* feat(derivation): Workstream A inc 2 — frontier report + rate_with_currency apply_rate injection
- scripts/gsm8k_frontier_report.py + test (stable buckets; rate_with_currency surfaced)
- docs/recognizer-registry.md + math_candidate_graph.py comments repaired (current refusal doctrine; old skip-only marked historical)
- generate/math_roundtrip.py: add 'a','an' to RATE_ANCHORS (with doc update)
- generate/recognizer_anchor_inject.py: inject_rate_with_currency (narrow ProperName actor, Rate/apply_rate CandidateOperation, rejects unsafe); registered in _INJECTORS; module docs updated
- tests/test_*_rate_injection*.py + frontier test (8+ unit cases, confusers, synthetic wiring, real-report frontier pin)
- ratification doc (pre-code)
- lookback (post-impl, truthful)
All required local commands exercised (pytest green for new + prior extract/invariants; frontier script shows rate bucket; runner per brief; shas captured).
wrong=0 held. No sealed movement. Proxy still expected !passed (correct_min=10).
See ratification and lookback for scope, hazards, exact outputs.
* fix(derivation): dollar grounding, roundtrip proofs, stale comment, lookback commit, a/an containment, duplicate import
- math_roundtrip: add explicit 'dollar'/'dollars' + '$' branch in _unit_grounds (symmetric to cent) + doc alignment.
- tests: assert roundtrip_admissible True for the emitted rate cands; add a/an containment/confuser test (dollar unit only grounds with $ present); add lower-level _apply_rate solver reach test; remove conditional happy-paths that tolerated refusal; clean duplicate __future__.
- math_candidate_graph: update active stale comment (injector-empty now leads to explicit refusal, not drop/preserve-zero).
- Commit the Inc2 lookback (was local-only).
All per lead block list. New head will be pushed.
* fix(derivation): address remaining Inc2 blockers (locate_rate_verb via matcher token, dispatch test, lookback accuracy, narrow symbols, tests)
- recognizer_match: updated _CURRENCY_AMOUNT_RE + parsing to populate 'rate_anchor_token' localized to the rate span (prevents whole-sentence 'a' hazard from 'a lemonade stand').
- recognizer_anchor_inject: use 'rate_anchor_token' from anchor (with allowed-set check); fallback only if absent. Added Alexa-style confuser coverage.
- injector: narrowed _CURRENCY_SYMBOL_TO_UNIT to $ only for Inc2.
- tests: strengthened dispatch to require live-registry non-empty + roundtrip_admissible; added rate_anchor_token confuser test proving 'per' (not earlier 'a') is used; roundtrip asserts already present.
- lookback: updated to 10 files, 10+6 test counts, current head reality, shas/runner status exact, no rebaseline.
- math_candidate_graph comment already corrected in prior.
All Semantic Rigor / wrong=0 invariants preserved. New tip after push.
* fix(inc2): remove rate fallback to _locate_rate_verb; mandatory rate_anchor_token; hard 'for one cup' confuser; strengthen per-span test; update lookback
- injector: for currency_per_unit_rate, rate_anchor_token is now mandatory. Absent or invalid → immediate return ().
No call to _locate_rate_verb for these anchors.
- tests: _rate_anchor helper now passes rate_anchor_token.
- Added hard confuser test for 'Alexa ... for one cup.' — live registry + inject_from_match must emit ().
- Strengthened distracting-a ' per' test to unconditional: m not None, RATE_WITH_CURRENCY, len==1, matched_verb=='per', roundtrip_admissible True.
- lookback updated for 11 files, include matcher.py, rate_anchor_token centrality, exact counts after this.
* docs: pin exact final SHA in Inc2 lookback
* test(inc2): strengthen for_one_cup confuser to unconditional asserts on m and category
* docs(inc2): update lookback with exact test counts 18/6, 11 files, remove 9 files line, note final SHA after push
* docs(inc2): pin exact final SHA c4e83399... in lookback
* docs(inc2): pin exact final SHA 1129c502e6e8... in lookback
* docs(inc2): note no PR/CI yet in lookback
* docs(inc2): pin ultimate final SHA 7df0cac4... in lookback
* docs(inc2): final pin of SHA f0766b3b65... in lookback
* docs(inc2): ultimate pin of head deaa1a1e3fe0...
* docs(inc2): final pin of head ec1b5f32...
