docs(adr-0244-d4): RATIFIED — ADR-0244 + ADR-0245 Proposed→Accepted (Joshua Shay)
Governance flip carrying Joshua Shay's ratification provenance inline (ruling 2026-07-17: "Ratify both"). Anti-self-Accept guard satisfied — status flips are authorized by explicit human ruling, not self-issued. - ADR-0245 → **Accepted** (clean): mechanical-sympathy + semantic-rigor §3 gate green — parity, f32 467× speedup, 0-LAPACK-on-repeat, collision-resistance. - ADR-0244 → **Accepted as an implemented mechanism** with a RATIFIED live-activation limitation: identity_wave_gate stays default-off and live activation is NOT authorized. Acceptance covers the operator-preservation manifold, fail-closed gate capability, γ_id calibration, telemetry, and lifecycle contracts — not a production flip. The Phase-3 calibration explicitly did NOT authorize activation (benign traffic not separable at the nominal frame; best balanced error 0.346). Activation is blocked pending a separately ratified ADR-0246 (induced action, lawful stabilizer, path integrity, semantic-frame discrimination) + renewed discrimination evidence + acceptable benign refusal rate + explicit human ratification. Governance additions (per the ruling): both ADR status lines carry "Accepted — ratified by Joshua Shay … acceptance-packet" (provenance-guard format); ADR-0244 header carries the Operational-status limitation paragraph + a machine-readable identity_wave_gate: ledger block (implementation: accepted / live_activation: not_authorized / default: off); both packet §8 RULING RECORDs RATIFIED with the "not safe-to-activate" caveat prominent. Plan doc Phase 6 → DONE. [Verification]: smoke 176 passed; provenance/ADR pins + all ADR-0244/0245 tests 503 passed (both-Accepted-with-provenance format enforced). Docs-only.
This commit is contained in:
Shay
parent
d459cfaf7c
commit
5027adf8cb
5 changed files with 28 additions and 11 deletions
|
|
@ -1,10 +1,26 @@
|
|||
# ADR-0244: Wave-Field Identity Manifold and Inalienable Geometric Alignment
|
||||
|
||||
**Status**: Proposed (R\&D ratification path: benchmark evidence \+ Joshua review)
|
||||
**Status**: **Accepted** — ratified by Joshua Shay on 2026-07-17 (D4 acceptance-packet `docs/audit/adr-0244-acceptance-packet-2026-07-17.md`). Accepted **as an implemented mechanism**; live gate activation LIMITED — see **Operational status** below.
|
||||
**Date**: 2026-07-17
|
||||
**Authors**: Joshua Shay \+ Multi-model R\&D
|
||||
**Traceability**: Notion R\&D (CORE Engineering Reference hub: Live-Entity Design Decisions, `core_HA` Patterns)
|
||||
**Related**: ADR-0003, ADR-0006, ADR-0010, ADR-0021, ADR-0028, ADR-0031, ADR-0035, ADR-0039, ADR-0238, ADR-0239, ADR-0241, ADR-0242, ADR-0243, **ADR-0245** (companion — mechanical-sympathy + semantic-rigor foundation), `core/physics/identity.py`, `algebra/cl41.py`
|
||||
**Related**: ADR-0003, ADR-0006, ADR-0010, ADR-0021, ADR-0028, ADR-0031, ADR-0035, ADR-0039, ADR-0238, ADR-0239, ADR-0241, ADR-0242, ADR-0243, **ADR-0245** (companion — mechanical-sympathy + semantic-rigor foundation), **ADR-0246** (activation prerequisite — induced identity action + path integrity), `core/physics/identity.py`, `algebra/cl41.py`
|
||||
|
||||
> **Operational status (ratified limitation, Joshua Shay 2026-07-17).** Acceptance covers the operator-preservation identity manifold, the fail-closed gate *capability*, the `γ_id` calibration record, telemetry, and the lifecycle contracts **as implemented** — it is **not** authorization to enable the live gate. `identity_wave_gate` remains **default-off** and live activation is **expressly NOT authorized**: current benign trajectories do not meet the frozen nominal-frame admission surface at an acceptable refusal rate (Phase-3 measured best balanced error **0.346**; the calibration explicitly did **not** authorize a production flip). Any future activation requires a **separately ratified ADR-0246** decision (induced identity action, lawful stabilizer `H_id`, path integrity, semantic-frame discrimination) **plus** renewed discrimination evidence, an acceptable benign refusal rate, and explicit human ratification. A reader seeing "Accepted" must not infer "safe to activate".
