Commit graph

2 commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Shay
5f74351729 feat(epistemic): Q1-C strictly single-slot — refuse multi-slot ASK
The template asserts 'one more value is still needed' (exactly one). Rendering
the first of several missing slots and ignoring the rest makes that claim
subtly false. Refuse multi-slot assessments with multi_slot_not_supported
(slot=None) rather than render-first-drop-rest; one-question-per-slot fan-out
is a later rung. Replaces the now-contradicting first-of-many test with a
test that pins the honest refusal.
2026-06-08 18:42:40 -07:00
Shay
b186f07382 feat(epistemic): Q1-C grounded-only question renderer (off-serving)
Add core/epistemic_questions/ — the renderer rung of the ASK spine.
render_question(LimitationAssessment) -> EpistemicQuestion turns ASK typed
residue into a user-facing question or an explicit question_unrenderable verdict.
Render only: no bus delivery, no served disposition, no serving (that is Q1-D).

Policy (scoping §2 / session §1.5.7 wrong=0 invariant): a question may name a
problem entity only if it appears verbatim in grounded_terms. Two substrate facts
force a generic-structural policy today: grounded_terms is empty everywhere (the
readers do not yet emit verbatim evidence), and a *missing* slot's referent is by
definition absent from the trace. So the renderer:

- renders a generic question whose only variable content is a controlled English
  phrase for the slot's expected_unit_or_type, from a closed audited map;
- never surfaces slot_name or binding_target (snake_case), never prettifies an
  identifier into a natural-language entity, never names a problem entity;
- degrades unmapped types to question_unrenderable (renderability_gap) rather
  than dumping raw snake_case;
- single-slot (first slot only); non-ASK / zero-slot -> unrenderable;
- post-render fabrication guard re-checks every token is closed-vocab scaffold or
  grounded (defense in depth).

Off-serving: imports no generate.derivation / core.reliability_gate (AST-tested).
Tests: 9/9 green; smoke 90/0.
2026-06-08 17:20:49 -07:00