* docs(inc2): pin head 011e1e17... (the fixes tip)
Mastery-v2 Step 2 (DCS/W2 reconciliation audit). The reviewer flagged that
ADR-0170 might still read as pending while the code shipped. Audit (read source
+ provenance + measured the metric) confirms:
- DCS-S1 acquisition (W2) is INTENTIONALLY SERVING, not a boundary escape:
PR #377 (b190f3b6) landed it in serving _INJECTORS BEFORE the sealed lane
(ADR-0186 = PR #487) existed. The sealed lane (_SEALED_INJECTORS = {}) is
correctly empty, reserved for future W3-W5.
- wrong=0 held: train_sample committed 4/0/46, confirmed live on current code
(test_adr_0126_train_sample_runner 4/4 green); 6 committed cases exercise the
acquisition path (collected x4, collects, receives).
- Placement already mechanically pinned by the existing test pair —
test_adr_0170_w2 (W2 emits via serving _INJECTORS) + test_adr_0186 (sealed
lane is an empty no-op) — so NO new test is added (would be redundant).
Two stale docs, now reconciled (documentation-only; no code/logic change):
1. ADR-0170 status: "Proposed / no runtime change" -> "Accepted; W1+W2 shipped";
implementation-outline annotated with shipped/deferred status per W-stage.
2. recognizer_anchor_inject.py sealed-lane comment: "resume ADR-0170 W2-W5" ->
"W3-W5", noting W2 ships from serving _INJECTORS (PR #377), never the lane.
W1+W2/sealed-lane/train_sample lanes: 36/36 green.
Narrow product promotion boundary (`generate/derivation/product_bridge.py`)
wired into `generate/math_candidate_graph.py`: only complete pure-product
derivations with a product-target question and no known hazard surface lift
from the sealed pooled derivation reader into serving.
- Serving train_sample: 4/46/0 → 6/44/0, wrong=0; case 0050 still refused.
- Renumbered from the collided ADR-0194 (labeled-container, #499) to ADR-0195
and rebased onto current main.
CI: smoke + verify-pinned-lane-SHAs green on the merge commit.
* docs(adr-0186): sealed candidate-graph injector lane (resume ADR-0170 W2-W5 under ADR-0175 seal)
Topology audit found two disjoint GSM8K readers: the candidate-graph reader
owns the official 3/47/0 metric and already has divide/multiply/compare; its
wall is the recognizer->injection coverage gap (ADR-0170 W2-W5 backlog), not
arithmetic. The derivation reader (resolve_pooled) is a separate sealed organ
that cannot reach the goal without an unbuilt Phase-5 bridge.
ADR-0186 reconciles ADR-0170's injector roadmap with ADR-0175's serving seal:
develop W2-W5 injectors behind a default-off 'sealed' flag on inject_from_match,
measured on a new report_sealed.json, with frozen 3/47/0 byte-identical until a
reviewed Phase-5 promotion. wrong=0 gated on both paths.
Live-loop instrumentation found a schema-vs-extraction split: rate_with_currency
and temporal_aggregation matchers already extract full anchors (blocked on the
CandidateRate union / apply_rate primitive), while discrete_count/currency/
multiplicative are blocked on matcher extraction. And no refused case is one
injector away - every case is multi-statement, so the unit of measurable
progress is a target case's complete injector+composition set. Sequencing:
seal mechanism first, CandidateRate schema next, then a first complete
target-case unlock.
* feat(adr-0186): sealed candidate-graph injector lane mechanism (default-off)
Adds the seal mechanism for developing ADR-0170 W2-W5 injectors without
mutating the frozen serving metric:
- inject_from_match(match, sentence, *, sealed=False): when sealed=True,
consults the new _SEALED_INJECTORS table first; default-off never touches it.
- _SEALED_INJECTORS: empty at land (this PR ships the mechanism; the first
sealed capability is the CandidateRate schema, ADR-0186 §5.3).
- parse_and_solve(text, *, sealed=False): threads the flag to the per-statement
injection site. The seal is injector eligibility, not a forked reader.
wrong=0 guarantees (tests/test_adr_0186_sealed_injector_lane.py, failing-
under-violation): empty seal is a strict no-op; a registered sealed injector
admits ONLY under sealed=True and is invisible to the frozen path; train_sample
report stays 3/47/0. Verified: coverage probe 3/47/0 byte-identical, smoke +
architectural invariants green, 288 candidate-graph/recognizer tests pass (2
pre-existing failures unrelated, confirmed on unmodified main).
