{
  "after_status": "speculative",
  "authority_path": [
    "demos.proof_carrying_promotion.authority.validate_payload",
    "teaching.proof_promotion.certify_promotion",
    "vault.store.VaultStore.apply_certified_promotion",
    "generate.proof_chain.certificate.verify_certificate(expected_engine_pin)"
  ],
  "before_status": "speculative",
  "certificate_digest": "cb81eb9ceb16a11c5fdeca7af6bb4c317d3449e054bbcf6c169afcfbd24f2129",
  "claim_entry_id": "claim-q",
  "claim_entry_index": 2,
  "decision_reason": "certificate_replay_failed",
  "engine_pin": "97a230949016e38d5e3f37a69e4245b320575ee70e5af92ff7607f7b05f74b5f",
  "premise_entry_ids": [
    "premise-p",
    "premise-p-implies-q"
  ],
  "premise_entry_indices": [
    0,
    1
  ],
  "promoted": false,
  "proposer_ignored_fields": [
    "proof"
  ],
  "refusal_reason": "certificate_replay_failed",
  "request_id": "demo-pccp-e1",
  "scenario_id": "tampered-certificate-refuses",
  "status": "refused",
  "tool": "proof_carrying_coherence_promotion",
  "trace_hash": "0bc466c3cb78d8832beecf7fe874f47c44fdbba24f056e58bfde90d39d583411",
  "trace_summary": {
    "apply_attempted": true,
    "apply_reason": "certificate_replay_failed",
    "arena_entry_count": 3,
    "authority_evaluated": true,
    "certify_certificate_digest": "1dfd9a393bd4fc32e6d62835f284c6c56e64c3ced87062df23471dc7a0a5305a",
    "certify_promoted": true,
    "certify_reason": "promoted_entailed_from_coherent_premises",
    "engine_decision": "entailed",
    "engine_reason": "tautological_implication",
    "proposer_fields_ignored": [
      "proof"
    ],
    "sabotage_applied": [
      "tamper_claim_form"
    ]
  }
}
