The speculative-marker cache seeds a subject AND each >=4-char token split from
it, so two independent proposals can claim the same token ("wisdom" from both
`wisdom` and `practical wisdom`). `_forget_speculative_subject` popped the token
outright on COHERENT promotion — regardless of which proposal had seeded it — so
promoting one proposal stripped the marker from another that was still
unreviewed. Unreviewed material was then served WITHOUT the "(speculative, not
yet reviewed)" prefix: the expensive failure direction, on the surface whose
whole job is telling reviewed knowledge from unreviewed.
_speculative_subjects becomes OrderedDict[str, int] — the value is a reference
count. Seeding increments and refreshes LRU position; promotion decrements and
evicts at zero. Seeding and eviction walk the same source list so counts
balance; where they disagree the count stays positive and the subject keeps its
marker, which is the honest direction to fail. An unmatched release floors at
removal and never goes negative, so it cannot borrow against a later proposal's
claim. The LRU cap survives unchanged as a size valve.
Four new pins in tests/test_speculative_subject_lifecycle.py, ALL FOUR OBSERVED
RED BEFORE GREEN — sibling token evicted, marker lost at the served surface,
repeated teaching cleared by one promotion, and count underflow. The eight
pre-existing lifecycle pins pass unchanged.
Also H-8e — expand_relation_closure's docstring claimed "Cycle: if path would
revisit a node, skip", describing a check the code does not perform. The code
was right: termination is structural (monotone growth over a finite triple set),
and a path-revisit skip would REFUSE SOUND transitive derivations, since a
witness path that revisits a node still proves a true fact. The docstring now
says that, and records that `path` is the witnessing step rather than full
ancestry — extending it would move operator_invocation and therefore trace_hash,
so it is deliberately not done here.
Registers updated: H-13 marked FIXED with the ratification note (this changes
served surfaces toward disclosure, restoring ADR-0021 §Articulation's stated
intent rather than extending it); H-8e marked CORRECTED.
Found while fixing it, recorded not acted on: tests/test_speculative_subject_
lifecycle.py — the file pinning this exact behavior — is in NO curated suite,
reachable only through `full`. G-7's mechanism, caught on the pin that would
have caught the defect. Assignment left to PR-4; adding it to TEST_SUITES
["smoke"] alone would widen N-3's ten-file delta and prejudge R-14.
Pre-existing ruff findings in pipeline.py (3 unused imports, 1 E402) confirmed
present before this change and left alone — module-top, not adjacent to the edit.
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Wcw2pnMBwyvmNyQg4uPEt4
Two external first-principles assessments of CORE were verified against code
line-by-line at 8f0ccfe3. What survived is entered; what failed is recorded in
the audit's negative space with the refuting file named, per the register's own
discipline.
Entered:
H-13 — the speculative-marker cache over-evicts shared tokens: promoting one
proposal to COHERENT pops tokens regardless of owner (pipeline.py:736-739,
:1045-1055), so a sibling proposal's still-SPECULATIVE material is served
without its marker. Honesty regression, served direction. Remedy: refcounted
cache, failing test first. (The source assessment described this seam with
the direction inverted — under-eviction; the code over-evicts. The check
that caught the inversion is what confirmed the bug.)
H-14 — _run_turn is 759 lines (pipeline.py:189-947) under a thin-wrapper
docstring, with finalize_turn_trace_hash x2 / finalize_turn_surface x1
back-stamps as the measured symptom. H-4's sibling: refactor ADR, PR-10's
byte-identical-trace bar, and the learn stage named stateful.
H-8e — inductive_closure.py's docstring claims a path-based cycle skip the
code does not perform (:106 vs :189-193) — and the code is the right side:
the monotone fixed point needs no path check, and adding one would refuse
sound derivations. path records only (a,b,c) for longer chains (:198), so
trace provenance is incomplete. Docstring fix is mechanical; extending path
changes operator_invocation bytes -> trace_hash, held to the trace-change bar.
PR-9 widened — the logos-authority bare except (pipeline.py:555) and the
three OOV-probe swallows (:605-657) join the count-the-swallow scope; same
remedy shape (record repr(e), keep the backstop), explicitly not the
narrow-catch alternative.
R-4 packet addition — first collapse candidate: composed_surface +
transitive_surface + transitive_max_depth -> chain_depth:int, justified by
ADR-0083's own docstring ladder; ruled in-lineage, not ad-hoc.
R-12a note — lived_life.json staleness recorded as a question; the proposed
PID-attestation fix rejected (refuses every reboot resume; PID reuse).
Cleared, with the refuting file named: EpistemicState compression
(vault/store.py, policy.py's ADR-0206 partition), the EpistemicState x
NormativeClearance product type (erases refusal evidence — H-3 rebuilt as a
type), PID attestation, path-based cycle skipping, the depth-enrichment cache
(pack_resolver.py:19 already lru_caches the cost), and the unified reasoning
engine as-refactor (trace_hash change + capability widening + discards the
ROBDD engine one merge after ADR-0265 ratified denial).