|
||||
>
|
||||
> ```yaml
|
||||
> identity_wave_gate:
|
||||
> implementation: accepted # ADR-0244, ratified 2026-07-17
|
||||
> live_activation: not_authorized
|
||||
> default: off
|
||||
> blocker:
|
||||
> - benign nominal-frame mismatch # Phase-3 best balanced error 0.346
|
||||
> - ADR-0246 induced action and path integrity
|
||||
> activation_requires:
|
||||
> - calibrated discrimination evidence
|
||||
> - acceptable benign refusal rate
|
||||
> - explicit human ratification
|
||||
> ```
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
|
|
@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
|
|||
# ADR-0245: CGA Unification — Mechanical Sympathy, Boundary Rigor, and Eigendecomposition Memoization
|
||||
|
||||
**Status**: Proposed (acceptance path: benchmark evidence \+ Joshua review)
|
||||
**Status**: **Accepted** — ratified by Joshua Shay on 2026-07-17 (D4 acceptance-packet `docs/audit/adr-0245-acceptance-packet-2026-07-17.md`; §3 gate green — parity, f32 467× speedup, 0-LAPACK-on-repeat, collision-resistance).
|
||||
**Date**: 2026-07-17
|
||||
**Authors**: Joshua Shay \+ Multi-model R\&D
|
||||
**Traceability**: Notion R\&D (CORE Engineering Reference hub: Live-Entity Design Decisions, `core_HA` Patterns)
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
|
|
@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
|
|||
|
||||
**Arc:** ADR-0244 Wave-Field Identity Manifold & Inalienable Geometric Alignment (D4 Phases 0–6), built on the ADR-0243 lifecycle + the ADR-0245 mechanical-sympathy foundation.
|
||||
**Evidence base:** `feat/adr-0244-d4 @ 8ef80daa` (Phases 0–5 pushed direct-to-`main` per your sole-worker authorization; Phase 6 = this packet + the ADR-0245 packet).
|
||||
**Status of ADR-0244:** **Proposed — submitted for your ruling.** The `Proposed → Accepted` flip is a **separate one-line governance commit** carrying your ratification provenance inline (anti-self-Accept guard, `tests/test_adr_0241_governance_p12.py::test_adrs_accepted_with_recorded_ruling_provenance`). **I have NOT flipped it** — §8 is PENDING. See §5 for the one caveat that shapes the ruling.
|
||||
**Status of ADR-0244:** **Accepted (with a ratified live-activation limitation)** — ratified by Joshua Shay on 2026-07-17. Accepted as an implemented mechanism; `identity_wave_gate` stays **default-off** and live activation is **NOT authorized** pending ADR-0246. §8 is RATIFIED; see §5 for the caveat that shaped the ruling.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -63,4 +63,4 @@ So the ruling is on the ADR **as a specification and a validated mechanism**, wi
|
|||
|
||||
## 8. RULING RECORD
|
||||
|
||||
**PENDING — awaiting Joshua Shay's ruling.** No status flip has been made; ADR-0244 remains **Proposed**.
|
||||
**RATIFIED — Joshua Shay, 2026-07-17.** ADR-0244 accepted **as an implemented mechanism** — the operator-preservation manifold, fail-closed gate capability, `γ_id` calibration record, telemetry, and lifecycle contracts — **not** as authorization to enable live identity enforcement. **The Phase-3 calibration explicitly did NOT authorize a production flip:** it measured that benign traffic is not separable at the frozen nominal frame (best balanced error 0.346). `identity_wave_gate` remains **default-off** and live activation is **NOT authorized**, blocked pending a **separately ratified ADR-0246** (induced identity action, lawful stabilizer `H_id`, path integrity, semantic-frame discrimination) **plus** renewed discrimination evidence, an acceptable benign refusal rate, and explicit human ratification. Status flipped `Proposed → Accepted` on 2026-07-17 with provenance inline (+ machine-readable `identity_wave_gate:` ledger block in the ADR header). "Accepted" here means implemented, **not** safe-to-activate.
