos.episteme.systematic -> logos.episteme.systematic_knowledge,
logos.epignosis.experiential -> logos.epignosis.knowledge).
Loader hardening (recovered from v1 rewrite):
- _validate_lens_id_for_fs: reject path-traversal / slash / empty
- companion-SHA mismatch check in load_anchor_lens when require_ratified
- atom must be non-empty when substrate != 'none'
- available_anchor_lens_packs returns summary dicts (was list[str])
Ratify script special-cases substrate='none' so the null sentinel
default_unanchored_v1 keeps its self-seal (ADR-0073b invariant).
Test suite migrated to v2 schema: dropped obsolete list-shape gates
(duplicates, too-many-preferences — v2 has scalar atom), updated error
match strings, added a v1->v2 normalisation back-compat test.
All 11 round-2 packs ratified. 102/102 anchor-lens tests pass.
Cognition eval byte-identical (100/100/91.7/100).
anchor-lens-tour + register-tour both green.
* feat(packs): add pedagogical_v1, precise_v1 register packs + 5 new anchor lens packs
Register packs:
- pedagogical_v1: fills the reserved 'pedagogical' depth tier (loader had it in
_ALLOWED_DEPTH_PREFERENCES since R1 with zero packs using it). Socratic markers
in openings/closings; transitions scaffold inquiry progression.
- precise_v1: standard depth, disclosure_domain_count=2 override. Focused output
(two semantic domains vs default three) with no discourse markers. Distinct from
terse_v1 (which forces count=1) and default_neutral_v1 (which has no overrides).
Anchor lens packs (all grc or he substrate, all atoms confirmed in
language_packs/data lexicons):
- grc_zoe_v1: logos.vitality.animate — animate-vitality pole, grc substrate
- grc_aletheia_v1: logos.aletheia.verity — unconcealment pole, grc substrate;
dual-correction pair with he_logos_v1 (same atom, different substrate + mode)
- grc_arche_v1: logos.genesis.origin — generative-origin pole, completes grc quad
- he_dabar_v1: logos.utterance.word — divine-word pole, he substrate;
dual-correction pair with grc_logos_v1 (same atom, different substrate + mode)
- he_chayyim_v1: logos.vitality.animate — covenant-life pole, he substrate;
dual-correction pair with grc_zoe_v1
Also updates ratify scripts to include all new IDs in REGISTER_IDS / LENS_IDS
tuples so ratify_*.py picks them up on next run.
All packs ship with mastery_report_sha256='' — operator runs ratify scripts
after merge to seal. No schema changes; all fields within existing loader bounds.
* fix(packs): wire R6 boolean knobs into precise_v1 + pedagogical_v1; widen R4 gate
Precise: add drop_provenance_tag=true — formal output drops the meta-tag,
making it substantively distinct from default_neutral_v1 on the gloss
path (not just the rare no-gloss disclosure surface).
Pedagogical: add append_semantic_domain_clause=true — expands the gloss
with full semantic domain context, giving the learner cognitive anchor
points. Pairs with the existing Socratic markers for a genuinely
distinct substantive+presentational posture.
ratify_register_packs.py: widen _KNOWN_OVERRIDE_KEYS to include the four
R6 boolean knobs (drop_provenance_tag, compress_gloss, drop_articles,
append_semantic_domain_clause). Validator: isinstance(v, bool). This
anticipates R6 landing on main — the R4 gate must know the keys before
the packs can ratify. All four keys are informational-only in _KNOWN_OVERRIDE_KEYS
until the realizer dispatch code in R6 actually reads them; the gate
just needs to not refuse them.
R5 (ADR-0072) shipped the register *machinery*; ADR-0074's orthogonality
tour proved the axis was decoratively orthogonal to anchor-lens but
inspection of the cognition-eval surfaces revealed two structural gaps:
* On pack-grounded DEFINITION/RECALL/COMPARISON composers, the only
realizer override any register consumed was `disclosure_domain_count`
— which only fires on the no-gloss disclosure path. Under terse_v1,
every gloss-DEFINITION cell was byte-identical to default_neutral_v1.
* The register-tour's `surfaces_vary_at_least_once` gate could be
satisfied by convivial's decorative wrapper alone, masking that
regression in CI.
R6 closes both:
Layering separation (the load-bearing fix):
* New TurnEvent/ChatResponse field `register_canonical_surface` carries
the composer output BEFORE any register transformation. The pipeline
hashes this field for `trace_hash`, preserving R5's invariant that
per-prompt trace_hash is CONSTANT across registers even while
substantive transforms produce visibly different surfaces.
Substantive transforms (`chat/register_substantive.py`):
* terse_v1 gains 3 bool knobs: `drop_provenance_tag`, `compress_gloss`,
`drop_articles` — all pure regex transforms on the canonical surface.
* convivial_v1 gains `append_semantic_domain_clause` — appends a single
bounded "Related: <atom>." clause using the lemma's pack atoms.
* default_neutral_v1 leaves overrides empty; substantive transform is
byte-identical no-op (preserves `byte_identity_null_lift`).
* C1 (ADR-0075) safety preserved: drop_articles refuses to drop
articles following `not` (avoids R3 violations); no knob combination
trips R2/R3.
Strengthened tour gate (`evals/register_tour/run_tour.py`):
* Replaces `surfaces_vary_at_least_once` with two falsifiable claims:
- `terse_substantively_differs_from_neutral_on_pack_grounded_definition`
- `convivial_substantively_differs_from_neutral_on_pack_grounded_definition`
Both restrict to DEFINITION+pack-grounded cells and require
difference beyond whitespace/punctuation.
* New claim `register_canonical_surfaces_identical` directly proves
the layering separation.
* Preserves R5's `all_grounding_sources_identical` +
`all_trace_hashes_identical`.
Pack ratification:
* Loader widened to accept `bool` for closed-set R6 keys
(drop_provenance_tag / compress_gloss / drop_articles /
append_semantic_domain_clause).
* `_KNOWN_OVERRIDE_KEYS` ratify gate extended with same.
* terse_v1 + convivial_v1 reratified with new knobs; companion
mastery reports re-sealed. default_neutral_v1 unchanged.
Invariants pinned:
* `invariant_register_canonical_surface_constant_across_registers` (new)
* `invariant_terse_substantively_distinct_from_neutral` (new)
* `invariant_convivial_substantively_distinct_from_neutral` (new)
* `invariant_realizer_no_illegal_articulation` (C1, preserved)
* `invariant_realizer_guard_byte_identity_on_currently_passing_cases`
(C1, preserved)
Verification:
* `core eval cognition`: 100.0% / 91.7% / 100.0% / 100.0% — byte-
identical under default_neutral_v1.
* `core demo register-tour`: all 5 claims green, exit 0.
* `core demo anchor-lens-tour`: green (no anchor-lens code touched).
* `core demo orthogonality-tour`: green (5/5 claims).
* Full lane: 2858 passed, 1 pre-existing failure
(test_all_preamble_explains_combined_run, carried forward
unchanged from main). 56 new R6 tests across three files.
Shay