Register ranges updated to G-1..G-21 / H-1..H-14. Docs only; no runtime
behavior, no flag, no test changed.
[Verification]: uv run pytest tests/test_adr_index.py
tests/test_adr_status_governance.py tests/test_adr_0252_s5_blindness.py -q —
327 passed at this tree.
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Wcw2pnMBwyvmNyQg4uPEt4
Track A of docs/assessment/50-execution-plan.md §6, executed under its own
protocol. Criterion pre-registered at dfc394d2 (that commit carries the
thresholds as importable constants and NO results); this commit carries the run.
VERDICT: NO-GO. Full credit by ADR-0252 §5.4's own terms.
docs/research/sme-experiment-verdict-797ebad5.md
evals/structure_mapping/adr0252_s5/results/report-797ebad5.json
deterministic_digest b3d9d27592e213104c51bcace7415fd819d722a1b06f7d0a5ca65bd5a234e4ec
53 cases, 1378 pairs, 0.0% non-convergence — no exception contributed to any
number. RS-A (structure-only) separates perfectly, AUC 1.0000, margin +0.0867,
and fails structure-sensitivity. RS-B (attribute-bearing) fails all three.
The mechanism, measured rather than argued: the similarity quotient that would
deliver attribute-invariance is the same quotient that annihilates structural
contrast. An add-vs-subtract minimal pair — one entity, identical numbers, one
relation kind changed — aligns at residual exactly 0.0, its two configurations
being related by a PROPER rotation about e1. Sweeping the attribute weight
(committed as diagnostic_sweep), structure-sensitivity fails at every setting,
and every regime where the SME property survives is a regime where attributes
contribute nothing: AUC 1.00 -> 0.97 -> 0.83 -> 0.69 as they begin to matter.
Scope stated narrowly: this refutes H1 for embeddings that encode role-structure
as point positions aligned by conformal Procrustes under similarity. The
argument is about the quotient, so it generalises across that class; it does not
refute every Cl(4,1) representation, and it does not touch the symbolic
structure-mapping lane already in evals/structure_mapping/.
Two findings that were on nobody's list:
N-8 — the experiment was NOT unrun. rnd/sme-experiment-v2 @ 96e5f468 is titled
"Verdict: GO" and rnd/structure-mapping-experiment @ fc9d0c14 carries an earlier
one. Neither survives inspection: attempt 1 leaked the S1-S4 label into the
embedding; attempt 2 was blind and then took its separability from
`except ValueError: res = 1000.0` — a solver exception counted as a distance —
on a corpus 46/51 of which is outside holdout_dev/v1 with nothing marked, with
duplicate graphs, colliding ids, and an extractor that was never committed. The
register, the plan and the ADR all read the same absence and inherited the same
error for nine days. A branch tip is not a record.
G-21 — the math reader returns a selected graph for 5 of 500 holdout_dev/v1
cases (1.0%), all one skeleton; 24/150 on the public lane. That is why §5.1's
four-structure corpus is not extractable, and it is a sharper measurement of the
comprehension frontier than G-3's construction count.
Registers updated: G-1 carries the verdict, H-10 confirmed and discharged, G-21
added, plan §0 gains N-8, Track A closed, synthesis frontier 2 rewritten.
Pins: tests/test_adr_0252_s5_blindness.py, each observed red before green
(label leak and duplicate-graph sabotage both caught).
Off-serving — evals/structure_mapping/adr0252_s5/ is imported by no serving
path, emits no answers, and changes no flag.
[Verification]: 797ebad5 + this branch — `uv run core test --suite smoke -q`
641 passed in 199.76s; `uv run ruff check` clean; report regenerated after lint
with an unchanged digest.
PR-1's amendments were derived at ed06dd64. main has since moved (#140, #138),
so every amended claim was re-measured against code at 797ebad5 before landing:
- TEST_SUITES["full"] == ("tests/",) (N-1) holds
- 5 tests/test_l10_*.py, none marked quarantine or slow (N-2) holds
- smoke suite 23 files vs smoke.yml 13, same ten-file delta,
and zero CI-only files (local is strictly the superset) (N-3) holds
- RuntimeConfig: 32 booleans, 28 off, the same 4 on (N-7) holds
- CONTINUOUS_LIFE_CONFIG_FLAGS still omits accrual (N-6) holds
- ADR-0264 §4.1 self-supersession banner in place (N-5) holds
- 18 resolve_promotable_* organs in generate/derivation/ (H-8b) holds
One correction to the amendment itself. H-8d said CONTINUOUS_LIFE_CONFIG_FLAGS
"contains neither claim's subject." It contains one of them: consolidate_
determinations IS forced. The false clause in both docstrings is the one naming
accrue_realized_knowledge as co-enabled, and a third comment on persist_session_
state makes the same shape of claim and is true. The entry now says that, and
says it was caught on re-verification — the same standard §0 holds itself to.