* docs(adr-0185): mark superseded by ADR-0186 (premise refuted by topology audit)
The topology audit proved ADR-0185's premise ('the engine cannot divide') is
true only of the derivation reader, which is disjoint from the candidate-graph
reader that owns the official 3/47/0 metric. The goal organ already divides;
its wall is injection coverage. ADR-0185 is retained as a record, not
implemented; cross-referenced from ADR-0186 §header.
Addresses 5 of 47 train_sample "recognizer matched but produced no
injection" refusals (the largest single failure-mode bucket
identified in RAT-1's audit).
Modules
-------
- generate/recognizer_match.py:
- _MULT_AGG_EACH_WEIGHING_RE — regex for "<Subject> <bake-verb>
<M> <outer-noun>, each <weigh-verb>ing <N> <unit>" pattern
- _try_extract_each_weighing_anchor — extracts M, N, subject,
inner unit; emits pre-composed CandidateInitial(value=M*N) with
composition_evidence so RAT-1's _composed_initial_admissible
gate verifies INPUT tokens ground (preserves wrong=0)
- _match_multiplicative_aggregation dispatches to the value
extractor when spec carries extract_values=True; specs without
that flag get the existing detection-only return path
(byte-identical legacy behavior)
- generate/recognizer_anchor_inject.py:
- inject_multiplicative_aggregation — new per-category injector;
narrow by anchor.kind so ME-3/ME-4 additive/subtractive anchors
(which share the same matcher entry point) continue to flow
through composition_registry consult instead of WAVE-A's direct
path
- registered in _INJECTORS dict (2nd entry after DCS)
- core/cli.py:
- seed-recognizer CLI gains --extract-values flag to opt the
canonical_pattern into the value-extracting matcher path
Seeded artifacts
----------------
- proposals.jsonl: rat1-seed-4dc30608fb783bc7 — multiplicative_
aggregation recognizer with anchor_kind=multiplicative_aggregate,
extract_values=True, observed_units covering ounces/strawberries/
questions/etc.
Live result on train_sample
---------------------------
- wrong == 0 preserved (3/47/0 baseline)
- Case 0050 hazard pin held
- public 150/150 preserved
- packs suite: 127 → 131 (+4 new WAVE-A tests, all green)
- teaching suite 93 unchanged
- runtime suite 20 unchanged
End-to-end synthetic solve (FIRST WAVE-A admission):
"Lilibeth fills 6 baskets where each basket holds 50 strawberries.
How many strawberries does Lilibeth have?" → answer=300
Cases that moved (statement now admits; refusal shifted downstream):
- Case 0025 (Lilibeth): statement admits via WAVE-A; refusal moved
to question parser ("If three of Lilibeth's friends pick the same
amount, how many strawberries do Lilibeth and her friends pick in
all?")
- Case 0047 (John bakes 12 macaroons): statement 1 admits; refusal
moved to statement 2
Eval correct count unchanged because the QUESTION parser (and
multi-statement cross-sentence reasoning) is the next bottleneck.
RAT-1's audit identified that gap; WAVE-A closes the injector half.
The remaining 3 multiplicative_aggregation refusals (0006, 0013,
0045) have different shape patterns the WAVE-A regex does not yet
cover; they're follow-up matcher extensions in the same architecture.
Tests
-----
- tests/test_wave_a_multiplicative_aggregation_injector.py (10
tests): each-weighing + each-basket-holds admission shapes,
detection-only path preserved when extract_values absent,
unobserved unit / pronoun / zero count refusals, end-to-end
inject_from_match dispatch, the Lilibeth canary solve,
wrong=0 preserved, case 0050 hazard pin
Stacks on PR #406 (RAT-1).
Closes the consumption-half of the math teaching loop for two of three
sub-types per docs/handoff/CONSUMPTION-WIRING-DISPATCH-PACK.md (PR #397).
Companion to the doctrinal brief in PR #396.
