Commit graph

2 commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Shay
1cc05d9cce
docs: schema-defined proof obligations doctrine + convergence-site invariant + FOLLOWUPS §6 (#360)
Three small surgical anchors capturing the verified architectural
insight surfaced during the ADR-0167 wave (no new ADR — the gap claim
that prompted this resolved on verification; what remains is a sharper
residual question worth memorialising).

1. CLAUDE.md — new "Schema-Defined Proof Obligations" section between
   Documentation Discipline and Validation Through CLI.  Generalises
   the wrong=0 invariant pattern: schema types that name structural
   properties are real only when an executing test can meaningfully
   fail under the violations it is written to catch.  Three-step rule
   for treating a schema as load-bearing.

2. language_packs/compiler.py — ARCHITECTURAL INVARIANT comment on
   _apply_mounted_primary_domain_resonance naming it as the single
   convergence-decision site for DEPTH_ROOT/DEPTH_RELATION packs.
   Anchors the doctrine at the code site so any future modification
   trips on the reference to the holonomy proof's coverage gap.

3. docs/handoff/ADR-0167-FOLLOWUPS.md §6 — captures the structural-vs-
   blend convergence isolation question.  HolonomyAlignmentCase IS
   executed today (we verified), but the existing test doesn't
   distinguish structurally-derived convergence from blend-induced
   convergence.  Ablation test or reframed claim — both acceptable
   resolutions.

Verified before commit:
- All 13 architectural references in the Gemini analysis resolve
  exactly: triliteral 0.30, root 0.40, prefix 0.03/(idx+1), stem 0.24,
  _INFLECTION_PRIORITY case-near-last, _apply_mounted_primary_domain_resonance
  with 40% English-prototype blend, HolonomyAlignmentCase defined
  AND executed
- tests/test_alignment_graph.py: 8 passed (no behavioural change)
- Documentation discipline (#355) honoured: pure Markdown, no HTML

No code behaviour changes.  No runtime effect.  Drops the larger
ADR-0168-PROPOSAL idea — the gap claim that prompted it dissolved
under verification.
2026-05-27 07:52:20 -07:00
Shay
a7d1547fbb
docs(ADR-0167): follow-ups queue — 5 named items deferred from LexicalClaim slice (#358)
Captures the named follow-ups that surfaced during the ADR-0167 wave so
they don't drift. Five items, each with scope / why-deferred /
breadcrumbs / acceptance criterion:

1. Frame-opener sub-types (FrameClaim / CompositionClaim / ReferenceClaim
   / SlotClaim) — four additional handlers, each its own ADR
2. Partition test architectural fix — current git-status-at-test-runtime
   assertion is structurally brittle (3 options outlined)
3. Two pre-existing main failures (test_unparseable_statement,
   test_audit_real_corpus_runs_clean) — fix or quarantine, don't ignore
4. Workbench v1 math-candidate rendering — ADR-0167 §Q4
5. Cross-domain partition risks Gemini flagged (contemplation pack
   indexing, replay gate default)

Includes leverage-based sequencing recommendation (no timelines per
project convention).

Docs-only. No code, no test, no eval, no pack change.
2026-05-27 07:39:22 -07:00