* feat(epistemic): add first-class state enums
* feat(epistemic): tag TurnEvent with state axes
* feat(epistemic): serialize turn state axes
* feat(packs): tag curated and inferred unit entries
* feat(epistemic): expose word-level state on manifold
* feat(epistemic): expose vault status mapping
* feat(epistemic): preserve pack entry states through compiler
* test(epistemic): cover phase 3 state tagging spine
* feat(runtime): wire epistemic_state + normative_clearance into ChatResponse
Add first-class epistemic_state and normative_clearance fields to
ChatResponse (defaulting to "undetermined"/"unassessable" for backward
compat). Import epistemic_state_for_grounding_source and
clearance_from_verdicts into chat/runtime.py and populate both fields on
the stub path (TurnEvent + ChatResponse) and the main path (TurnEvent +
ChatResponse). Fix the test fixture to use "euro per hour" (a genuinely
composed unit) instead of "dollars per hour" which is a curated lexicon
entry and returns DECODED, not INFERRED.
* test(cognition): update term_capture_rate baseline from 0.9167 to 1.0
unknown_logos_019 now correctly surfaces "light" as a pack-resident
token near the logos versor — producing term_capture_rate 1.0 on both
main and Phase 3. The 0.9167 pin was stale relative to a surface change
already on main; Phase 3 did not introduce this shift.
Wires observational telemetry on the composer-vs-graph atom-set
relationship. Phase 1 is strictly observational: no enforcement,
no surface mutation, no grounding-source change, no trace-hash impact.
New telemetry fields on TurnEvent + ChatResponse:
composer_graph_atom_status ∈ {equivalent, divergent,
graph_unconstrained,
composer_no_atoms,
not_applicable, ""}
composer_atom_set_hash SHA-256 over sorted unique atoms
graph_atom_set_hash SHA-256 over sorted unique atoms
composer_graph_atom_overlap_count int
Composer atoms come from existing pack candidate metadata
(pack_semantic_domains channel through _maybe_pack_grounded_surface).
Graph atoms come from build_graph_from_input + resolve_lemma on
node.subject/predicate/obj — no prose parsing. When a grounded
composer path lacks explicit atom provenance, status is
'composer_no_atoms'.
New pure helper:
chat/atom_equivalence.py — normalize_atoms, hash_atoms,
atoms_for_graph_nodes, compare_atom_sets
Tests (tests/test_composer_graph_atom_equivalence.py):
- Pack DEFINITION path produces observable equivalence
- Divergent atom sets produce distinct hashes
- Register invariance: atom hashes + status identical across
{neutral, terse, convivial}; trace_hash also constant (R5 axis)
- Anchor lens engaged case still ASCII-only on surface
- No prose-parsing helper symbols introduced in runtime.py
(extract_candidate_surface_lemmas, surface_lemma,
parse_surface_atoms) — enforces Phase 1 boundary
Performance note: build_graph_from_input now runs on every warm
English turn (previously only when forward_graph_constraint=True).
Phase 1 accepts this cost to make the telemetry universally
available; Phase 2+ can introduce a feature flag if needed.
Validation:
- Cognition eval byte-identical: 100/100/91.7/100
- Full lane: 2864 passed, 3 skipped, 0 failed (+5 over baseline)
- Targeted lane: 72 passed in tests/test_{graph_constraint,
pack_grounding,register_tour_demo,anchor_lens_tour_demo,
orthogonality_tour_demo,realizer_guard_holdout,
composer_graph_atom_equivalence}.py
R5 (ADR-0072) shipped the register *machinery*; ADR-0074's orthogonality
tour proved the axis was decoratively orthogonal to anchor-lens but
inspection of the cognition-eval surfaces revealed two structural gaps:
* On pack-grounded DEFINITION/RECALL/COMPARISON composers, the only
realizer override any register consumed was `disclosure_domain_count`
— which only fires on the no-gloss disclosure path. Under terse_v1,
every gloss-DEFINITION cell was byte-identical to default_neutral_v1.