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
|
|
@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
|
|||
|
||||
**Arc:** ADR-0245 CGA Unification: Mechanical Sympathy & Semantic Rigor — the foundation ADR-0244's identity gate sits on. Committed as a real companion ADR in D4 Phase 0; its D4 scope (§2.2 cast, §2.3 residual, §3 gate) closed across Phases 4–5.
|
||||
**Evidence base:** `feat/adr-0244-d4 @ 8ef80daa` (Phases 0–5 on `main`).
|
||||
**Status of ADR-0245:** **Proposed — submitted for your ruling.** The `Proposed → Accepted` flip is a **separate one-line governance commit** with your ratification provenance inline (anti-self-Accept guard). **I have NOT flipped it** — §8 is PENDING.
|
||||
**Status of ADR-0245:** **Accepted** — ratified by Joshua Shay on 2026-07-17. All four §3 legs green; no live-serving caveat. §8 is RATIFIED.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -48,4 +48,4 @@ Landed across D4 Phases 0 (commit), 4 (§2.2), 5a (§2.3), 5d (§3). Phase 5 gat
|
|||
|
||||
## 8. RULING RECORD
|
||||
|
||||
**PENDING — awaiting Joshua Shay's ruling.** No status flip has been made; ADR-0245 remains **Proposed**.
|
||||
**RATIFIED — Joshua Shay, 2026-07-17.** ADR-0245 accepted on its clean mechanical-sympathy + semantic-rigor evidence — all four §3 legs green (parity, f32 467× speedup, 0-LAPACK-on-repeat, collision-resistance), independent of the ADR-0244 identity gate. Status flipped `Proposed → Accepted` on 2026-07-17 with provenance inline.
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
|
|
@ -187,8 +187,8 @@ Dependencies: `0 → {1, 4}` · `1 → 2 → 3` · `5 after 0` · `6 last`. Each
|
|||
**Steps:** D10-pattern acceptance packets for **both** ADRs; **user-ratified** Proposed→Accepted flips (provenance guard: inline `**Accepted** — ratified by Joshua Shay <date>` + packet `## 8. RULING RECORD`); update memory; delete worktree + branch (merge-then-cleanup).
|
||||
**Acceptance:** both packets complete; provenance-guard green; status flips only on explicit user ratification; worktree/branch swept.
|
||||
**Gate:** smoke + provenance/ADR pins.
|
||||
**Status:** ◐ PACKETS DELIVERED — **awaiting Joshua's ratification** for the two Proposed→Accepted flips (the one step I cannot self-authorize).
|
||||
**Resume notes:** Both D10 acceptance packets written and pushed: `docs/audit/adr-0244-acceptance-packet-2026-07-17.md` + `docs/audit/adr-0245-acceptance-packet-2026-07-17.md` — evidence dossiers, §8 RULING RECORD **PENDING**, both ADR status lines still **Proposed** (anti-self-Accept guard `test_adr_0241_governance_p12` stays green). The ADR-0244 packet §5 foregrounds the one caveat shaping the ruling: **the identity wave-gate is BUILT + VALIDATED but NOT live** (`identity_wave_gate=False`; Phase-3 live-non-separation, best balanced error 0.346) — validated scaffolding pending ADR-0246. **Remaining (human-gated):** on Joshua's explicit "ratify", make ONE governance commit flipping both `**Status**: Proposed → **Accepted** — ratified by Joshua Shay <date>`, fill both §8 RULING RECORDs, then final cleanup (delete `feat/adr-0244-d4` branch + this worktree — merge-then-cleanup). Until then the arc is **build-complete, ratification-pending**.
|
||||
**Status:** ✅ DONE — **RATIFIED by Joshua Shay 2026-07-17.** Both ADRs flipped Proposed→Accepted with provenance inline; both packet §8 RULING RECORDs filled.