Docs only. No runtime behavior, no flag, no test changed.
scripts/hooks/pre-push describes its own step 1 as "the smoke suite — exact
CI-gate parity" while running 23 files against the CI gate's 13. That is the
second in-repo assertion of the parity H-12 falsifies, and it is inside the
tooling that enforces the protocol.
The corrections derived in 50-execution-plan.md §0, applied where the wrong
claims live. Every amendment is marked [AMENDED N-x] inline so the register
carries its own correction history rather than quietly reading correct.
Gap register — four entries amended:
- G-5 the soak RAN and passed (5000 beats, reboot at 2500, all four gates,
aed273b1). Retitled: what is owed is the committed artifact, the pinned
deterministic_digest, and a cadence — not the run. Both prior claims
withdrawn with their causes: "no suite contains any l10 test" was a
scan artifact (TEST_SUITES["full"] is a directory), and the pins
execute twice a day (post-merge + nightly cron).
- G-7 respecified. The proposed meta-check was already satisfied and would
have shipped green proving nothing — a hollow gate in the entry
proposing to abolish hollow gates. Now two pins: gate parity, and
curated-suite membership EXCLUDING full.
- G-8 28 default-off flags of 32 RuntimeConfig booleans, not seventeen.
- G-10 the 16-premise cap was removed by ADR-0264 R5 on 2026-07-26; the ADR
carries a self-supersession banner directly under the heading Phase 4
quoted. No engineering prerequisite remains — R-8 alone gates it.
- G-19 note: the 21/25 exposure is already pinned in test_volume_honesty.py,
so the work is applying the demotions, not discovering them.
Hindrance audit:
- H-12 added — the local smoke suite (23) and smoke.yml (13) have diverged by
ten files. Counter-evidence stated first: AGENTS.md makes the local run
the merge gate and it is the superset, so nothing is unguarded. What is
real is one comment claiming an equality that does not hold, and the
push that skipped the local gate.
- H-8 gains instance (d), inside the code: two flag docstrings assert a
production profile CONTINUOUS_LIFE_CONFIG_FLAGS does not have.
- H-1 gains the already-pinned note.
Also: correction note on the 2026-07-25 verification doc (a corrective
document that introduced the error at H-8c), and a staleness banner on
MIND-PHYSICS-BLUEPRINT.md pointing at the taxonomy that dissolved it.
The two ratified-ADR amendments (ADR-0146, ADR-0252) are NOT here — they are
drafted in full in 50-rulings.md R-12 and land on that ruling, because editing
a ratified ADR is Shay's authority even when the edit changes no decision.
Docs only. No runtime behavior, no flag, no test changed.
30-gap-register.md — CORE's first LIVE gap register since docs/gaps.md
closed its 26th entry (supersession proposed for ruling). 20 entries in
four tiers, each with evidence, deciding authority, and leverage rank:
- Tier A (frontier-blocking): G-1 the unrun ADR-0252 §5 experiment
(leverage 1 — authorized, scaffolded, verdict-less; the paradigm governs
ALL future comprehension); G-2 the #138 fabrications (pre-labeled
measured-and-pinned, held for ADR + ratification); G-3 reader 19 vs
writer 1739; G-4 CR-2 no-chooser (the AGI-grade conceptual absence);
G-5 L10 proof debt (no artifact, no suite, no cadence); G-6 the
half-gated lived learning loop.
- Tier B (enforcement debt): G-7 orphaned-pin meta-check (the highest-
leverage single mechanical change); G-8 flag-default register; G-9 three
doctrine laws without verified failing pins; G-10 curriculum scoping +
absent ledger; G-11 identity authorization bar unstated.
- Tier C (one-line rulings): CR-3 efferent, CR-4 temporal stance, CR-1
attention ADR, the daemon's owning ADR.
- Tier D (latent/carried): aspect-arm defect class (generate/templates.py
:79, unreachable today), sensorium entry criterion, curriculum-formation
bypass (unverified carry), Wilson evidence debt, refusal materialisation.
- Plus what is NOT in the register and why (deferred-with-ruling is the
scripture model; benchmarks excluded by the completeness criterion).
31-hindrance-audit.md — 11 entries ranked by leverage, each with fitness
verdict, evidence, proposed better home, deciding authority; decides
nothing. Headliners: H-1 Wilson/replay counting basis (wrong-solution in
the counting, not the gating — 21/25 bands short; the re-count may demote
licenses and that is the mechanism working); H-2 decoration as testimony
(DriveGradientMap, InhibitionMask — deletion per mastery step 2); H-3 the
typed refusal discarded at the public boundary; H-4 extend the resolver's
declared-precedence pattern upstream; H-8 three record/code contradictions
(each one paragraph to fix); H-9 dead instruments standing as if live.
Plus five examined-and-CLEARED candidates (the 18 organs' continued
service is governance working; pure-Python-by-default is measured-correct;
flag-gated conservatism is not hindrance — unregistered darkness is).
Claude