* The register-tour's `surfaces_vary_at_least_once` gate could be
satisfied by convivial's decorative wrapper alone, masking that
regression in CI.
R6 closes both:
Layering separation (the load-bearing fix):
* New TurnEvent/ChatResponse field `register_canonical_surface` carries
the composer output BEFORE any register transformation. The pipeline
hashes this field for `trace_hash`, preserving R5's invariant that
per-prompt trace_hash is CONSTANT across registers even while
substantive transforms produce visibly different surfaces.
Substantive transforms (`chat/register_substantive.py`):
* terse_v1 gains 3 bool knobs: `drop_provenance_tag`, `compress_gloss`,
`drop_articles` — all pure regex transforms on the canonical surface.
* convivial_v1 gains `append_semantic_domain_clause` — appends a single
bounded "Related: <atom>." clause using the lemma's pack atoms.
* default_neutral_v1 leaves overrides empty; substantive transform is
byte-identical no-op (preserves `byte_identity_null_lift`).
* C1 (ADR-0075) safety preserved: drop_articles refuses to drop
articles following `not` (avoids R3 violations); no knob combination
trips R2/R3.
Strengthened tour gate (`evals/register_tour/run_tour.py`):
* Replaces `surfaces_vary_at_least_once` with two falsifiable claims:
- `terse_substantively_differs_from_neutral_on_pack_grounded_definition`
- `convivial_substantively_differs_from_neutral_on_pack_grounded_definition`
Both restrict to DEFINITION+pack-grounded cells and require
difference beyond whitespace/punctuation.
* New claim `register_canonical_surfaces_identical` directly proves
the layering separation.
* Preserves R5's `all_grounding_sources_identical` +
`all_trace_hashes_identical`.
Pack ratification:
* Loader widened to accept `bool` for closed-set R6 keys
(drop_provenance_tag / compress_gloss / drop_articles /
append_semantic_domain_clause).
* `_KNOWN_OVERRIDE_KEYS` ratify gate extended with same.
* terse_v1 + convivial_v1 reratified with new knobs; companion
mastery reports re-sealed. default_neutral_v1 unchanged.
Invariants pinned:
* `invariant_register_canonical_surface_constant_across_registers` (new)
* `invariant_terse_substantively_distinct_from_neutral` (new)
* `invariant_convivial_substantively_distinct_from_neutral` (new)
* `invariant_realizer_no_illegal_articulation` (C1, preserved)
* `invariant_realizer_guard_byte_identity_on_currently_passing_cases`
(C1, preserved)
Verification:
* `core eval cognition`: 100.0% / 91.7% / 100.0% / 100.0% — byte-
identical under default_neutral_v1.
* `core demo register-tour`: all 5 claims green, exit 0.
* `core demo anchor-lens-tour`: green (no anchor-lens code touched).
* `core demo orthogonality-tour`: green (5/5 claims).
* Full lane: 2858 passed, 1 pre-existing failure
(test_all_preamble_explains_combined_run, carried forward
unchanged from main). 56 new R6 tests across three files.
C1 coherence floor: a deterministic verifier that runs on every
candidate surface produced by the truth path, before assignment to
ChatResponse.surface. Rejects illegal articulations and routes them
to a bounded disclosure string — admission control with a
deterministic fallback, not normalization.
Active rules (R1 deferred during ratification — see ADR):
R2_aux_neg_requires_verb — "<aux> not <wrong-POS>" rejected
R3_be_neg_requires_predicate — "<be> not <verb>" rejected
Fail-open on unknown POS, fail-closed on explicit wrong POS.
Cognition eval byte-identical (100/91.7/100/100).
Original bug class — "Light reveals truth, right?" → "Right does not
thought." — now routes to "I do not have a reviewed articulation for
that yet." with grounding_source=none, walk_surface preserving the
rejected candidate, and telemetry carrying R2_aux_neg_requires_verb.