|
||||
**Resume notes:** Joshua ruled **Ratify both** (via the D4 ruling): **ADR-0245 Accepted** cleanly (four §3 legs green); **ADR-0244 Accepted as an implemented mechanism with a ratified live-activation limitation** — `identity_wave_gate` stays **default-off** and live activation is **NOT authorized** pending a separately-ratified **ADR-0246** (induced action, lawful stabilizer, path integrity, semantic-frame discrimination) + renewed discrimination evidence + acceptable benign refusal rate + explicit human ratification. Governance additions landed: both ADR status lines carry `Accepted — ratified by Joshua Shay ... acceptance-packet` (provenance-guard format); ADR-0244 header carries the **Operational status** limitation paragraph + a machine-readable `identity_wave_gate:` ledger block (`implementation: accepted / live_activation: not_authorized / default: off`); packets say prominently that calibration did **not** authorize a production flip. Gate: smoke 176 + provenance/ADR pins green (both-Accepted-with-provenance). **Final janitorial step (from the MAIN checkout — cannot self-remove this cwd):** `git worktree remove` + `git branch -d feat/adr-0244-d4` (content is all on `main`). Arc is **COMPLETE**.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -237,6 +237,7 @@ Forward-looking mechanical-sympathy items from the critique — a separate optim
|
|||
- **2026-07-17** — **Phase 3 landed `f3702ad4` → calibration built + certified; live flag flip BLOCKED by empirical non-separation.** `evals/adr_0244_gamma_calibration/` + `tests/test_adr_0244_gamma_calibration.py` (9 tests). The bracketed-local Fibonacci search certifies `γ* = 0.2126624458513829` (cert `0079b5f201fbf616…`) separating the geometric attack signal; pinned as `identity._WAVE_LEAKAGE_BOUND` and **decoupled the wave path from `alignment_threshold`**. **Then measured the crux the whole arc deferred:** real benign live turns do NOT preserve `span(e1,e2,e3)` — leakage 0.14–0.81 (mean 0.55), self-align to −0.52, **12/13 benign false-refused at γ***, best-achievable balanced error **0.346**. So the calibration certifies `flag_flip_authorized=False`; **`identity_wave_gate` stays OFF**. Root cause: the shipped value axes are *nominal basis vectors, not dynamically-preserved eigenmodes* — no dynamical anchoring in the current field evolution; the fix is the **ADR-0246 induced-action programme** (brief already merged). The wave gate is validated, correctly-off scaffolding. A slow drift-guard test canaries any future change that starts preserving identity. Gate: smoke 176 + fast lane + 59 targeted (incl. wave/ablation/runtime unchanged). Next: Phase 4 (§2.5 cast) — independent of 1–3.
|
||||
- **2026-07-17** — **Phase 4 landed `918aa843` → §2.5 / 0245 §2.2 serving cast COMPLETE.** `serving_cast(psi_steady, certificate, verdict) → ServingState` + `ServingCastError` in `core/physics/cognitive_lifecycle.py`; `tests/test_adr_0244_serving_cast.py` (10 tests). The single explicit, fail-closed f64→f32 down-cast at the certified egress: casts only a validated / digest-matched / admitted state; precision-checks the f32 result and fails closed on a cliff (`f32_precision_insufficient`); keeps f64 as source of truth (digest chain untouched) and carries audit provenance. Measured `cast_error ≈ 1.2e-8`. Off-serve (A-04 guard green). Gate: smoke 176 + fast lane + 10 targeted. Next: Phase 5 (§2.7 residual + §2.9 allocator + §2.10 audit + 0245 §3 gate).