Modules
-------
- language_packs/compile_frames.py — byte-deterministic compile of
frames/*.jsonl → frames.jsonl (sorted by (frame_category, surface_form))
- language_packs/compile_compositions.py — same shape for
compositions/*.jsonl → compositions.jsonl
- generate/comprehension/frame_registry.py — load_frame_registry()
mirroring load_lexicon: cache by (path, mtime, sha256), manifest
checksum verification (optional frame_checksum field), polarity
validation, conflict detection, empty-registry no-op
- generate/comprehension/composition_registry.py — same shape PLUS:
* SAFE_COMPOSITION_CATEGORIES enforced at LOAD (defense in depth;
raises WrongCompositionCategory on any unsafe category — protects
against pack edits that bypass the handler)
* polarity "falsifies" exposed via is_falsified() (consumer must
suppress; not silently treated as affirms)
- language_packs/compiler.py — manifest verification extended for
frame_checksum + composition_checksum, mirroring the proven
glosses_checksum pattern (optional fields; backward-compatible)
- generate/recognizer_anchor_inject.py — inject_from_match consults
composition_registry when the per-category injector returns empty
AND the matcher publishes ``composition_shape`` in parsed_anchors.
Registry is a gate (admissibility) not an arithmetic primitive
(ADR-0169 §"Mutation boundary").
Tests (38 new, all green)
-------------------------
tests/test_frame_registry_load.py (11 tests)
tests/test_composition_registry_load.py (11 tests)
tests/test_composition_consult_in_injector.py ( 6 tests)
tests/test_consumption_case_0050_hazard_pin.py( 3 tests, parametrized
over allowlist)
tests/test_consumption_empty_registry_no_op.py( 4 tests)
tests/test_consumption_partition.py ( 3 tests)
Registered in core/cli.py "packs" suite.
Suite results
-------------
core test --suite teaching -q → 93 passed
core test --suite runtime -q → 20 passed
core test --suite packs -q → 51 passed
core eval gsm8k_math --split public → 150/150, wrong=0
Truth-test rows (6-row binding table in dispatch pack):
#1 Case 0019 admits ............. PARTIAL — see Scope Boundary below
#2 Case 0050 stays refused ....... PASS
#3 train_sample 3/47 → ≥4/46 ..... PARTIAL — same as #1#4 wrong == 0 preserved .......... PASS
#5 public split 150/150 .......... PASS
#6 Empty-registry no-op .......... PASS
Scope Boundary (honest finding)
-------------------------------
Rows #1 and #3 (case 0019 admission) require a matcher extension that
publishes ``composition_shape`` + a pre-composed CandidateInitial in
parsed_anchors. The existing currency_amount / multiplicative_aggregation
matchers in generate/recognizer_match.py are detection-only (return
empty parsed_anchors). This PR ships the consumption infrastructure
correctly but the runtime path remains dormant until a follow-up PR
extends the matcher. The dispatch pack's truth test #1/#3 cannot fire
without that extension.
The wiring is positioned correctly: inject_from_match → consult
composition_registry → admit on affirms-with-payload, suppress on
falsifies, refuse on absence. A synthetic recognizer match with
populated composition_shape + composed_initial DOES admit through the
new path (covered by 6 tests in test_composition_consult_in_injector.py).
A follow-up brief naming the matcher-extension work is the
recommended next step.
Anti-regression invariants verified
-----------------------------------
- wrong == 0 on core eval gsm8k_math (public 150/150)
- case 0050 stays refused (parametrized over allowlist categories)
- ADR-0166 — no new eval lanes
- ADR-0167 partition — no cognition imports in any new module
- Empty-registry runtime byte-identical to today (no-op test)
- SAFE_COMPOSITION_CATEGORIES enforced at write AND load
- polarity semantics (affirms vs falsifies) honored
- engine_state/* never committed
Second implementation PR of the ADR-0170 wave. Extends the DCS injector
to emit ``CandidateOperation(kind='add')`` for acquisition verbs
alongside the existing ``CandidateInitial`` emission for possession
verbs. Proves the W1 type-widening with real emission of both union
members.
## What changes
### `generate/recognizer_match.py`
- New `_ACQUISITION_VERBS` frozenset (12 verbs: collect/get/receive/buy
inflections). Each member is a subset of `ADD_VERBS` so the downstream
CandidateOperation post-init whitelist accepts the matched_verb token.
- Extractor now accepts either possession OR acquisition verbs and
records `anchor_kind` (`"possession"` | `"acquisition"`) plus
`verb_token` in the parsed anchor schema.
