Track A, per 50-execution-plan.md §6: "state the GO/NO-GO criterion in writing
BEFORE running (the ADR's §5 conformance bar, not a criterion chosen after
seeing results)." This commit carries the criterion and the code and NO results.
Why the protocol is load-bearing here rather than ceremonial: the §5 experiment
is not unrun. It has been run twice and returned GO twice, on unmerged branches,
and neither run's rule was binding.
- rnd/structure-mapping-experiment @ fc9d0c14 — disowned by its own successor:
the S1-S4 label entered the embedding, so Procrustes ran on identical
matrices per structure.
- rnd/sme-experiment-v2 @ 96e5f468 — blind, and then measured separability
with `except ValueError: res = 1000.0`. Its GO test cross_mean > 2*same_mean
is satisfied by that sentinel alone. A solver exception is not a distance.
Instrument characterised before use, on dummy clouds: conformal_procrustes has
two branches. The (5,K) Kabsch+Umeyama path never raises and is invariant to
rotation, translation AND uniform scale (identical 1.8e-16, rotated 7.8e-16,
translated 3.9e-15, scaled x2.5 1.4e-14) while separating non-similar
deformation (5.9e-1) and unrelated clouds (1.1e0). The mixed versor/point
sequence path performs field conjugacy and raises. Attempt 2 used the second;
this uses the first, and treats a raise as non-convergence — excluded, reported
as a rate, never counted as separation.
Corpus fact that forced the design, measured at 797ebad5: the serving reader
returns a selected graph for 5 of the 500 holdout_dev/v1 cases (1.0%), all with
the same skeleton. §5.1's four-structure corpus is not extractable from
holdout_dev/v1 today, so §5.1's own escape hatch is used and MARKED — 5 real
cases, 48 synthetic from four declared templates. A verdict from this corpus
speaks about the geometry, not about coverage; §5.5's compression estimate is
not answerable at 1.0% coverage and is not attempted.
Off-serving. Imported by no serving path; no answers emitted.
Increment 2 for ADR-0252 Track B. Extends Increment 1's structure-mapping
slice with pure-family canonicals S2–S4, overlapping-waves selector, and a
structure-mapping-owned pure-S1 text extract that recovers four real
holdout cases the serving reader misses (0148, 0228, 0234, 0441).
Bar results (command-backed via scripts/measure_trackb_inc2.py):
- generalization ratio S1 = 9.0 (9 holdout cases / 1 template)
- coverage gain organ 5 → trackb 9, wrong=0
- selector routes S1/S2/S3; refuses empty; surface≠structure
Off-serving: no organ retirement, serving reader untouched. S2–S4 holdout
ratios are 0 (parser frontier). S3/S4 emit refuses at multi-register scope
without weakening the three-gate wrong=0 path.
[Verification]: Smoke suite passed locally (~132s, 176 passed);
trackb unit tests 35 passed; measure_trackb_inc2 all modes green.
ADR-0252 §5 geometric SME is NO-GO; this is Track B Increment 1.
Adds role-predicate conversion from MathProblemGraph, S1 canonical skeleton,
blind symbolic mapper (match/refuse + binding), and solve via classical
verify plus multi-register certificate. Research report and holdout measures
included. Serving reader unchanged; no S2–S4 generalization.