|
||||
- **2026-07-17** — **Phase 5 landed (5a–5d) → all D4 build phases COMPLETE.** Four gated sub-commits closing the semantic-rigor + mechanical-sympathy tail. **5a §2.7** (`5c69b741`): four residual content-ids widened to full 256-bit digests (schema/plan_preflight/articulation_quality — dropped `default=str` — + holographic_vault `_default_mode_id` with explicit LE byte-order); 334 contemplation/vault tests green. **5b §2.9** (`4a550c1d`): recall order-independence **proven** (Gram lstsq onto span is permutation-invariant to ~1e-15; allocator ordinal-reconstructible) — wiring would be a category mismatch. **5c §2.10** (`eacea087`): the "reduce harmonic phase-locking" claim pinned (golden-ratio density, no `BB`/`AAA`, aperiodicity), not just structure. **5d §3** (`b31d6fde`): ADR-0245 §3 gate closed — Rust-guarded f32 **≥10× speedup** (measured **467×**) + `_content_id` collision-resistance + coverage manifest. Built `core_rs` locally to run the speedup + ~126 Rust-parity tests (all green; not committed). Gate: smoke 176 + fast lane + 43 targeted. **Next: Phase 6 (close-out) — the only remaining work; all §-mechanisms built.**
|
||||
- **2026-07-17** — **Phase 6 → ARC RATIFIED & COMPLETE.** Both D10 acceptance packets delivered (`d459cfaf`); Joshua ruled **Ratify both**. Governance flip commit: **ADR-0245 → Accepted** (clean §3 gate); **ADR-0244 → Accepted as an implemented mechanism** with a ratified **live-activation limitation** — `identity_wave_gate` stays default-off, live activation NOT authorized pending **ADR-0246** (induced action, lawful stabilizer, path integrity, semantic-frame discrimination) + renewed discrimination evidence + acceptable benign refusal rate + explicit human ratification. Both status lines carry `Accepted — ratified by Joshua Shay 2026-07-17 (… acceptance-packet …)` (provenance-guard format); ADR-0244 header carries the Operational-status paragraph + a machine-readable `identity_wave_gate:` ledger block; both packet §8s RATIFIED. Gate: smoke 176 + provenance/ADR pins green. **Remaining = janitorial only:** worktree/branch sweep from the MAIN checkout (this session is inside the worktree, cannot self-remove cwd). **The ADR-0244 D4 arc is complete.**
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -250,8 +251,8 @@ Forward-looking mechanical-sympathy items from the critique — a separate optim
|
|||
| 3 | §2.4 γ_id calibration (certified; **live flip BLOCKED — flag stays OFF**) | ✅ DONE | `f3702ad4` |
|
||||
| 4 | §2.5 / 0245 §2.2 serving-boundary cast | ✅ DONE | `918aa843` |
|
||||
| 5 | §2.7 residual + §2.9 wiring + §2.10 audit + 0245 §3 gate | ✅ DONE | `5c69b741`+`4a550c1d`+`eacea087`+`b31d6fde` |
|
||||
| 6 | Close-out (2 acceptance packets + 2 ratified flips) | ◐ PACKETS DELIVERED — awaiting Joshua's ratification | packets pushed |
|
||||
| 6 | Close-out (2 acceptance packets + 2 ratified flips) | ✅ DONE — **RATIFIED** (Joshua Shay 2026-07-17) | `d69a70e1` |
|
||||
|
||||
**▶ NEXT: Joshua's ratification ruling.** All build phases (0–5) are complete — ADR-0244 §2.1–2.10 and ADR-0245 §2.1–2.4 + §3 are built/proven/audited, every gate green. Both D10 acceptance packets are delivered (`docs/audit/adr-024{4,5}-acceptance-packet-2026-07-17.md`, §8 PENDING). **The only remaining step is the human ratification gate** — I cannot self-authorize the Proposed→Accepted flips (anti-self-Accept guard). On Joshua's explicit "ratify", one governance commit flips both statuses with inline `— ratified by Joshua Shay <date>` provenance + fills the §8 RULING RECORDs, then the worktree/branch are swept. **Standing caveat in both packets:** `identity_wave_gate` stays OFF (Phase-3 live-non-separation) — the identity gate is validated scaffolding, not a live gate, pending ADR-0246.
|
||||
**▶ ARC COMPLETE — RATIFIED 2026-07-17.** All build phases (0–5) done and both ADRs **Accepted** (Joshua Shay, provenance inline): ADR-0245 clean; **ADR-0244 accepted as an implemented mechanism with a ratified live-activation limitation** (`identity_wave_gate` default-off, live activation NOT authorized pending ADR-0246). Every gate green. **Only janitorial step left:** worktree/branch sweep — must run from the MAIN checkout since this session is *inside* the worktree (`git worktree remove <path>` + `git branch -d feat/adr-0244-d4`; content is all on `main`). The follow-on programme is **ADR-0246** (induced identity action / path integrity) — the prerequisite for ever activating the live identity gate.
|
||||
|
||||
**Phase 3 headline for resumers:** the γ_id calibration machinery is built + certified, but the empirical finding is that **the live serving flag cannot honestly be flipped on** — real benign traffic doesn't preserve the nominal identity subspace (best balanced error 0.346), so the gate would mass-refuse. `identity_wave_gate` stays OFF; the live gate awaits the ADR-0246 induced-action work. This is a **true architectural-gap discovery**, faithfully honoring the plan's conditional ("flip *once evidenced*"), not a deviation.
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
Loading…
Reference in a new issue