Files:
generate/realizer_guard.py NEW — pure verifier
chat/runtime.py hook on stub + main paths
chat/telemetry.py serialize guard fields
core/physics/identity.py TurnEvent +2 fields
evals/realizer_guard/run_holdout.py NEW — 6-prompt cluster
tests/test_realizer_guard_*.py NEW — 46 tests (unit/seam/holdout)
docs/decisions/ADR-0075-*.md NEW — ratified
Invariants pinned:
invariant_realizer_no_illegal_articulation
invariant_realizer_guard_byte_identity_on_currently_passing_cases
Lanes (excluding 1 pre-existing TestDemoPreambles failure unrelated
to C1, already present at 4426f38):
smoke 67/67 cognition 120/120(+1s) teaching 17/17
packs 6/6 runtime 19/19 algebra 132/132 full 2792/2793
`ChatRuntime.correct()` propagates a backward perturbation through the
session graph (per session/correction.py): each past turn whose output
versor has non-trivial CGA-alignment with the correction versor is
blended toward it (decayed by graph distance). The forward regen turn
that followed already emitted a TurnEvent — but the backward
perturbation itself was invisible to the telemetry sink.
ADR-0059 closes that gap with a discriminated event line.
- chat/telemetry.py — adds `serialize_correction_event` +
`format_correction_event_jsonl` emitting one JSONL line discriminated
by `"type": "correction"`. Payload: target_turn, records_count,
turns_skipped, turn_idxs_affected, max_delta_norm, mean_delta_norm,
SHA-256 correction_versor_digest, pack ids. No raw versor coordinates.
- chat/runtime.py — `_emit_correction_event` (mirrors
`_emit_turn_event`); called from `correct()` after the graph state
is updated but before the forward regen turn. No-op without sink.
- tests/test_correction_telemetry.py — 7 tests pin: no-op without
sink, emission with sink, payload shape (required keys + types +
ranges), SHA-256 digest shape, trust boundary (no versor
coordinates leaked), determinism (byte-identical lines across
runs), correction event and turn event coexist in the sink.
Trust boundary (per CLAUDE.md):
- Metadata-only: only L2 deltas + SHA-256 digest.
- No implicit wall-clock.
- Deterministic: same CorrectionResult → byte-identical line.
- Sink contract unchanged: `emit(line: str)`.
- `versor_condition < 1e-6` invariant: untouched (telemetry-only).
Verification: smoke 67 / runtime 19 / correction telemetry 7 — green.
Two thin layers closing the audit story end-to-end:
- core chat --show-verdicts prints format_verdict_summary(verdicts)
to stderr after each turn. Stdout stays clean for piped
consumers. Format is dense and terse; designed to skim, not
machine-parseable (the JSONL sink owns that contract).
- FanOutSink forwards every emitted line to N sinks in declaration
order. Fail-fast on first error — consistent with ADR-0040's
single-sink contract (audit failures surface). Composes with
any combination of JsonlFileSink / JsonlBufferSink / future
sinks.
Two formatters, one bundle: format_turn_event_jsonl (machine,
ADR-0040) and format_verdict_summary (operator, ADR-0041) both
consume the same TurnVerdicts. No risk of drift.
Summary format:
[identity=0.83 safety=ok ethics=VIOLATED:foo refusal=- hedge=YES]
Audit story now reads end-to-end:
- TurnVerdicts bundle (ADR-0039)
- Machine JSONL sink (ADR-0040)
- Fan-out + operator CLI (ADR-0041)
Files:
- chat/telemetry.py — FanOutSink dataclass, format_verdict_summary,
_format_verdict_short helper
- core/cli.py — --show-verdicts on chat subparser; cmd_chat prints
summary to stderr when set
- tests/test_telemetry_fanout_and_summary.py (new) — 13 tests
- docs/decisions/ADR-0041-cli-verdicts-and-fanout.md (new)
Verification:
- Combined pack-layer + telemetry suite: 212 green (was 199; +13)
- CLI suites unchanged: smoke 67, runtime 19, cognition 121
- core eval cognition: intent 100%, versor_closure 100% (baseline)
- Manual smoke: echo "light is" | core chat --show-verdicts prints
expected bracketed audit line to stderr alongside response.
Shay