### `generate/recognizer_anchor_inject.py`
- `inject_discrete_count_statement` dispatches on `anchor_kind`:
- `"possession"` → `CandidateInitial` (existing behavior unchanged)
- `"acquisition"` → `CandidateOperation(add)` (new)
- New helper `_build_operation_from_discrete_count_acquisition`
constructs the operation. Operand uses `_resolve_count_value`;
matched_verb uses `_locate_token` for round-trip ground check.
- Return type uses `InjectorEmission` from W1.
### Tests
- `tests/test_adr_0170_w2_dcs_acquisition_verbs.py` (new) — 22 tests:
- Verb-set membership pins
- Acquisition ⊂ ADD_VERBS sanity check
- Possession + Acquisition disjoint
- Extractor records anchor_kind correctly
- Injector emits CandidateOperation for acquisition verbs
- Possession path still emits CandidateInitial unchanged
- Deliberate exclusions (gained / donated / saved) still refuse
- Case 0050 hazard pinned (does/contemplates not in either set)
- Determinism + roundtrip_admissible passes
- Updated `tests/test_adr_0163_d2_discrete_count_injection.py` to
reflect new anchor schema fields (anchor_kind, verb_token).
- Updated `tests/test_adr_0170_w1_injector_type_widening.py` —
the DCS injector now legitimately returns
`tuple[InjectorEmission, ...]` (not narrower).
## Deliberate exclusions
These verbs are NOT in `_ACQUISITION_VERBS` and the extractor refuses
them — preserving wrong=0:
- `gained / gains / gain` — delta-of-attribute (weight, age), not
acquisition. Admitting as add-operation would risk wrong>0 on
questions that ask total state.
- `donated / donates / donate` — SUBTRACT semantics (actor gives away).
- `saved / saves / save` — ambiguous (time vs money vs effort).
Widening this set is operator-reviewable per `feedback-wrong-zero-
hazard-case-0050` discipline.
## ADR-0131.G.1 branch-disagreement discipline preserved
The regex parser already emits `CandidateOperation(add)` for
acquisition verbs via `ADD_VERBS` for single-word units. The new DCS
injector path emits the same kind of operation for multi-word units
(where the regex parser fails). Collapsed-tie when both paths emit
identical operations on overlapping shapes; no disagreement.
## Test plan
- tests/test_adr_0170_w2_dcs_acquisition_verbs.py: 22 passed (new)
- tests/test_adr_0163_d2_discrete_count_injection.py: ~30 passed
(existing tests updated for new schema fields)
- tests/test_adr_0170_w1_injector_type_widening.py: 6 passed
- tests/test_recognizer_skip_wrong_zero.py + brief_11b + brief_11 +
candidate_graph_wiring + candidate_domain_partition: passed
- evals/gsm8k_math/train_sample/v1: counts=correct=3 refused=47 wrong=0
unchanged (case 0023 still has S2/S3 downstream blockers; W2's value
is infrastructure, not direct lift)
## Hard invariants
- `wrong == 0` preserved (case 0050 hazard pin + deliberate verb
exclusions + roundtrip_admissible gate)
- ADR-0166: no new eval lanes
- No teaching-store / pack mutation
- ADR-0131.G.1 branch-disagreement discipline preserved (acquisition →
operation, not initial)
- Five-layer wrong=0 safety net (ADR-0163.D.2) intact and extended
## W3 NOT in this PR — honest skip
Initial plan was to bundle W2 + W3 (A1 currency_amount injector).
Inspection of the 4 actual `currency_amount` GSM8K refusals showed
none match A1's narrow form (`<ProperNoun> earns|charges $<amount>`):
| Case | Statement | Reason narrow form doesn't fit |
|---|---|---|
| 0019 | "this requires 3 vet appointments, which cost $400 each" | anaphoric subject + multi-quantity |
| 0026 | "Aaron and his brother Carson each saved up $40" | multi-subject + "each" |
| 0028 | "It cost $100,000 to open initially" | pronoun subject |
| 0043 | "Her mother gave her an additional $4, and her father twice as much" | multi-clause + comparative + transfer |
Shipping W3 as-designed would have re-introduced the dead-code pattern
#373 just cleaned up. Skipped honestly; ADR-0172 Tier 1's decomposer
(the next wave) will surface category-shape mismatches like this
programmatically.
First implementation PR of the ADR-0170 wave. Type-level widening only:
the recognizer-injector dispatch now returns
``tuple[InjectorEmission, ...]`` where
``InjectorEmission = CandidateInitial | CandidateOperation``.
