Commit graph

2 commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Shay
9efd5a6143 docs: apply the Wave 0 record amendments that need no ruling (N-1…N-7, H-12)
The corrections derived in 50-execution-plan.md §0, applied where the wrong
claims live. Every amendment is marked [AMENDED N-x] inline so the register
carries its own correction history rather than quietly reading correct.

Gap register — four entries amended:
- G-5  the soak RAN and passed (5000 beats, reboot at 2500, all four gates,
       aed273b1). Retitled: what is owed is the committed artifact, the pinned
       deterministic_digest, and a cadence — not the run. Both prior claims
       withdrawn with their causes: "no suite contains any l10 test" was a
       scan artifact (TEST_SUITES["full"] is a directory), and the pins
       execute twice a day (post-merge + nightly cron).
- G-7  respecified. The proposed meta-check was already satisfied and would
       have shipped green proving nothing — a hollow gate in the entry
       proposing to abolish hollow gates. Now two pins: gate parity, and
       curated-suite membership EXCLUDING full.
- G-8  28 default-off flags of 32 RuntimeConfig booleans, not seventeen.
- G-10 the 16-premise cap was removed by ADR-0264 R5 on 2026-07-26; the ADR
       carries a self-supersession banner directly under the heading Phase 4
       quoted. No engineering prerequisite remains — R-8 alone gates it.
- G-19 note: the 21/25 exposure is already pinned in test_volume_honesty.py,
       so the work is applying the demotions, not discovering them.

Hindrance audit:
- H-12 added — the local smoke suite (23) and smoke.yml (13) have diverged by
       ten files. Counter-evidence stated first: AGENTS.md makes the local run
       the merge gate and it is the superset, so nothing is unguarded. What is
       real is one comment claiming an equality that does not hold, and the
       push that skipped the local gate.
- H-8  gains instance (d), inside the code: two flag docstrings assert a
       production profile CONTINUOUS_LIFE_CONFIG_FLAGS does not have.
- H-1  gains the already-pinned note.

Also: correction note on the 2026-07-25 verification doc (a corrective
document that introduced the error at H-8c), and a staleness banner on
MIND-PHYSICS-BLUEPRINT.md pointing at the taxonomy that dissolved it.

The two ratified-ADR amendments (ADR-0146, ADR-0252) are NOT here — they are
drafted in full in 50-rulings.md R-12 and land on that ruling, because editing
a ratified ADR is Shay's authority even when the edit changes no decision.

Docs only. No runtime behavior, no flag, no test changed.
2026-07-27 17:38:12 -07:00
Shay
4c342cdc02 docs(assessment): Phase 4 — the gap register and the hindrance audit
30-gap-register.md — CORE's first LIVE gap register since docs/gaps.md
closed its 26th entry (supersession proposed for ruling). 20 entries in
four tiers, each with evidence, deciding authority, and leverage rank:

- Tier A (frontier-blocking): G-1 the unrun ADR-0252 §5 experiment
  (leverage 1 — authorized, scaffolded, verdict-less; the paradigm governs
  ALL future comprehension); G-2 the #138 fabrications (pre-labeled
  measured-and-pinned, held for ADR + ratification); G-3 reader 19 vs
  writer 1739; G-4 CR-2 no-chooser (the AGI-grade conceptual absence);
  G-5 L10 proof debt (no artifact, no suite, no cadence); G-6 the
  half-gated lived learning loop.
- Tier B (enforcement debt): G-7 orphaned-pin meta-check (the highest-
  leverage single mechanical change); G-8 flag-default register; G-9 three
  doctrine laws without verified failing pins; G-10 curriculum scoping +
  absent ledger; G-11 identity authorization bar unstated.
- Tier C (one-line rulings): CR-3 efferent, CR-4 temporal stance, CR-1
  attention ADR, the daemon's owning ADR.
- Tier D (latent/carried): aspect-arm defect class (generate/templates.py
  :79, unreachable today), sensorium entry criterion, curriculum-formation
  bypass (unverified carry), Wilson evidence debt, refusal materialisation.
- Plus what is NOT in the register and why (deferred-with-ruling is the
  scripture model; benchmarks excluded by the completeness criterion).

31-hindrance-audit.md — 11 entries ranked by leverage, each with fitness
verdict, evidence, proposed better home, deciding authority; decides
nothing. Headliners: H-1 Wilson/replay counting basis (wrong-solution in
the counting, not the gating — 21/25 bands short; the re-count may demote
licenses and that is the mechanism working); H-2 decoration as testimony
(DriveGradientMap, InhibitionMask — deletion per mastery step 2); H-3 the
typed refusal discarded at the public boundary; H-4 extend the resolver's
declared-precedence pattern upstream; H-8 three record/code contradictions
(each one paragraph to fix); H-9 dead instruments standing as if live.
Plus five examined-and-CLEARED candidates (the 18 organs' continued
service is governance working; pure-Python-by-default is measured-correct;
flag-gated conservatism is not hindrance — unregistered darkness is).
2026-07-27 16:04:22 -07:00