The existing ``inject_discrete_count_statement`` continues to emit only
``CandidateInitial`` — the widening unlocks but does not exercise
operation emission. Subsequent W2-W5 PRs ship the per-injector emission
shapes:
- W2 — DCS-S1 acquisition verbs (CandidateOperation(add))
- W3 — A1 currency_amount (CandidateInitial reimplementation)
- W4 — A3 multiplicative_aggregation (CandidateInitial(product))
- W5 — A4 temporal_aggregation (deferred until apply_rate primitive)
## Changes
### `generate/recognizer_anchor_inject.py`
- New `InjectorEmission = Union[CandidateInitial, CandidateOperation]`
- `inject_from_match` return type widened to
`tuple[InjectorEmission, ...]`
- `__all__` exports `InjectorEmission`
- Documentation comment names ADR-0170 §"Implementation outline"
### `generate/math_candidate_graph.py` (admissibility dispatch)
The per-statement admission loop now dispatches admissibility on the
concrete candidate type:
if isinstance(c, CandidateInitial):
if _initial_admissible(c): admitted.append(c)
elif isinstance(c, CandidateOperation):
if roundtrip_admissible(c): admitted.append(c)
No new admission semantics — each type is gated by the predicate it was
already gated by elsewhere in the codebase. The dispatch unifies the
injector path with the parser path.
### `tests/test_adr_0170_w1_injector_type_widening.py` (new)
- Pin: `InjectorEmission` union members are exactly the two candidate types
- Pin: `inject_from_match` return type is widened
- Pin: `inject_discrete_count_statement` still emits CandidateInitial (W1
is type-level only)
- Hazard pin: case 0050 remains refused
- Hazard pin: unparseable-verb refusal path (#359) unchanged
- Anti-regression: canonical DCS narrow-form extraction still works
## Test plan
- tests/test_adr_0170_w1_injector_type_widening.py: 6 passed (new)
- tests/test_adr_0163_d2_discrete_count_injection.py: 21 passed
(existing D.2 v1 injector regression)
- tests/test_brief_11b_audit_artifact.py + step2_lexicon +
recognizer_skip_wrong_zero + brief_11_audit: 55 passed
- tests/test_candidate_graph_recognizer_wiring.py: 7 passed
- tests/test_candidate_domain_partition.py: 5 passed
- tests/test_adr_0131_G2_comparatives + G4 + G5 + S1_rate_events:
130 passed
- Total: 225 passed
- evals/gsm8k_math/train_sample/v1: counts=correct=3 refused=47 wrong=0
(unchanged; verified no behavioral regression)
## Hard invariants
- `wrong == 0` preserved (admissibility dispatch is type-aware but
semantically identical to the parser path's gating)
- ADR-0166: no new eval lanes
- No teaching-store / pack mutation
- Five-layer wrong=0 safety net (ADR-0163.D.2) intact
- Reader path unchanged
Three concrete cleanup items from the day's work, per the
cleanup-as-you-find memory principle.
## 1. Remove inject_rate_with_currency stub
PR #369 (A2 rate_with_currency) shipped a function that always returns
() with an extensive docstring documenting the Rate-not-in-SentenceChoice
schema gap. The function is dead at runtime — `_INJECTORS.get(category)`
returning None has the same downstream behavior as the function
returning (). The 16 tests pinned the empty-tuple return; the case-0050
hazard pin is duplicated in test_recognizer_skip_wrong_zero.py and
test_brief_11b_step2_lexicon.py.
The schema gap is now properly documented in ADR-0170 (PR #372). A
dispatch-table comment at the removal site retains the at-code pointer
to that ADR for anyone wiring a new injector.
Removed:
- `inject_rate_with_currency` function in generate/recognizer_anchor_inject.py
- Its `_INJECTORS` dispatch table entry
- Its `__all__` export
- tests/test_injector_rate_with_currency.py (371 lines, 16 tests)
## 2. Remove docs/handoff/GPT55-MOBILE-DISPATCH.md
Single-session travel-time scaffolding. The 5 tasks it named are
complete or superseded by ADR-0170's findings. Pure historical artifact.
## 3. Remove docs/handoff/WAVE-NEXT-INJECTORS.md
Superseded by docs/handoff/WAVE-NEXT-REVISED.md, which captures
everything load-bearing from the original brief in its A1–A4 findings
table. The "kept for history" justification didn't survive scrutiny:
the document was misframed (over-promised lift; misframed schema work
as injector work). Lessons captured in REVISED + ADR-0170.
Updated cross-references:
- WAVE-NEXT-REVISED.md: removed the "supersedes ... kept for history"
pointer; tightened cross-reference list
- ADR-0167-FOLLOWUPS.md §7: rewrote pointer to name ADR-0170 + REVISED
as the live plan rather than "the original is retained"
## Test plan
- 219 tests passed across G.2/G.4/G.5/S1/Brief 11/B1/B11A/wiring/partition/DCS-D.2
- evals/gsm8k_math/train_sample/v1/report.json untouched (regen
surfaces a separate stale-baseline test issue — out of cleanup scope)
- No runtime behavior change
## Net impact
- 5 files removed (~1200 lines)
- 1 file modified for explanatory comment (~30 lines)
- 2 doc files updated to remove dangling cross-references
- 0 behavioral change
Wave-Next A2 brief outcome: the Rate type (ADR-0122) DOES structurally
model a per-unit rate, but it is not a member of the per-sentence
injector contract's SentenceChoice union (CandidateInitial |
CandidateOperation). The injector therefore returns () and documents
the schema gap inline plus in audit_brief_11.md.
Lift count: 0 (expected — the brief explicitly anticipates this
outcome when the schema decision is "no"). Documenting the gap is
the deliverable.
- generate/recognizer_anchor_inject.py: new inject_rate_with_currency
+ dispatch-table entry routing ShapeCategory.RATE_WITH_CURRENCY.
- tests/test_injector_rate_with_currency.py: 16 tests pinning schema
evidence, schema refusal, dispatch wiring, case 0050 hazard,
determinism, and wrong=0 invariant.
- evals/gsm8k_math/train_sample/v1/audit_brief_11.md: appended
Wave-Next A2 section documenting the schema decision, eval delta
(3/0/47 unchanged), case 0050 hazard verification, and the
CandidateRate follow-up sequencing.
Case 0050 hazard pin: sentence 0 ("Mark does a gig every other day
for 2 weeks.") carries no currency symbol — rate_with_currency
never matches it; case stays refused at sentence_index=0.
First PR plumbing recognizer parsed_anchors into the candidate-graph as
typed CandidateInitial primitives. Scope limited to discrete_count_statement;
other five round-2 categories route to the round-2 skip-only fallback until
follow-up D.2.x PRs.
Five-layer wrong=0 safety net:
1. Matcher narrowness — _try_extract_discrete_count_anchor refuses on any
ambiguity (multi-subject, pronoun subject, non-possession verb,
multi-count, clause-split, unobserved counted_noun, unobserved
count_kind).
2. Extraction correctness — refusal-preferring; populated parsed_anchors
only when ALL narrowness rules hold.
3. Injection correctness — _initial_admissible gates every constructed
CandidateInitial; failure to ground returns () (under-admit).
4. Replay gate — propose-time admissibility_replay_gate auto-rejects any
matcher change that would lift GSM8K wrong count.
5. Multi-branch decision rule — injected candidate disagreeing with
another branch triggers refuse path.
Re-baseline (GSM8K train_sample v1):
- Old (#309 alone): correct=3 refused=47 wrong=0
- New (#309 + D.2 v1): correct=3 refused=47 wrong=0
- Empirical lift in v1 = 0 cases; framework operational. No GSM8K
train_sample case has a discrete_count statement that simultaneously
meets all narrowness rules AND is missed by the existing parser.
Bottleneck moves to other recognizer categories (D.2.2+).
Validation:
- tests/test_adr_0163_d2_discrete_count_injection.py: 34 passed
- tests/test_recognizer_match.py + test_candidate_graph_recognizer_wiring
+ test_admissibility_replay_gate: 27 passed
- adr_0131_* (G1..G5 + S1 wrong=0 invariant): 222 passed / 2 pre-existing
report-comparison failures / 3 skipped — byte-identical to pre-D.2
- Solver code: unchanged
Operator caveat: round-1's ratified discrete_count_statement spec is
unchanged. Matcher behavior on the spec's canonical_pattern has been
extended from detection-only to populated parsed_anchors. Re-ratification
is not required; if policy requires it on matcher-behavior changes, the
registry digest provides byte-stable provenance.
Shay